3 ms·
Is there a single case of someone misusing an open source license and being assigned significant damages as a result in a court? I know Google v Oracle is stil
by endisneigh 6y ago
Is there a single case of someone misusing an open source license and being assigned significant damages as a result in a court?
I know Google v Oracle is still ongoing but other than that?
Unless there’s a whistleblower in your organization or your product itself is open source it seems impossible to identify, let alone litigate.
- speeder 6y agoI don't remember if any damages were awarded, but I do remember that the infringing software were all removed from the market when SCUMMVM sued Atari for releasing Nintendo Wii games using their game engine without sharing anything at all. Atari of course got stuck in a bad situation then, if they complied with GPL they would breach Nintendo NDA, so their choice was just stop selling the products in question entirely, so I must assume the lost sales were smaller than the potential damage if they were found guilty of copyright infringement.
- lmm 6y agoThey settled before trial; one of the settlement terms was Atari donating a certain amount of money to a specified to an open-source foundation.
- makk 6y agoIn an acquisition, the acquirer will have full access to source code and may look for open source violations during technical due diligence. They may then use any violations to squeeze the valuation and/or demand remediation, either of which is a real cost to the company being acquired. It’s not in court, but is is a routine situation that does not require a whistleblower, where the violations are relatively easy to identify.
- wongarsu 6y agoCisco/Linksys had to make available the source code that became the basis for a whole ecosystem of open router software that offers enterprise features on much cheaper devices. Cisco also paid an undisclosed amount to FSF. Similar things have also happened to other router manufacturers. Westinghouse had to pay the SFC $90k for shipping BusyBox without observing the license. Most cases that are pursued are settled out of court though.
- wooptoo 6y agoYes, look up Eben Moglen's work for the FSF. He has defended GPL in court many times.