4 ms·
I still have one in a drawer. I worked at Nokia at the time. These were awesome phones. But they were deliberately crippled by management that preferred other p
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
I still have one in a drawer. I worked at Nokia at the time. These were awesome phones. But they were deliberately crippled by management that preferred other platforms they had.
So, several devices originally earmarked for Maemo/Meego (the name changed at some point) actually shipped with Symbian instead.
Some fun facts about Maemo:
Shipped in 2006 with the N770. Had a tablet UI based on X and GTK, a mozilla based browser and was based on Debian. You could build your own packages, add your own apt repositories, and people basically built most of Debian from source to run on it. E.g. I had a JVM running on it and a full LAMP stack at some point.
The N800 was for a time the only device that could run Android (dual boot) and basically shared large parts of the kernel with it. Google used this device for early Android testing and probably owes a lot to Nokia engineers contributing patches to the Linux kernel. The first Nexus phone shipped quite late in the Android development process.
Development of Meego saw several strategy changes that ultimately delayed products for a long time. One of those unfortunate decisions was the decision to swap out GTK for QT; effectively retiring all of the user facing UI. That set back the clock by years. And it got slowed down further by a simultaneous attempt to get Symbian on QT as well. That trainwreck of course ended up sucking up all the resources and failed to ultimately deliver the goods. This was in the middle of Nokia's realization that "oh fuck this iphone thing is real; we need a touch screen UI". It killed at least two touch screen platforms that it had before it came to that realization.
Technically, the N800 was running circles around the first iphone in terms of what you could do on it. All it needed was a bit of hardware polish and a phone stack. Early Android had nothing on Meego. Even the UX was clumsy and it was slow and limited as well. But unlike Meego, Google shipped it and supported it and persisted in developing it. Nokia instead threw out the baby with the bathwater betting on several other horses before ultimately walking away from the whole phone business.
Nokia declined to combine a phone stack + SIM card with the N770 and N800 deeming it to risky; they were protecting their deals with operators to basically cripple phones in favor of crappy operating services. E.g. bundling Skype with the n800 was controversial. It even did video calls with Skype. In 2007. The N800 was a tablet before the iphone, ipad or Android were a thing. There was not a lot else in the market at that point. That thing with a phone stack would have been a killer product despite its many limitations.
The N900 and the later N9 were both labelled as developer phones and cut off from any serious marketing effort. The N9 technically was a decent phone but by the time it shipped, the team had been layed off, the platform cancelled and Nokia was endorsing Windows Phone. It also shipped an Android phone around the same time, leaving the ugly job of cancelling that product to Microsoft after the acquisition.
Samsung's Bada is a direct decendent of Meego. It never really gained any market share against Android and it seems Samsung pretty much gave up on it.
- agloeregrets 6y agoIt's stunning to me just how many incredible technical efforts Nokia made to just kill. The N9 after this was killer but boom, dead, the Nokia X was okay but weird, Dead, the Lumia, alive, then boom, dead. It's remarkable that Elop was never prosecuted for his actions that clearly were in benefit to his prior employer. It's almost hilarious that modern Nokia HMD makes phones now because I expect the company to randomly up and disappear and come back with a WebOS phone or some other weird offshoot.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoElop was a stooge that executed the master plan created bv the Nokia board together with MS as specified. Blame the decade of incompetence that preceded Elop.
- zelos 6y ago> One of those unfortunate decisions was the decision to swap out GTK for QT; That was kind of swings and roundabouts, though. The second version of the Maemo app I worked on ended up being a major rewrite Gtk->Qt thanks to the switch, but Qt was so much better.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoYes, it just meant shipping after Apple and Android had become entrenched in the market. Nokia wasted a good two years doing this. And it was too little too late.
- butokai 6y agoI would be curious to know more about the several devices that were planned to be on Meego but then shipped with Symbian! I remember seeing Bada phones at the time, but (at least in my country) the "does it run WhatsApp" era was already starting, and the total lack of apps for Bada made it totally unattractive. All said, I am not sure that polishing and marketing would have been enough to save the situation. I didn't see Palm's Pre and webOS mentioned in the thread so far: that makes for an example of an excellent platform, with good marketing and capabilities, that still didn't manage to affect the rise of the duopoly.