3 ms·
What does it being a commodity have to do with it being separately from employment and freely available? Sorry, I’m not following.
by endisneigh 6y ago
What does it being a commodity have to do with it being separately from employment and freely available?
Sorry, I’m not following.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIt’s not a commodity. There’s no price I wouldn’t pay to be treated for an active heart attack - if I’m even conscious to decide!
- endisneigh 6y agoI’m still not following. I’m using the word “commodity” to refer to a good or service that’s indistinguishable from another of the same type. So under that definition what you’re describing isn’t relevant to whether it’s a commodity or not. Also, health care isn’t a commodity right now but I’d argue it should be (a high quality one).
- ceejayoz 6y agoIf I’m having a heart attack, healthcare is distinguishable by “what’s the closest ER”. The ambulance crew is unlikely to even permit a choice in the matter.
- endisneigh 6y agoSure, but I’m talking about the services mentioned in the featured article. Amazon Care does not provide emergency surgery at the moment. Health care is far more than just emergency services.
- tidepod12 6y agoI think you're misunderstanding the word "commodity". If healthcare were commoditized, then "what's the closest ER" would be the only thing that matters. You are actually advocating for commoditization. Water, for example, is a commodity. It doesn't matter where you get it, because water from one tap is mostly indistinguishable to water from a different tap. When you need water, you simply just go to the closest tap and you can be happy that you're getting the same quality water as anywhere else. That's exactly what you want with healthcare, too.
- ceejayoz 6y agoWater is a public utility here. I’d like the same for healthcare.
- tidepod12 6y agoBeing a public utility or not has nothing to do with commoditization. You keep saying you're against commoditization but then make arguments in favor of it. In fact, commoditization of healthcare is probably one of the best steps towards making it a public utility. So if that's what you want, then you probably do want healthcare to be commoditized.
- throwaway53453 6y agoIn the event of a stroke, you can hardly take the time to shop around the local hospital market, compare prices and review scores.
- tidepod12 6y agoExactly, which is why you want it to be a commodity, so that there isn't even the need to do something like shop around. If healthcare was a commodity, you just go to the nearest hospital and can rest assured that you're getting the same care you would get anywhere else.
- nemo44x 6y agoThe trouble is there will always be a difference in quality. It’s a human business after all. Different hospitals have different facilities as well. You’re better off having a type of procedure at one place than another for example. And even if you somehow made it so every hospital had the same high quality equipment you still wouldn’t have the same quality of specialists, surgeons, etc. This matters a lot. There’s probably a baseline we could get to but the experience will never be a commodity overall.
- endisneigh 6y agoI agree completely but I do think we should be trying to make healthcare as much of a commodity as possible.
- tidepod12 6y agoThere are definitely parts of healthcare that are unreasonable to expect to be commoditized. A heart transplant or brain surgery are probably things where centers specialized in those areas will be higher quality. But for more common things like an annual wellness exam, or blood tests, mending a broken arm, treating the flu, or even doing surgery on a burst appendix, those are things that I think can reasonable be commoditized across any healthcare providers.
- bhupy 6y agoHow is that relevant to preventive care? That's what Amazon Care appears to be...
- pzone 6y agoYou're ignoring the vast vast majority of health care out there to focus on one extreme example - for which we have a separate answer already. (catastrophe insurance.) I just want a decent doctor to prescribe my meds and to purchase them at a reasonable price. I won't die without these things, and I'd prefer the costs be visible so there will be price competition. Most health care is like this.