5 ms·
>>does the 3.5" form factor have something to do with the limitations of spinning rust tech? There are issues. As the platters get bigger they get wobbly, mor
by sandworm101 6y ago
>>does the 3.5" form factor have something to do with the limitations of spinning rust tech?
There are issues. As the platters get bigger they get wobbly, more probe to vibrations. The difference in platter speed between the inner and outer 'rings' of data also increases. There is no hard reason for 3.5 over 4.5 or 4.8 inches, but the advantages of going bigger do not outweigh the practicalities of trying to push a new form factor for a commodity product.
>> spinning rust
This is a common refrain, but seagate and the others are proving that HDD tech is not 'rusting'. With lower per-TB costs, and phenomenal reliability numbers (<1% chance of failure per year) HDDs are going to be around for a while. Outside of the datacenter, most users are more limited by more by network speeds than storage speeds.
- johnsoft 6y agoOther issues with larger platters: - more power usage - more heat - more noise Datacenters in particular are not interested in increasing heat or power usage. 5.25" hard drives used to be common, but were phased out sometime around Y2K.
- sennight 6y ago>> spinning rust > This is a common refrain, but seagate and the others are proving that HDD tech is not 'rusting'. It is a common refrain because disk platters were originally coated with iron oxide, and iron oxide is rust. It isn't a value judgement.
- matmatmatmat 6y agoIsn't it a little hard to accept that it isn't a value judgement when we generally have a lower value of things that have rusted? I think the original comparison to 'spinning rust' was tongue-in-cheek and not meant to be taken so-very-seriously, but it's kind of taken on a life of its own and, personally, I feel that it's gone a bit far and undeservedly undervalues hard drives.
- monocasa 6y agoIt's a term from an era where HDDs were the best way to bulk store data (except maybe tape in some applications, which where also iron oxide). I think you're reading too much into it.
- sennight 6y agoThe earliest use I could find is more inline with my observations of matter-of-fact usage than a joke taken too far: "Logically, if you utilize a 'memory' disk you are ridding yourself of the physical limitations of disk drive technology — basically trading in the spinning rust. In a disk drive, you are battling physics to squeeze more performance out of your array; there are certain physical properties that just can’t be altered on a whim." - 2004 https://web.archive.org/web/20041018152106/http://www.dba-oracle.com/art_dbazine_ault_ssd.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20041018152106/http://www.dba-or... As to the question of its present use as a method to hurt the feelings of hard drives and hard drive cognoscenti... I dunno.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- at_a_remove 6y agoI think the "rust" comes not from the fact that the technology is aging, but that we're dealing with metal oxides. Tapes, then, are spooled rust.