4 ms·
So, is 30% too much of a cut when the platform offers: - Credit card processing - The largest marketplace with the most paying customers - Download hosting
by zdw 15y ago
So, is 30% too much of a cut when the platform offers:
- Credit card processing
- The largest marketplace with the most paying customers
- Download hosting
- Promotion
- Highly available document and key/value store infrastructure
- Keeping junk and malware out of the store, which maintains user trust.
I'd argue that, like most emotionally influence business decisions, Apple sticking with the same percentage is a good thing - witness how the markets vary when things are up in the air politically.
Keeping the same policies for a long time allows businesses to plan appropriately as they know what they're going to get, even if it's not ideal.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoThat may be a very good deal for some... but what if it's not or the people just want an alternative? If Apple's platform is that good, then there is no reason to lock in people to use only that, devs will flock to it anyway, it can stand on it's own merits. Or Amazon or someone else may come in and offer all of the above + more at only 20% because of their efficiencies (AWS etc.). Not to mention the still ongoing forced 30% of subscriptions fiasco for which Apple does not provide hosting.
- LokiSnake 15y agoThere is good reason to not offer alternatives. There will be platform fragmentation, and end up being a worse experience for both developers and users. Devs probably need to publish on all stores to cover their bases, otherwise users need to know which store to buy from or have to search for an app in every single store. Also, Apple has changed their subscriptions policy: http://www.macrumors.com/2011/06/09/apple-reverses-course-on-in-app-subscriptions/ http://www.macrumors.com/2011/06/09/apple-reverses-course-on...
- jonknee 15y agoI don't think the 30% has ever been an issue. The exclusivity is. Doubly so as Apple keeps changing the rules which if you're caught on the wrong side of can destroy your business.
- YooLi 15y ago"I don't think the 30% has ever been an issue." Seriously? The 30% on apps, the 30% on in-app purchases, 30% on subscriptions, etc., each caused an uproar when they were announced.
- jonknee 15y agoNot because of the percentage, but because of the exclusivity. 30% on in-app purchases/subscriptions was only a big deal because Apple required that you use it and match the lowest price anywhere else. (They since backed down on this, but they can change their minds again.)
- Stormbringer 15y ago30% on apps caused an uproar because it was so much cheaper than the other alternatives. Not to come across as an Apple apologist, but seriously, it wasn't even that frickin' long ago... even in internet time. Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it, repeatedly, in online forums, but in a badly twisted and inaccurate version.
- avgarrison 15y agoWhat do you mean by the exclusivity? How do you mean it can destroy your business if caught on the wrong side?
- jonknee 15y agoYou can't distribute an iOS app outside of the App Store (outside of the enterprise). So Apple's 30% fee is essentially a tax on iOS apps--there's not a way around it. Apple can destroy your business by changing a rule that makes your app ineligible for the App Store (or at least unprofitable, most recently seen in the whole in-app fiasco). There's not a way to distribute outside of Apple, so if Apple doesn't want to distribute your app then you have no business.
- Aloisius 15y agoDoes anyone believe that the promotion that Apple offers on average is worth two cents? And what good is a marketplace with some of the worst discovery ever? I mean, there are now hundreds of thousands of apps. Finding high quality apps on the app store is like finding a needle in a Utah sized haystack. I much rather do my own marketing, have a user download the app off my website or heck, Amazon (which actually has a decent recommendation engine). And keeping junk out? Have you seen most of the apps? I mean the number of them that haven't been updated in years is staggering. The number that are essentially clones churned out by some make-an-app framework is ridiculous. The signal-to-noise ratio on the app store is awful. Credit card processing? Not having to do anything is worth 4-5%.
- xenophanes 15y ago> Does anyone believe that the promotion that Apple offers on average is worth two cents? I do. I made a couple small and quick apps. They have made several hundred dollars. I attribute that almost entirely to Apple's promotion of them, mostly by having them show up in iTunes search results which Apple promotes. Also having them show up as recent releases. My promotion consisted of linking them on my websites. If that was all it was -- my website links and nothing else -- I think sales would be near zero. For better apps, Apple's promotion is even more valuable. Definitely no where near 2 cents.
- smackfu 15y agoCounting search results as promotion is a stretch.
- ojilles 15y agoNot really as Apple made sure searches happen in the first place.
- danilocampos 15y agoNot sure why you're being voted down. Distribution channels don't just spring out of the ground overnight. Apple's promotion of iTunes and the App Store created a critical mass of users willing and able to spend money, while Apple maintains that by creating mechanisms to satisfy their demand for apps and content.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]