3 ms·
> it’s tampons vs a reusable reply device that lasts forever ... but you have to wash it with water and cleaning products, and possibly carry around dirty. Do
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
> it’s tampons vs a reusable reply device that lasts forever
... but you have to wash it with water and cleaning products, and possibly carry around dirty.
Does it still come ahead? Probably. I don't know. We had this conversation with my wife around cups and reusable pads, and we're still not 100% sure which is the most environmental-friendly option.
I raise this as a general point: I've never seen any good resources to help people estimate full environmental impact of disposable vs. reusable things, accounting both the difference of {emissions, energy, water, plastics} used in manufacturing of disposable vs. reusable item, and then the difference of those in ongoing maintenance.
It's important we learn to figure this out as consumers, because I fear otherwise our civilization will die on lots of bad decisions driven by not knowing the total costs. Things like not realizing you'll have to use a reusable bag a couple thousand times before you're ahead energy-wise over single-use plastic bags (the correct answer here being, treat your reusable bag with respect, and find other ways to reduce packaging churn - otherwise you'll likely lose or destroy your eco bag before you achieve a net environmental win).
(On that note, I recommend watching videos about how things are made - it's a good way to calibrate your sense of how much plastic actually goes into a thing. In case of e.g. disposable trash bags, my brain can't really internalize information like "10 microns thick", but actually seeing the process of making a big roll of plastic film and turning it into unending stream of bags made the relative amount of material involved intuitively comprehensible. Also, videos of industrial machines are relaxing to watch.)
- DanBC 6y ago> I raise this as a general point: I've never seen any good resources to help people estimate full environmental impact of disposable vs. reusable things, accounting both the difference of {emissions, energy, water, plastics} used in manufacturing of disposable vs. reusable item, and then the difference of those in ongoing maintenance. It's a very good point. This kind of stuff is impossible for the lay person to estimate. Here's one example for nappies. It's 37 pages long. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/291130/scho0808boir-e-e.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- azornathogron 6y ago> It's important we learn to figure this out as consumers, because I fear otherwise our civilization will die on lots of bad decisions driven by not knowing the total costs I don't think it is feasible to figure these things out as a consumer in any way that scales to the range of products that we use, changes in manufacturing and materials over time, and the available attention that each consumer can dedicate to the problem. I would like to see more externalities incorporated into the price of goods, via taxes or other market intervention. Of course, that's hideously difficult as well, but I feel it's closer to being feasible than consumers estimating externalities of each product themselves. (Probably we need both approaches, and more besides.) Edit: a good thing about incorporating externalities into prices is that to a large extent it should naturally aggregate through the whole production/supply chain. If plastic is a problem and you tax plastic feed-stock (probably someone who knows about plastic manufacture would have a better suggestion, sorry), then that naturally will be incorporated into the price of everything made out of plastic, proportionately to the amount of plastic the thing required.