6 ms·
iTunes now costs $1.3 billion/yr to run
- Kylekramer 15y agoIt is quite a leap to assume it runs break even. I know Apple's people like to say it does, but numbers can be manipuated and I trust Apple is smart enough to optimize over the years to give themselves a small but healthy profit.
- ugh 15y agoLet's say 300 million? That would still mean that iTunes costs a billiom to run for a year. Saying that iTunes is run a bit over break even – which Apple did during their conference calls – while making something like 300 million is very likely illegal and not something Apple would do.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoYes,Apple is a white horse when it comes to financial and legal matters, right?
- ugh 15y agoI don't know, I have no evidence to claim that Apple routinely lies to shareholders. That's why I don't. I'm not particularly attached to that postion and willing to be convinced.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoJudging by your posting history, I am not surprised. http://www.eetimes.com/electronics-news/4068357/Apple-restates-acknowledges-faked-documents http://www.eetimes.com/electronics-news/4068357/Apple-restat... http://www.betanews.com/article/SEC-Charges-Former-Apple-Counsel-with-Fraud-Former-CFO-Settles/1177440019 http://www.betanews.com/article/SEC-Charges-Former-Apple-Cou... http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2008/07/steve-jobs-and-company-sued-for-stock-fraud.ars http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2008/07/steve-jobs-and-com... From the wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs#Stock_options_backdating_issue http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs#Stock_options_backda... Edit: Thanks for the silent downvotes with no replies. Here's the relevant quote from the first link: In the filings, Apple (Cupertino, Calif.) acknowledged that the company faked documentation to indicate that a grant of 7.5 million options to CEO Steve Jobs was recorded at a special meeting of the board of directors on Oct. 19, 2001. Such a meeting, Apple said, did not occur.
- chc 15y agoThose stories are all about one incident many years ago. Posting several articles about the same thing doesn't turn it into a trend. And since that scandal, Apple has been fastidious about obeying the letter of the law. Sarbanes-Oxley is practically Apple's religion.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoI was merely responding to the statement that 'illegal things are not something Apple would do' that was stated in a matter-of-fact manner. >And since that scandal, Apple has been fastidious about obeying the letter of the law And you would know this how? Just because there's nothing revealed right now doesn't mean there is nothing that is going on and might be revealed later. Of course this cuts both ways and I am certainly not implying that something shady is going on, but I am just curious about the free pass given to Apple on here on various things that other companies don't get.
- tjogin 15y agoNo, but they also aren't complete imbeciles. Apple are making money hand over fist overall. First of all, it would be astonishingly idiotic of them to break the law for such relatively little potential gain. Secondly, it wouldn't make any sense of them to nickel and dime customers for such a tiny little part of their overall business. This is peanuts to them. The AppStore's purpose is not to bring in a relatively tiny bit of profit to Apple, it purpose is providing reasons for developers to invest in their ecosystem, and for customers to buy their hardware, where their real money comes from.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- zdw 15y agoSo, is 30% too much of a cut when the platform offers: - Credit card processing - The largest marketplace with the most paying customers - Download hosting - Promotion - Highly available document and key/value store infrastructure - Keeping junk and malware out of the store, which maintains user trust. I'd argue that, like most emotionally influence business decisions, Apple sticking with the same percentage is a good thing - witness how the markets vary when things are up in the air politically. Keeping the same policies for a long time allows businesses to plan appropriately as they know what they're going to get, even if it's not ideal.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoThat may be a very good deal for some... but what if it's not or the people just want an alternative? If Apple's platform is that good, then there is no reason to lock in people to use only that, devs will flock to it anyway, it can stand on it's own merits. Or Amazon or someone else may come in and offer all of the above + more at only 20% because of their efficiencies (AWS etc.). Not to mention the still ongoing forced 30% of subscriptions fiasco for which Apple does not provide hosting.
- LokiSnake 15y agoThere is good reason to not offer alternatives. There will be platform fragmentation, and end up being a worse experience for both developers and users. Devs probably need to publish on all stores to cover their bases, otherwise users need to know which store to buy from or have to search for an app in every single store. Also, Apple has changed their subscriptions policy: http://www.macrumors.com/2011/06/09/apple-reverses-course-on-in-app-subscriptions/ http://www.macrumors.com/2011/06/09/apple-reverses-course-on...
- jonknee 15y agoI don't think the 30% has ever been an issue. The exclusivity is. Doubly so as Apple keeps changing the rules which if you're caught on the wrong side of can destroy your business.
- 15y ago
- chicagobob 15y agoActually, what Tim Cook said at the Apple's Financial Conference last quarter was that it runs "a little ahead of break even". Therefore, it is reasonable to say it runs at break even. Even if you are cynical and assume a certain amount of money is moved from one department to another, he can't say something on the record like that, if it isn't basically the truth (these numbers are audited and are subject to Sarbanes–Oxley. So, even assuming a small amount of shifting money around between departments and his fudge factor "a little", I think you could at most say single digits, for example: 5% if you want (or whatever small % you choose), it is still close enough for normal conversation to say its break even.
- borism 15y agothese numbers are audited and are subject to Sarbanes–Oxley AFAIK only if they're large enough to make a dent in overall AAPL financial picture.
- zitterbewegung 15y agoEven if it costs 1.3 billion to run a year Apple's profit from quarter to quarter vastly dwarfs that. Sort of like how it used to cost microsoft to create their xbox platform. I think it is worth it.
- int3rnaut 15y agoAs a gamer I was thinking about the exact same thing. When assessing this model do you think it matters that Microsoft has a monopoly on Xbox games, whereas Apple has a number of competitors in terms of App and Music services?
- recoiledsnake 15y agoWho are the competitors to Apple for iOS apps and games? Android and BlackBerry? On that metric,XBox has competitors in the form of PS3, Wii etc. Apple does have a monopoly on iOS games and apps.
- int3rnaut 15y agoI suppose that's true, I think I was looking at things with more of a lens towards music.
- leviathant 15y agoAnecdote: When I buy music, I either buy it from Amazon MP3 or direct from the artist via Bandcamp.
- smackfu 15y agoToo bad Apple doesn't break it down a bit: iTunes music: must make money. There is no review process, the labels handle everything, and the file sizes are tiny. iBooks: Probably loses money, based on a gut feeling for how many people are actually buying books on iBooks vs Amazon. Mac App Store: Probably losing money at this point. iOS App Store: Could be break even I suppose. Obviously lose money on free apps, plus the review process can't be cheap.
- recoiledsnake 15y ago>iOS App Store: Could be break even I suppose. Obviously lose money on free apps, plus the review process can't be cheap. Free apps still need a $99/yr developer fee, though one could submit a whole lot of free apps.
- smackfu 15y agoI just looked and Apple hires iOS reviewers as full-time US employees with a CS degree. No salary listed, but I would guess that's around $100/hr cost to Apple. So one hour spent on reviewing a free app and now Apple is losing money.
- jfoutz 15y agoAfter the first, because you still have to register as a developer
- rsynnott 15y agoI would have called music the least likely one to be making money, actually. A common usage pattern is buying one or two songs in a sitting, at which point transaction charges really become significant, and it has always seemed that the record labels take the lion's share of the payment. iTunes TV, on the other hand, is probably more profitable, due to higher unit cost. Books almost _must_ be profitable, because they're in the same range as Kindle books, and Amazon wouldn't be pushing ebooks (and thus damaging their traditional book market) so hard if they couldn't make a profit on them.
- briandoll 15y agoAlso of note, according to the article they spend $2.5 B on developers (ops likely included in that stat). Another data point to illustrate that to effect total cost of ownership on a given system, focusing on developer productivity can have a greater impact than operational efficiencies.
- jfruh 15y agoCan someone help a poor liberal arts major? I see "costs $1.3 billion to run" and I think "Apple loses $1.3b a year on the iTunes store." But reading the article and the constant Apple talk about breaking even makes me think that what they're trying to get at is "the infrastructure for the store and payments to artists and app creators costs $1.3b a year, but Apple's 30 percent cut of everything produces about $1.3b a year in revenue, so it all works out," which is a very different proposition, yes?
- cooldeal 15y agoYour first thought is wrong, because "costs" is very different from "takes a loss of".
- jfruh 15y agoWell, OK, but is my second thought right?
- ugh 15y agoApple's revenue is $1.3 billion and since they about break even their costs are about $1.3 billion. Your second thought is consequently not in line with how cost is usually defined. If you are using the usual definition of cost the title of the submission is not misleading. Price is what you charge your customers, cost is what you have to pay to make the product, revenue is the number of sold products times the price, profit (or loss) is revenue minus number of sold products times the cost.
- pflats 15y agoAlmost. The site quotes the money that Apple keeps "after paying content owners but before paying for other costs". The 1.3 billion doesn't include paying the record/movie labels, bands, or app developers, but does include everything else. In other words, "the infrastructure for the store and payments to everyone other than artists and app creators costs $1.3b a year, but Apple's 30 percent cut of everything produces about $1.3b a year in revenue, so it all works out."
- supercanuck 15y agoAt risk of sounding like a broken record, would it help to know that Apple/iTunes runs SAP?
- guelo 15y agoiTunes store is an integral part of iDevices, they couldn't sell the things without it. They're trying to separate out the cost to try to justify their fees but it doesn't make any sense because it should be built into the price of the devices. Before the app store existed Apple still provided the iTunes store service to customers for free with the purchase of the device.
- Stormbringer 15y agoOkay... so if 70% of the take is 2.5 billion, that means the total amount taken in is 3.57 billion and change. So Apple gains 1.07 billion with their 30% cut and spends 1.30 billion? In other words, Apple digs into their own pocket for 230 million dollars in order to run it? And people still complain about Apple's 30% cut. Wow.
- trotsky 15y agoFrom the article: If we add the content margins from music and apps ---> and assume the store runs at break even <--- we can get an idea of what it costs to operate the store. Asymco's analysis always seems to have some completely unsupported claim at the center of its logic, thrown in almost as an aside. The portion marked with arrows is the questionable bit this time. While the numbers aren't broken out directly in their market filings, it is both obvious from their behavior, and support by quite a number of analysts that the App Store(s) return significant operating profit to Apple. Cook suggests they run the service "just a bit ahead of break even" which would suggest that they're up instead of down, but even that presumably dubiously includes a large swath of media buys that are arguably more promotional for the ecosystem as a whole than simply getting iPhone users to go buy an album or app today. There's a reason that they don't break it out: pissing off their content partners. Think about it. You don't fight tooth and nail for 30% on bringing content in house (ebooks, etc.) if you're somehow only going to break even on it or worse. Just on the face of it, it's wildly improbable that you could spend over a billion dollars operating ITMS.
- Stormbringer 15y agoJust on the face of it, it's wildly improbable that you could spend over a billion dollars operating ITMS. Surely it isn't that much of a stretch? I'd be surprised if the music companies weren't taking a big chunk of that, and server/bandwidth costs the lion's share of whatever scraps are left.
- zmmmmm 15y agoI think it's missing the point to even talk about the operational cost of running the iTunes store. It's a strategic play equivalent to the setting up of tollgates on rivers in medieval times. The one most consistent theme across all of Apple's decisions is to not let go of a vice like control of access by third parties to their platform. My personal belief is that they know the future value of owning the tollgate that everyone must pass through to get digital products and information to consumers is far greater than even their hardware business is today. It may not manifest in raw numbers directly (yet) but in terms of the position of power it puts them in its value is incalculable.
- patrickgzill 15y agoIt is part of their (Apple's) ecosystem, so it really is just sales and general admin. expenses at this point.