3 ms·
I honestly can’t stand Amazon, but isn’t health care the kind of thing you want commoditized and streamlined? Amazon is in the upper echelon of doing this kind
by endisneigh 6y ago
I honestly can’t stand Amazon, but isn’t health care the kind of thing you want commoditized and streamlined? Amazon is in the upper echelon of doing this kind of thing.
I would much rather be able to request services in the way Amazon allows you to buy products than continue to engage in the current opaque system.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> isn’t health care the kind of thing you want commoditized No? I want it separated from employment and universally and freely available like the rest of the developed world. (At half our costs, and similar outcomes!)
- ryandvm 6y agoFair enough. Would you also prefer if we had government-run grocery stores or gas stations?
- endisneigh 6y agoWhat does it being a commodity have to do with it being separately from employment and freely available? Sorry, I’m not following.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIt’s not a commodity. There’s no price I wouldn’t pay to be treated for an active heart attack - if I’m even conscious to decide!
- endisneigh 6y agoI’m still not following. I’m using the word “commodity” to refer to a good or service that’s indistinguishable from another of the same type. So under that definition what you’re describing isn’t relevant to whether it’s a commodity or not. Also, health care isn’t a commodity right now but I’d argue it should be (a high quality one).
- ceejayoz 6y agoIf I’m having a heart attack, healthcare is distinguishable by “what’s the closest ER”. The ambulance crew is unlikely to even permit a choice in the matter.
- endisneigh 6y agoSure, but I’m talking about the services mentioned in the featured article. Amazon Care does not provide emergency surgery at the moment. Health care is far more than just emergency services.
- tidepod12 6y agoI think you're misunderstanding the word "commodity". If healthcare were commoditized, then "what's the closest ER" would be the only thing that matters. You are actually advocating for commoditization. Water, for example, is a commodity. It doesn't matter where you get it, because water from one tap is mostly indistinguishable to water from a different tap. When you need water, you simply just go to the closest tap and you can be happy that you're getting the same quality water as anywhere else. That's exactly what you want with healthcare, too.
- ceejayoz 6y agoWater is a public utility here. I’d like the same for healthcare.
- tidepod12 6y agoBeing a public utility or not has nothing to do with commoditization. You keep saying you're against commoditization but then make arguments in favor of it. In fact, commoditization of healthcare is probably one of the best steps towards making it a public utility. So if that's what you want, then you probably do want healthcare to be commoditized.
- throwaway53453 6y agoIn the event of a stroke, you can hardly take the time to shop around the local hospital market, compare prices and review scores.
- bhupy 6y agoHow is that relevant to preventive care? That's what Amazon Care appears to be...
- pzone 6y agoYou're ignoring the vast vast majority of health care out there to focus on one extreme example - for which we have a separate answer already. (catastrophe insurance.) I just want a decent doctor to prescribe my meds and to purchase them at a reasonable price. I won't die without these things, and I'd prefer the costs be visible so there will be price competition. Most health care is like this.
- bhupy 6y agoAnd in the one country where healthcare is a consumer-driven commodity (Singapore), it's 1/6 our cost, and better outcomes!
- asciimike 6y agoFun anecdote: after a weekend of skiing a few years ago, I had a sore throat, went to One Medical and got a rapid strep test, and was charged $140 for what was a negative result. The next day I was on a flight from SFO to Singapore, and it was extremely apparent I had strep. Upon landing in Singapore, I went to a clinic where they diagnosed the strep, gave me antibiotics, decongestants, sudafed (the good kind), throat lozenges, and ibuprofen. Total cost? $20 USD.
- bhupy 6y agoThe Singapore "3 M" model largely takes advantage of transparent pricing and savings-account driven healthcare spending to bring down costs, as well as price controls to introduce an upper-bound to prices. It's, in my opinion, the paragon of what "healthy regulation" of markets looks like; the price controls don't undermine the market forces, and are instead crafted to complement them.
- dbtc 6y agoAgreed. But maybe Amazon.com has more potential to "disrupt" the US healthcare industry than any kind of traditional legislation. And... maybe that disruption could benefit actual people? (I really don't know) But I don't see the US government being able to do anything serious in the near term, with the forces of overpowered lobbying and general insanity working against it.
- kwanbix 6y agoNothing is freely available. Somebody is paying for it. In my case, I pay 800 euros per month, and then we can use it "freely". What you surely meant is universally available for all.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe cost per capita for healthcare in the US is $11k/person. Next highest is about $6k. This counts both public and private spending. We’ve picked the worst of each approach in the US and combined them.
- webmaven 6y ago> Nothing is freely available. Somebody is paying for it. In my case, I pay 800 euros per month, and then we can use it "freely". What you surely meant is universally available for all. In the US, most health plans include co-pays for various services, annual deductibles that delay the point that the insurance actually starts paying for things, and lifetime limits on the total amount the insurance can be required to pay. So people in the US usually have incentives to avoid using medical services unless they absolutely must. These incentives magically morph otherwise reasonable insurance plans into rather expensive versions of catastrophic insurance plans with a prescription benefit.
- InitialLastName 6y ago> I would much rather be able to request services in the way Amazon allows you to buy products than continue to engage in the current opaque system. Is a system where n% of the care is provided by unqualified/unlicensed providers masquerading (indistinguishably) as other, qualified providers, where the reviews are invariably fake, and from which both customers and providers can be banned from the system with no recourse for arbitrary reasons really something we want? Not to mention that people are different in their health needs, responses both physiological and psychological to treatment, and in their goals for healthcare. I didn't think much could make the US's current health system less transparent or effective, but on reflection I think Amazon taking their current marketplace strategy and applying it to the health industry with a wide brush might just do the trick.
- bhupy 6y agoThere's also other interesting competition in the space. I recommend checking out Forward: https://techcrunch.com/2021/03/11/forward-health-raises-225m-from-investors-including-the-weeknd-as-it-looks-to-expand-nationwide/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/03/11/forward-health-raises-225m... I think their thesis is aligned with Amazon: to decouple primary care from insurance as much as possible. Another interesting care provider is Curai which (like Amazon) mostly focuses on tele-health: https://curaihealth.com/ https://curaihealth.com/ Full disclosure: while I don't work for either of these companies, I do work on healthcare pricing and payments, and adjust claims; so I generally find news like this to be interesting and cool.
- SkyMarshal 6y agoJeff Bezos: "There are two kinds of companies, those that work to try to charge more and those that work to charge less. We will be the second." If he can do that with healthcare, it could be a godsend for a great many people currently suffering under the opaque, private-equity-rigged healthcare system the US currently has. Such a system is ripe for disruption. It seems to largely depend on what kind of healthcare quality and health outcomes Amazon can deliver while pushing prices down, as well as how Amazon can deal with the edge cases that currently account for the bulk of healthcare expenses in the current system. One litmus test for where they're heading with this is whether they publish fixed costs for medical procedures or not. That seems to be one necessary-but-maybe-not-sufficient requirement for getting this mess under control.