2 ms·
This comes as no surprise giving the repetitious, almost regurgatory nature of public debates these days. I can't remember the last time I heard a new argument
by whatshisface 6y ago
This comes as no surprise giving the repetitious, almost regurgatory nature of public debates these days. I can't remember the last time I heard a new argument made up on the spot. The Chinese Room thought experiment applied to debate wouldn't need an infinite book, you could get by with at most a pamphlet.
- qsort 6y agoThese days? A good chunk of all arguments are a variant of the myth of the golden age, which has been around since the Greeks. There's a saying that only three books have ever been written: voyage, love and war. I suspect the number of rethorical arguments is the same order of magnitude.
- whatshisface 6y agoThat's true in the abstract, but in the concrete there are unique lines of argument, contingent on details specific to a topic, that get invented shortly after the topic arises. It is at that level that you can literally have an indexed pamphlet to guide you verbatim through 90% of dialogues. Injecting contextual facts into 500BC rhetorical forms is a little more human-level than repeating other people's filled-out Pnyxian madlibs, an activity that is a little below machine-level.