7 ms·
Smart METL airless metal bike tires use a “shape memory alloy” for deformation
- mc32 6y agoWhat happens when you go over sand or mud? Do things get trapped in there? Is it like a mix-master with thick dough and it gets all clogged up and you better wash it before lumpy things harden?
- c0nsumer 6y agoHeck, it'd be terrible the moment some dirt or mud pushes through and makes the wheel heavy on one side.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThese look like they'd be full of sand and rocks rattling around really fast.
- senectus1 6y agonot only that but ruin your rims when you hit a kerb or something. Also I'd be really concerned about how much grip it'd retain on a sandy concrete corner..
- meepmorp 6y agoThe article specifically mentions that the exterior will be wrapped in some rubbery material, with the very silly name polyurethanium.
- dasKrokodil 6y agoI usually try to stay open-minded towards any new inventions, but there have been sooo many failed attempts at replacing pneumatic rubber tires that I'm very skeptical whenever a new one is made. Best of luck to them, but I'm not holding my breath.
- 0_____0 6y agoThe bicycle itself is highly resistant to change as well. The overall concept basically hasn't changed for over a hundred years. Just small tweaks here and there.
- fanf2 6y agoThat’s mostly because the UCI has very strict rules about bicycle design. They banned recumbent bikes very early in the history of the sport; more recently they banned Graeme Obree’s “superman” position and other changes to the geometry of a normal upright. http://www.wolfgang-menn.de/superpos.htm http://www.wolfgang-menn.de/superpos.htm https://www.bikeradar.com/features/top-five-banned-tech-the-pros-cant-have-video-2/ https://www.bikeradar.com/features/top-five-banned-tech-the-... Check out Mike Burrows for some interesting bike designs. Check out the Battle Mountain speed records for what the highest performance bikes look like.
- analog31 6y agoOddly enough the human body also hasn't changed much. I've noticed this in some other technologies as well, such as the electric bass guitar, which I play. The electric bass settled on a fairly standardized geometry within a few years of it being invented. And while there have been some experiments and oddball instruments made over the years, the bread and butter instrument still looks pretty much like the original Fender bass with some tweaks. I've tried some of the modernizations, and they're physically awkward to play. There was a period of basses with sexy long necks and tiny little bodies, and they all suffered from "neck dive." Still, while I ride a bike that would not have looked out of place in 1890 when viewed from a distance, on closer inspection a lot of things have been improved. Perhaps most importantly, all of the newer materials are better, including high performance steel, aluminum, tires, and so forth. Hydroforming and carbon fiber layup have finally made it possible to experiment with more interesting frame shapes.
- jfengel 6y agoThere are a lot of alternative bike geometries that go a lot faster than the standard bike position. They reduce wind resistance and/or have better biomechanics. The lack of change has more to do with Union Cycliste Internationale rules than with optimization.
- awelkie 6y agoSo the article says the technology was developed at NASA and then licensed to Smart via the "Space Act Agreement". It looks like the company has three patents already, one of which[0] seems (to me, after a brief glance) to cover the essential innovation behind the metal tires. Can anyone tell me how the Space Act Agreement works? Does the innovation developed by NASA end up as a patent for a chosen company? Or do these three patents represent work done by the company and not at NASA? If it's the former, does NASA get any money from this agreement? [0]: https://patents.google.com/patent/US10449804B1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US10449804B1/en
- wil421 6y agoThe patent you linked to is under NASA and the NASA employees who came up with the tech. What do the company’s patents say and detail?
- awelkie 6y agoAh good catch! The reason I thought the patent was assigned to the Smart company was because they list it in their Wefunder page[0] (under the heading "Key Accomplishments"). But actually all that's stated on that page is that "multiple patents protect this innovation", they don't actually claim that they have the patents. I'm still curious how the licensing from NASA works. Do they typically grant a monopoly to certain companies or can multiple competing companies license this technology? [0]: https://wefunder.com/the.smart.tire.company https://wefunder.com/the.smart.tire.company
- dpiers 6y agoIt depends. NASA will file a notice of intent to grant an exclusive or partial license - you can see the notices here[1]. In this case it seems the patent is still available for anyone to license[2]. They have special licensing terms for startups that are pretty favorable[3]. 1: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/search?conditions%5Bagencies%5D%5B%5D=national-aeronautics-and-space-administration&conditions%5Bterm%5D=patent&conditions%5Btype%5D%5B%5D=NOTICE https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/search?conditions%... 2: https://technology.nasa.gov/patent/LEW-TOPS-99 https://technology.nasa.gov/patent/LEW-TOPS-99 3: https://technology.nasa.gov/startup https://technology.nasa.gov/startup
- ballenf 6y agoI think this is more so just spring steel. Unless there's a heat source hidden in there. It's also kind of funny that they admit they'll have to wrap the metal in a rubbery substance for traction. So we're pretty much back at steel radial tires.
- Robotbeat 6y agoIn a way, yeah it is a better spring steel. Many shape memory alloys, besides their famous shape-changing-under-heating behavior, can also have superelastic properties, meaning they can reversible handle much larger strains than typical alloys (by a reversible phase change in the material). This means they can work as a better spring alloy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudoelasticity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudoelasticity
- scythe 6y agoNitinol typically has tight compositional tolerances and is used for things like stents and catheters. It's nothing new in the medical field. But it'd be pretty damn impressive to manufacture something so finely structured out of nitinol at scale.
- Robotbeat 6y agoOh, it’s not that uncommon. You can buy Nitinol wire pretty cheaply, although not the medical-approved stuff.
- mdip 6y agoI wonder, though, if the rubber can be more rugged as a result. Materials/chemistry is so far out of my wheelhouse, I can't even imagine what that might be. But I'd imagine there might be a way to optimize the synthetic rubber for handling friction against the road surface while not having to optimize it for handling pneumatic pressure. Unfortunately, I suspect that the things done to make the tire survive road friction better also make it grip the road worse. And that there's likely not a chemical formula that one can apply which wouldn't work equally well under a pressurized tire... but hey, most things are evolution, not revolution, anyway, right?
- lolc 6y agoHaha, they look so cool! Given that the mesh has an uneven surface though, I don't see how they could compare well to the resistance of a tire with a smooth surface. Also, it looks like the coating would have to be reapplied often because it's so thin. And small objects could start to accumulate inside, no? The more I think about them, the more impractical they seem. Would still love to try them though.
- sandworm101 6y agoMars? I think not. This woven-metal tire tech was around long before the mars rovers. https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/wheel-lunar-rover/nasm_A19750830000 https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/wheel-lunar-ro... https://www.nasa.gov/specials/wheels/ https://www.nasa.gov/specials/wheels/ And can someone explain to me what "shape memory alloy" means in this context? Iirc that means a metal that will return to a shape when heated. So I blowtorch these bike tires every few days to iron out dents? Or are these just spring steel, metal that bounces back into shape so long as it isn't push beyond its yield point?
- musingsole 6y agoNot a shape alloy expert, but the temperature that causes them to morph can be manipulated when they're formed (forged?). I have a few strands that just the heat from your hand is often enough to trigger them. So, the heat from friction is potentially an option.
- cbsks 6y agoThis video has a clear explanation of the shape metal alloy on the Mars rover wheel: https://youtu.be/2lv6Vs12jLc https://youtu.be/2lv6Vs12jLc Short answer is that the material is super elastic, and will return to its original shape either when heat is applied, or when stress is applied.
- wil421 6y agoThey developed the shape memory part recently while developing a new wheel for the Mars rover. From your NASA link: “ In one particular moment of serendipity, Engineer Colin Creager and Materials Scientist Santo Padula had a conversation that completely changed the path forward. The game changing material that dramatically advanced the development of spring tires was nickel titanium, a shape memory alloy with amazing capabilities as explained by Santo Padula.”
- brennanpeterson 6y agoWoven metal tires are old. And nitinol is also old (it was not developed for the rover, a wiki check would show as much). But the combination is new. I imagine the conversation went 'hey I am working on chainmail tires' 'areny those heavy' 'well. We need them light, strong and elastic, and you only get two...' ' hol up, there is an option, you heard of nitinol?' And thus, cool history.
- yodelshady 6y agoFYI, reasons why air works really well as a suspension medium: * stiffness-to-weight is high and hysteresis low. That means a) easily adjusting the compliance for different weights, b) excellent traction, since the "spring" isn't fighting its own inertia. * in normal operations, essentially unlimited durability, because there's no long-range order to break down. Let's see how these do after a million or so cycles. * when something does break your suspension, you're literally surrounded by the repair material. Again, let's see airless compete with that. The road is a very hostile surface. I've seen more than one well-meaning group try "ruggedised" tyres that became useless well before I'd even expect a puncture from a decent road tyre.
- Valgrim 6y agoYou're absolutely right, but I'm still happy that someone created a full-size prototype of it outside the lab, and is testing it, tinkering with it and putting it out there so people can also try it and experiment with it. I don't know what this could lead to, maybe some sort of hybrid air-filled spring loaded undestructible bike tire, maybe it's going to end-up in a completely different application, such as wheelchairs or farming tractors or mining equipment.
- zbrozek 6y agoI'm also glad folks are tinkering. That said, bike tires are probably not where I would expect something like this to land. I would love these to replace the tires on things like utility carts, air compressors, etc that typically end up with solid tires. Those solid tires are awful, but pneumatic ones must be filled and that's annoying for infrequently used stuff.
- analog31 6y agoAgreed. I happen to enjoy the hobby of tinkering with old bikes, so my bikes are typically a few decades behind the latest technology. So I can adopt a wait-and-see philosophy. But still I remember a cynical comment by my dad, maybe 40 years ago. They had just announced some new advanced material, and my dad said: "Mark my words, the first applications will be high end bikes and golf clubs." Also, improving on the bicycle is a very common capstone project for design students.
- interestica 6y agoIs there a company named "Smart" in every domain?
- cardiffspaceman 6y agoAnd every such name is just waiting for someone who has a bad experience due to a flaw, and christens it 'Stupid'. To avoid this phenomenon name your "Smart Pointer" "RefCountingPointer" not "SmartPtr".
- tyingq 6y ago"Polyurethanium" ??? Surely there's a real word they could use there.
- stdbrouw 6y agoAlso, if this is some kind of polyurethane, they're going to have a hard time convincing anyone that this is an environmentally friendly alternative to rubber tires.
- meepmorp 6y agoI keep reading it as 'poly-urethra-radium'
- dylan604 6y agoLike unobtanium? If they use a real word, they wouldn't be able to trade mark it and protect their brand. Sounds like people are taking cues from big pharma with naming, or silicon valley by taking real words and dropping vowels. It's a trend. Why is this surprising to you?
- 5560675260 6y agoPolyurethane [0] is a real world. Maybe that's what they meant? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyurethane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyurethane
- tyingq 6y agoNo, they trademarked the term, so it's definitely on purpose.
- FpUser 6y agoWhy spend $20 when you can spend many times more for the product without any real benefits. "Polyurethanium" - when normal tire wears off you just replace single piece of rubber, when this adamantium dies one will have to replace that whole metal wonder.
- dylan604 6y agoHow do you "replace single piece of rubber"? I've either had to replace a tube, or replace the tire itself. How is this different?
- FpUser 6y agoYes on a regular bike you replace cheap (sometimes not) tire. With this contraption they put tire / protective layer on top of their metal wonder. Problem is that this protective layer will wear in no time and then you will have to replace the whole metal piece which is expensive proposition.
- mbreese 6y agoIf you want background on the material in question here (nitinol), The Verge had a good video explainer about the material and a bit about how the “space tire” aspect will work. It’s really a fascinating video of you’ve never seen the metal in action. I can see why it would be chosen for the environment on Mars. I’m not sure if it would be better than air tires on Earth, but for the low atmosphere environment on Mars, it makes more sense. https://www.theverge.com/2021/3/17/22334611/nitinol-metal-shape-memory-alloy-mars-nasa https://www.theverge.com/2021/3/17/22334611/nitinol-metal-sh... https://youtu.be/Pn-6bGORy0U https://youtu.be/Pn-6bGORy0U
- dmayle 6y agoI received a pair of Tannus Airless tires ( https://tannustires.com/ https://tannustires.com/ ) for christmas, and have been waiting for good weather to install them. While they weigh more than regular tires, they weigh less than the combined weight of regular tires + pump + patch kit, so it's a net win on weight. For me, the biggest win is not about not worrying whether or not I get a flat, it's not having to pump the darn things up week in and week out before going out on my (admittedly city commuter) rides.
- tzs 6y ago> While they weigh more than regular tires, they weigh less than the combined weight of regular tires + pump + patch kit, so it's a net win on weight. Larger moment of inertia, though, so not a complete win. I wonder how the trade off works--where is the breakeven point between trading tire mass for mass being carried in a fixed position on the frame?
- gameswithgo 6y agoI have done the math, and the inertia issue is basically a non issue. Humans don’t accelerate hard enough to have any significant impact. the issue with airless tires though is bot weight, but rolling resistance and handling. Both are much worse. It is going to feel horrible.
- etcet 6y agoThe weight of your tires is in the worst place for rotational mass. You'll definitely feel it if you're doing city riding between frequent red lights but it could arguably be a benefit if you're cruising for long distances as it'll act like a fly wheel to some extent.
- c0nsumer 6y agoThe pump and patch kit are effectively static weight on a bike. What's referred to as rotating mass on a bike (usually talking about wheels+tires) is noticeable. Maybe not as much on your city bike, but the thing that usually makes a bike feel heavy is the weight of the wheels, not the overall bike itself. Best of luck with them.
- geocrasher 6y agoYet another solution looking for a problem to solve. We don't need better tires. We have them. They're called 'pneumatic' and in the late 1800's they were a significant advancement in technology. They provide a great ride, great traction, and are straightforward to repair. I seriously doubt whether "Smart METL" airless tires meet those same marks.
- m463 6y agoI think there are significant usability problems with wheels and tires that can be tackled. For example, tires lose air on a daily basis and have to be pumped up. Additionally, even the best pumps require a bunch of fidding to attach and detach the hose to the air fitting. Tires and suspension are a tradeoff between comfort and efficiency. Lower rolling resistance means a stiffer/harsher ride. High pressure tires are narrow, have a very small contact patch and no "suspension travel" Even though it's cliche, I think reinventing the wheel might take us interesting places.
- jfengel 6y agoRepair isn't that straightforward. It requires you to remove the wheel, and then the tire. You then replace the inner tube and re-mount the tire bead, which requires some practice to get right. Then you have to re-pump it. An expert can do it quickly, but it's a hassle for an amateur out for a cruise. It's also limited by the tubes and/or patches you've brought with you. If you blow a tube, you should have a spare. If you lose a second tube, you may be out of luck. Maybe it can be patched, though I've found patching unreliable. You may be in for a long walk, in your cycling shoes -- especially if you've ridden out of cell phone range. These are clearly going to be far beyond the price point of your casual rider, at least for a while. But if they can match the ride experience, and eventually lower the price, I could see these being wildly popular. Pneumatic tires are hard to beat, but there's a lot of room for improvement in their durability. Which is really important for something you depend on so much.
- hugey010 6y agoOne of the simplest and most common mods to off-road vehicles is called a tire mousse. It's basically foam or rubber that replaces the inflatable tube. The benefits are never getting a flat, and not having to carry a spare tube, tools, or patches. There's some efficiency loss which may be too much for a commuter bicycle, but it looks like they exist for mountain and e-bikes.
- mdip 6y agoI kind of takes tires for granted in a lot of ways. My assumption was that technology around the "tire" wasn't going to change substantially any time soon and there has to be a number of very good reasons I'm unaware of as to why we accept the risk of blow-out for the remaining benefits of the technology (the article mentions road grip, but yodelshady in the comments mentioning suspension medium explained the reasoning really well). A lot of thought has been put toward reducing "blow-out" and other risks associated with "rolling around on a balloon". I started looking at "run-flat tires" after having suffered a blow-out on the road at 70MPH on defective (two-day old) tires and experiencing what it really is like to have your life "in God's hands" for twenty long seconds. I was in my car, that time -- had it been a blow-out on my motorcycle... After some research and discussion with a trusted mechanic, I opted to save $100-or-so/tire[0] and skip the technology. I wanted tires that I wouldn't have to concern myself with the pressure, I was being sold tires that handle a nail pretty well. Having suffered a blow-out in a car, it's something that's on my mind on my motorcycle. There's just not a lot you can do -- the best tires are designed to prevent the typical causes of this but defects in the tire/chemicals involved can make it impossible to verify that the tire is safe to ride on prior to use for certain defects. Some won't be an issue until the tire has been driven at speed enough for it to reach a certain temperature (that was my issue) and there won't be a scar or bubble on the tire where it's about to fail. So all of this to say -- this looks like a really excellent thing if they can truly eliminate pressurized air and maintain the performance of a regular tire (while not costing an unrealistic amount -- that's probably tricky). I doubt it would "eliminate the tire" in every application -- it makes sense to start with bikes -- but I'll be an early customer when they have a motorcycle tire replacement. :) [0] His explanation was that they'll let you get to the shop if you "roll over the business end of a screw". Regular tires are designed to handle punctures gracefully, already. Run flat will do a little better than a regular tire but they blow out, especially if the car doesn't have a pressure monitor because the tires don't appear to be as low as they are, causing the driver to damage the tire rapidly. He also confirmed my suspicion: "It's a pretty safe bet that if the tire has 1,000 miles on it, it won't blow out until after you should have replaced it" -- basically, brand new and really old tires are the ones that just spontaneously "fall apart".
- aitchnyu 6y ago
- jiofih 6y ago> Polyurethanium. We have no idea what this is and Smart provided no detail. That was funny. The bad news: polyurethane is a type of plastic, already used as a replacement for rubber in some kinds of tires.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoI guess if the metal is doing 99% of the support work, then you might be able to "spray on" grip. This might be SUPER IMPORTANT if it's biodegradable, with all the stories about the noxious effects of car tire wear particles impacting the environment. Since the "grip" doesn't need to do the support job, we can use a more fragile compound.
- exabrial 6y agoHave you been converted to the cult of tubeless tires? They truly are remarkable. I ride on sharp limestone and thru hedgeapple rows, and the fact these things hold any sort of air after a ride is truly amazing. I was so mesmerized by the performance on my mountain bike, my 'city' bike now sports tubeless rims and tires. I haven't had a flat yet! (knock on wood, headed to Bentonville next weekend). To me, this problem is mostly 'solved' unless there's a generation leap in weight savings. My tires weigh .65kg each (and thats light for MTB)! That's a lot of rotating mass that's also unsprung on the suspension.