4 ms·
>My point was, the concept of layers of indirection making perpetrating evil/immoral acts easier is a well-recognized one It seems that you are again assuming
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
>My point was, the concept of layers of indirection making perpetrating evil/immoral acts easier is a well-recognized one
It seems that you are again assuming that drone strikes are evil immoral acts.
Most people view civilian casualties in war as a trolley car problem, (e.g. a necessary evil in an overall moral action)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kaba0 6y agoWhy is there war in the first place? Also, it is a created trolley car problem not the trolley car problem. And creating such a situation instead of coming across it is definitely morally evil.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoHow is it a new trolly problem? Technology may have changed, but I don't see how that changes the morality. If it is moral to minimize the deaths by pulling a lever, shouldn't it also be moral to invent the lever? Someone can certainly argue that drone strikes are not always an effective way to save lives, but if they are, I don't see an argument that makes them evil.
- olyjohn 6y agoDo most people really think that? I kind of doubt it.
- s1artibartfast 6y agohere is some survey data from 2015 showing that the majory approves of drone strikes with a 58 to 35 approval. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2015/05/28/public-continues-to-back-u-s-drone-attacks/ https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2015/05/28/public-conti...
- c1ccccc1 6y agoI don't really care what most people think. If I chose my beliefs based solely on what most people thought, I would be guilty of committing the bandwagon fallacy. So don't hide behind "most people". What do you think about this issue? My own personal view is this: The Geneva convention forbids the killing and torture of non-combatants. The Geneva convention exists for a reason: without it, war would be more brutal and kill many more innocent people. Sure, it's easier to destroy the enemy if you don't worry too much about civilian casualties. But if both sides reason that way, the advantage to each cancels out, and the net outcome is just more civilian deaths. It's cheap to say "oh it's a trolley problem" when we're talking about killing some innocent people thousands of miles away in order to take out an enemy general. Imagine if the civilians killed by each drone strike were all Americans. Want to kill that enemy commander? It'll cost you 5 American lives. Same logic from a trolley problem standpoint, but I expect you'd get some very different results on your poll.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think that the killing of civilians is undesirable, but clearly moral under the right conditions. The proposition is not weather one should "worry too much about civilian casualties" but if they are morally justifiable at all. Do you really hold that that it isn't acceptable to kill 1 non-combatant to save a greater number of non-combatants at a future date? You can change the conditions or description, but it is still a trolly problem.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt is an iterated trolley problem. Imagine the "default" track splitting into a hundred million tracks, which all cross and merge into and separate from each other. It's such a maze that nobody can really tell what path the trolley will take once it enters a particular track. There's a couple thousand people in blue shirts tied down to a single-digit number of those tracks. A hundred-million-way split is essentially a bump in the main track, which means the trolley will randomly pick one of the hundred million of directions. The service track (which splits off the main track before the hundred-million split) has a couple redshirts tied to it, plus 50 yellow-shirts per each redshirt. If you flip the switch, the trolley is sure to travel down the service track. Additionally, the rules of iterating the problem are: if you don't flip a switch, there's a small chance the game ends. If you do flip a switch, the game will always continue, and there's a small chance that next round, more blueshirts will be tied to some of the hundred million tracks, and a small chance that the trolley will go down the main track regardless of your choice. What do you choose? The US government answer is essentially to jam the switch in the "to service track position", because "fuck it, we don't care about non-blue shirts, and besides, the trolley company pays us to make sure the trolleys keep going".