6 ms·
They didn't buy the art, they bought an NFT that represents a hash of the file containing all of the art in question. This doesn't convey any property rights t
by sneak 6y ago
They didn't buy the art, they bought an NFT that represents a hash of the file containing all of the art in question.
This doesn't convey any property rights to the art's copyright, unless the purchase also included those separately from the NFT, which, of course, happens all of the time without the NFT silliness and doesn't require NFTs at all.
- tim333 6y agoI think in this case they did get property rights: >NFT carries no rights, express or implied, other than property rights for the lot (specifically, digital artwork tokenized by the NFT.. https://www.christies.com/pdf/onlineonly/ECOMMERCE%20CONDITIONS%20OF%20SALE%20-%20NEW%20YORK-8Mar21.pdf https://www.christies.com/pdf/onlineonly/ECOMMERCE%20CONDITI... So no rights apart from the property rights (Christies T&Cs)
- sneak 6y agoThe lot was the NFT. I don't believe that the text you quoted indicates that they get ownership of the copyright of the art. The art wasn't auctioned, the NFT was.
- tim333 6y agoThe catalogue says "EVERYDAYS: THE FIRST 5000 DAYS will be delivered directly from Beeple to the buyer, accompanied by a unique NFT" So presumably an image file and the NFT. Bit vague on copyright.
- techdragon 6y agoWait... the only way this NFT stuff made any sense to me was if they were actually selling the copyrights via NFT... this was actually just a $69 million version of calling “dibs” like some kind of schoolchild? WTF!
- Hjfrf 6y agoIt's more like buying a receipt, not the good itself. They can display the receipt but have no more right to the art than you or me.
- mavhc 6y agoLike bitcoin, the only way it makes sense is if you can trick someone else into buying it off you for more money later, thus you're incentivised to promote the idea everywhere.
- ric2b 6y agoOr gold, or dollars, or art, etc.
- mavhc 6y agoGold has a use, dollars are backed by a government. Owning original art is bragging/speculation. I read that the very expensive art that people buy isn't even hung on their walls to look at, they get a copy made for people to see, and put the original in a vault.
- ric2b 6y ago> Gold has a use But I won't be happy if people stop buying gold and all I can do with it is sell it to some electronics manufacturer for 1% of the price I paid for it. > dollars are backed by a government Sounds great, what can I do if people stop accepting dollars in trade? > Owning original art is bragging/speculation. Agreed, so nothing new.
- BTCOG 6y agoWrong. Don't bring Bitcoin into this. This is an Ethereum scam thing.
- mc32 6y agoIt’s like buying a digital photo of lottery ticket that’s already been played but played by a celebrity, let’s say.