2 ms·
I've read this article before and it sounds like the author is motivated by some sort of weird culture war. For instance: Xenophon (Xen. Lac. 2.12-14) disagree
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
I've read this article before and it sounds like the author is motivated by some sort of weird culture war. For instance:
Xenophon (Xen. Lac. 2.12-14) disagrees and argues that these relationships were not sexual. Xenophon has the benefit of proximity (writing 500 years before Plutarch), but at the same time openly admits that it was widely believed that these relationships were sexual, and Xenophon is expressly writing in defense of Spartan customs. Even if Xenophon is correct about the ideal nature of these relationships, we have to assume he wouldn’t tell us about occasions where that ideal was broken.
Well, if Xenophon is wrting in defense of Sparta and Plutarch is writing after 500 years, we should at the very least consider the two sources equally unreliable, rather than pick a side.
It's a great idea to dispell the myths, modern and ancient, that surround the Spartans, but I think this is going all the way to the other end and it ends up with an also distorted image of ancient Sparta (Lacaedemon).