4 ms·
> The initiative is timely. Japan has long grappled with a grim — and in some cases, fatal — culture of overwork. The problem is so severe, the country has even
by ekianjo 6y ago
> The initiative is timely. Japan has long grappled with a grim — and in some cases, fatal — culture of overwork. The problem is so severe, the country has even coined a term for it: karoshi means death by overwork from stress-induced illnesses or severe depression.
I love the ignorant CNN contributors there. You can really see the full effect of people commenting about cultures they do not know or do not understand.
First, 'overwork' is not what you think. Most of work done in Japanese companies is not busy work. Long hours are often the result of excessive bureaucracy and long meetings, and the expectation that you'll go out for dinner (maybe not everyday, but regularly enough) with your peers as a form of social bonding at the end of the day (something that is not really a thing in other cultures). If you don't understand that aspect of the culture, well you don't understand anything at all really.
As for coining words. Japanese people have a coin word for everything under the sun, even mundane things that foreigners would have no expression for. It's a culture that loves making new words, new expressions, new acronyms - very much in the DNA of the Japanese language, so there's no "even coined a term for X" that remotely means anything at all. Niche phenomena also coined specific words, and it does not mean there's a massive trend going on.
You should be a lot more concerned by the number of suicides in Japan than by the number of people dying from overwork - it's not even on the same scale at all.
- ath92 6y agoDo you think the suicide rate could be related to the cultural pressure to work long hours?
- ekianjo 6y agoJust like every problem, there's tons of factors at play. Let's not try to reduce everything to a single variable, because then we are surely mistaking ourselves. Top of mind, I would say the following factors probably play a role: - social pressure to conform - social pressure to be successful - depression not being very well treated in Japan - work/school being too much in one's life compared to other things - lack of support/encouragement - isolation - fatalism ('you can't do anything about that') kind of belief But even that list is too short, I feel. I think by living in Japan you grasp a little more what is at play but as I said, it's a whole package, not just a few factors.
- causality0 6y agoLong hours are often the result of excessive bureaucracy and long meetings, and the expectation that you'll go out for dinner (maybe not everyday, but regularly enough) with your peers as a form of social bonding at the end of the day You...you know that's worse, right?
- ekianjo 6y agoI'm not judging either way. Just stating the reality, and Japan is not a country where individualism is prized as much as in the US, for example. Being part of a larger community is very important here.
- serial_dev 6y agoI like criticizing CNN as much as the next guy, but nothing what you wrote really contradicts what you quoted from the article.
- ekianjo 6y agoI just explained at least that "coining words" means nothing in Japan. That's a clear refutation of what they insinuated.
- BadInformatics 6y agoThough I agree on the cultural ignorance point (especially not choosing to localize terms so that they sound exotic), needless overtime and the 996 culture are absolutely a problem. It's not so much that the work is tiring as the hours are unnecessary and prohibit people from doing stuff outside of work. 20-30 years ago, bonding with peers after work was still pervasive in China/Japan/SK, but the hours were nowhere near as crazy as they are now.
- koyote 6y ago> Long hours are often the result of excessive bureaucracy and long meetings, and the expectation that you'll go out for dinner I don't think it matters what the work is. If you spend most of your awake hours either in the office or with your colleagues then that deprives you from resting and relaxing (and of course seeing your family, engaging in leisure activities etc.). > You should be a lot more concerned by the number of suicides in Japan than by the number of people dying from overwork And how many suicides in Japan are work-related?
- ekianjo 6y ago> And how many suicides in Japan are work-related? Hard to say. Since there are a lot of suicides among students and retired people too, I'm sure work is not the only problem.
- Hamuko 6y ago>And how many suicides in Japan are work-related? Probably no hard statistics on this but here's something from Japan Times on karôshi: >Over the past decade, more than 300 people each year have been awarded compensation under work-related accident insurance after suffering either heart attacks or strokes. In 2013 alone, 133 of such people died. A growing number of workers also win damages for work-induced mental problems, with the figure hitting 436 last year, including 63 who either committed or attempted suicide. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2014/11/15/editorials/getting-a-grip-on-karoshi/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2014/11/15/editorials/g...