3 ms·
I considered that, surprisingly enough since I had not had my first cup of coffee when I typed all that verbage. I decided that the subsidies are equivalent to
by doodlebugging 6y ago
I considered that, surprisingly enough since I had not had my first cup of coffee when I typed all that verbage.
I decided that the subsidies are equivalent to greasing the wheels in that they provides an incentive for people to choose the path that you wish them to choose in absence of the subsidy. If you have a goal of eliminating brucellosis from your native herds and you want it to happen in as short a time period as possible then you design a program that rewards people for taking quick action.
The program controls can also do useful things like set a time limit on the availability of the subsidy so that people can be helped to understand that if they hesitate to act they will lose out on the benefit. It should also have controls in place to identify and sanction bad actors so that anyone in a position to falsify data will know in advance that damaging sanctions exist and that enforcement will be a program priority. Veterinarians would need to be on board with defrauding the system since they have to sign off on the relevance of the subsidy on a case by case basis. It seems unlikely that someone who has spend such a large part of their life earning that position, a position that will see them able to earn a good living for themselves and their families, would risk losing all of it by falsifying data.
It is clear that India has decided that vaccination is a net positive and that the end result is worth the cost since society will win. A subsidy to help those who stand to lose something, even temporarily like the milk output reduction, seems like a great trade.
- freeopinion 6y agoAre you familiar enough with daily life throughout India to know how easy it is to become a vet or to know how lucrative or desirable it is to be a vet? Or to know if it is practical for vets to respond to every failed birthing and certify them? Presumably you have to certify that the mother was vaccinated properly. Do you know how many vets would be involved? How big of an enforcement staff will you be hiring for this? How will you make sure they can't be bought? This scheme would be dominated by corruption from start to finish. Why not propose to pay vets for every vac-tag they record? Enforcement is a lot easier. Payment distribution is a lot easier. Incentive to vaccinate is higher. No incentive to abort calves. Still invites corruption. Edit: In other words, pay for the behavior you want to encourage. Do you want to vaccinate, or do you want to abort calves? Edit: I'm American. I'm not great at English.