4 ms·
> the spirit of open source This is not a thing that exists. What we have are licenses, not ghosts.
by pessimizer 6y ago
> the spirit of open source
This is not a thing that exists. What we have are licenses, not ghosts.
- donmcronald 6y agoThe spirit of collaboration and working for a common good absolutely used to exist. Many of the internet's core protocols were built with the spirit of cooperation weren't they? Think about email and the value it adds to the world. Would we ever get the protocols needed to create email if we started right now today? Not a chance. IMO the previous generation(s) of tech people were way better than what we have today. They were interested in and enthusiastic about building awesome tech / products. Today the only thing anyone with influence is interested in building is a company that can IPO and make them a billionaire.
- pessimizer 6y ago> The spirit of collaboration and working for a common good absolutely used to exist. That currently still exists. It has nothing in particular to do with software, though. People collaborate, academics collaborate. Are you telling me that massive corporations were part of this back in the good old days, just helping people for the fun of it?
- 838812052807016 6y agoI wonder what would happen if there was a law which forbade corporations from pursuing anything going against the common good? Or a law which only allowed companies to pursue the common good?
- oflanac52 6y agoThat would probably mean, for some, shutting down entire industries i.e. smoking, gambling..
- stonesweep 6y ago>> the spirit of open source > This is not a thing that exists. What we have are licenses, not ghosts. Before we had open source, we released software as public domain. The spirit existed before the trademark phrase was even invented and long after people were already giving away their software for free because of the spirit of the community. We used to go to computer swap meets in fairgrounds buildings and buy boxes of floppy disks with random software on them just to see what was around, people uploaded it to BBSes and shared the work they did - we had Donationware, Shareware, Postcardware (a personal favorite), Beerware and everything in between which was 100% based on the spirit of the community. We just called most of it Freeware. We have licenses because the spirit was abused.
- pessimizer 6y agoYou're projecting your good feelings about collaborating with other computer hobbyists onto a set of software licenses applied to extremely corporate, not-hobbyist software. And additionally complaining that the "abuse" of these licenses by massive corporations are keeping the authors of this software from getting rich. If you're doing this for the pure joy of programming, you're already rich in spirit - Amazon taking your software and using it is actually a tribute.
- stonesweep 6y agoI really don't think my comment said anything about people getting rich; I myself was involved in one report of GPL abuse to the EFF on behalf of Busybox, yet another early 2000s device created by 2 people in their bedroom who simply decided the license didn't apply and releasing the source code was not their responsibility - Busybox had a "Hall of Shame" web page up back then, you can still see it in the Internet Archive. It was pretty rampant, the sharks saw "free code" in the water and simply had the attitude "so, sue me and prove it in court" about early GPL. It took us collectively a decade or more to actual make things like the GPL enforced in courts of law, the dawn of our digital age started with bad guys trying to exploit the good guys who gave away code. My thought is that you're focusing on the "gratis" part of FOSS, whereas I'm over here in the "libre" side of the house - as a (now) Linux systems guy, when (foo) doesn't work I reach and go down that rabbit hole of code until I figure out what's wrong and we fix things - that is what Open Source is about to me, it has no underpinnings of monetary compensation, it's all about two (sic) people who don't know each other being able to randomly see each other's code to solve the problem at hand (and then possibly submit fixes, bug reports, etc.). I've traced tons of open source software to solve problems both personally and professionally. Getting paid for open source is a relatively new thing in my life timeline, I don't honestly subscribe to that idea but to each their own. I do, however, recognize the time effort and energy it takes to create said software, so I personally take these tech dollars I make at $job and donate to a lot of open source initiatives, coders and even public radio stations bringing me "free" music. There's no such thing as a free lunch as a wise sci-fi author once wrote.