13 ms·
EGA Monkey Island is similarly beautiful. I feel EGA forced artists to work within the limitations of the available color palette, and good artists created awe
by the_af 6y ago
EGA Monkey Island is similarly beautiful.
I feel EGA forced artists to work within the limitations of the available color palette, and good artists created awesome stuff (like shown in this case). Once they had VGA, some artists rushed to use every color gradient they could get away with, and this ruined their art till they got the hang of it.
Something similar happened with the transition from pixel art to 3D games -- games were 3D because they had to, whether necessary or not. And many suffered from it. (Arguably, many still do!)
Of course, I hold the extremist opinion that even some CGA (4 colors!) games were beautiful in their own way. I don't think more is always better, a lesson that seems to be lost on some game developers...
- Akronymus 6y agoCGA shines on a crt, usually. Some CGA games just look stunning with CRT/composite https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHXx3orN35Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHXx3orN35Y
- the_af 6y agoIndeed. I found out about CGA's amazing composite output only recently, watching a video by The 8 Bit guy. I was completely unaware of this back in the day...
- babypuncher 6y agoIt shines on a CRT with composite input. It's still the same eye-piercing nastiness people are familiar with today if you used an RGB monitor like the IBM 5153, which IBM marketed for use with the CGA card.
- short_sells_poo 6y agoPerhaps I'm just looking at things through rose tinted glasses, but I very much agree with this. I like to think that good pixel art works with the imagination. The artist puts down the broad strokes and lets the imagination fill the rest! There is a huge amount of skill that goes into good pixel art. It's not enough to have attention to detail, but an intuition about engaging and working with imagination. The more realistic the graphics, the higher the risk that it falls into the uncanny valley trap. The brain is already half fooled that it is seeing reality (or something that is supposed to be real) but if it's only slightly off, there'll be a feeling of unease. Of course, early 3d games were far off from feeling real, but they were already a step up and there was less headroom for imagination. The low polygon count models just look janky instead of endearing. Pixel art completely sidesteps this uncanny valley by not trying to be realistic, instead it tries to engage the brain to fill in the details. It's perhaps halfway between reading a book and watching a movie. E.g. looking at early 3d games, they just feel dated. One cannot help but compare them to today's 3d graphics and of course the oldies fall short by a very far margin. Comparing pixel art games to a modern AAA 3D game title is just so obviously apples to oranges that there is no struggle due to loss of fidelity. Again, perhaps my view is biased because I grew up with the pixelated games of old. Still, I'd like to assign the excitement of the early 3d titles more to the novelty (at the time) than from the fidelity of the graphics. I think the pixel art style will (or already does) have much more staying power.
- the_af 6y ago> I like to think that good pixel art works with the imagination. Fully agreed with this and the rest of your post. Are you familiar with Scott McCloud's "Understanding Comics"? I'm not particularly a fan of the whole book, but I really agree and am fascinated by the concept of "closure" he describes: the way the mind "fills in" the details that are missing in sequential art (i.e. comics), so you mentally create movement and detail when there is objectively none. This even works for storytelling itself, from a few "action" frames you mentally reconstruct the story, and this requires little effort. I think the same happens with pixel or line art. You just need some cues and then your brain gets to work on creating the scene.
- m16ghost 6y ago>E.g. looking at early 3d games, they just feel dated. One cannot help but compare them to today's 3d graphics and of course the oldies fall short by a very far margin. Comparing pixel art games to a modern AAA 3D game title is just so obviously apples to oranges that there is no struggle due to loss of fidelity. >Again, perhaps my view is biased because I grew up with the pixelated games of old. Still, I'd like to assign the excitement of the early 3d titles more to the novelty (at the time) than from the fidelity of the graphics. I think the pixel art style will (or already does) have much more staying power. I happen to agree that early 3d games like PS1/N64 look rather ugly, but nostalgia is very powerful, and retro low poly models is now its own aesthetic [0]. Like with pixel art, artists will take liberties with what was actually capable with hardware at the time, but people who grew up with the style will probably appreciate it more. [0]https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/321754/Designing_a_demake_in_2018_The_making_of_PS1_love_letter_OKNORMAL.php https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/321754/Designing_a_demak...
- majormajor 6y agoI never played this Indiana Jones game, or have much memory of other EGA games that I can think of, and to me, 90% of the VGA screenshots in this article look better than the EGA ones. To me, the limited color palette doesn't strike me as a differently meaningful sort of limitation than, say, the appearance of Mario 64 vs Mario Galaxy. The imagination always fills in the gap - I don't remember KOTOR looking worse than Mass Effect looking worse than Mass Effect Andromeda, say, but if I go back and look at them, they definitely were more limited - but if you don't have the memory of just how much your imagination originally filled in, I think it's harder to look past the actual pixels.
- foobarian 6y agoSpeaking of CGA, Defender of the Crown was my favorite. https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/defender-of-the-crown/screenshots/gameShotId,332308/ https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/defender-of-the-crown/scr...
- the_af 6y agoGorgeous! Thanks for sharing. I think CGA is an extreme case of "working with limitations/constraints". It was hard to get it right, but when they did, as in this case, it was awesome.
- tclancy 6y agoMan, I must have had hundreds of hours into that! Always go with the Greek fire.
- p1mrx 6y ago2-bit pr0n: https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/defender-of-the-crown/screenshots/gameShotId,332297/ https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/defender-of-the-crown/scr...
- stupidcar 6y ago100% agree. It's telling that most contemporary pixel artists work by choice with a limited palette. The actual number of colors, even in complex pieces, is often shockingly small.
- mrob 6y agoThe early LucasArts VGA games look worse than their EGA versions, but their artists learned to use VGA better. The Dig makes great use of VGA color. https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/dig/screenshots https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/dig/screenshots
- the_af 6y agoAgreed! And what an amazing game The Dig was. I liked that it was less "humorous" than the standard adventure fare, too.
- tptacek 6y agoOf course, I hold the extremist opinion that even some CGA (4 colors!) games were beautiful in their own way. I agree! I have a CGA game still inked on my left arm (in case any of you ever need to identify my headless corpse).
- the_af 6y agoWhich game?
- tptacek 6y agoThe Black Cauldron.
- codetrotter 6y agoCan we get to see a picture of your tattoo? It sounds cool!
- borisjabes 6y agoI really thought this game/book was lost in time. Glad to know there's a fellow pig herder fan.
- fullstop 6y agoLast Crusade supported CGA. I don't know how it was implemented, though -- it looks like dithering was used at least to emulate some of the EGA colors. [1] That wasn't the only change, through. I remember that there is a rotisserie in the castle which rotates in EGA/VGA, but does not in CGA, so they likely knew that the computers with CGA could not handle the animation as well. 1. https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/indiana-jones-and-the-last-crusade-the-graphic-adventure/screenshots/gameShotId,961433/ https://www.mobygames.com/game/dos/indiana-jones-and-the-las...
- aasasd 6y agoFrankly those screenshots in CGA look like 90% dithering and are pretty hard to take in.
- the_af 6y agoYes, to me those are examples where CGA didn't work well. It wasn't suitable for this kind of scenes. This cyan-magenta-white default palette was also pretty jarring; the green-red-yellow one was better looking.
- moonbug 6y agobut when viewed on a composite monitor, you see something quite different. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_artifact_colors https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_artifact_colors
- fullstop 6y agoYeah, it feels like someone was told that they needed to support CGA a few weeks before the final deadline.
- jonny_eh 6y agoIMO, nothing looks good in CGA. It's not just that it's 4 colours, it's 4 awful colours. I'd take a 1-bit Mac game over CGA.
- apozem 6y agoAs someone with no nostalgia for the PSX/N64, it's hard not to look back on that as an entire generation of ugly graphics. SNES pixel art has aged beautifully, Cloud's polygons have not. That's not even counting the many, many games with wonky cameras. It feels like cameras were not widely figured out until the 360/PS3 generation.
- MetaWhirledPeas 6y ago> Of course, I hold the extremist opinion that even some CGA (4 colors!) games were beautiful in their own way. This is one reason I appreciate Downwell. You unlock new 4-color palettes as you progress. Some are really nice to look at and completely change the mood of the game.
- the_af 6y agoWhat is Downwell?
- aasasd 6y agoSeems like another one of those games with a few colors and swappable palettes. ‘Down Ward’ does that too: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/fisholith/down-ward-owl-flight-pixel-art-platformer https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/fisholith/down-ward-owl... (or would do if it was funded—not sure of its fate).
- the_af 6y agoOooh, now that I've seen it I like Downwell. To me it has a distinct "Speccy" vibe to it. It's not just pixel art, it looks like a ZX Spectrum game!
- aasasd 6y agoMac games of the old are known for 1-bit graphics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y01lZbrxxb0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y01lZbrxxb0 Not much to look at, but plays well into the noir theme in this case. The aesthetic recently had a resurgence in the indie scene, with ‘Obra Dinn’ and whatnot. Many gamemakers especially reminisce about Gameboy's four-color palette. Some modern low-color games might have more than two colors, but are designed essentially in grayscale and allow switching the whole palette: https://pioneersgame.tumblr.com/post/112307966203/i-doubt-theres-anything-new-in-this-for-anyone https://pioneersgame.tumblr.com/post/112307966203/i-doubt-th... Though of course, this time the four colors aren't some arbitrary acid-neon colors, but are chosen by the authors.
- incanus77 6y agoI had a PCjr in the 90s, which meant that most games were CGA unless I happened to find one that supported the rare-but-more-common-than-native-PCjr-EGA Tandy TGA 16-color mode, in which case I’d get 16 colors. Every game acquisition was a crapshoot to see if I was lucky or not. Native EGA was out.
- the_af 6y agoI only owned PC clones. I discovered the Tandy in that 8 Bit Guy video in which he argues it was the best DOS gaming computer. I wish I had owned one!
- Lio 6y agoMy first PC XT clone had Hercules and CGA on an orange monitor. 4 shades of a single colour isn't so bad. Really wish I hadn't sold it now as I did a lot on that machine. Even ran Windows 2.0 passably. I really, really wanted something capable of playing Wolfenstein though so it had to go. :(
- the_af 6y agoMy first PC XT clone also ran Hercules with an ambar monitor. SIMCGA FTW! I still feel very nostalgic about that look & feel. I programmed my first real graphics using that hardware. (I started with a Commodore 64, but I was too young and didn't really manage to output graphics with it).
- Tarq0n 6y agoThe same thing applies to MIDI music from the same era. Though I'm not sure how much of it was related to the technology and how much was the culture or aesthetic influences of game makers at the time.
- Al-Khwarizmi 6y agoIndeed, the transition from pixel art to 3D games really set back the beauty of the games for some years. The Last Blade II (1998), IMHO the pinnacle of 2D fighting games (both in terms of graphics and replayability): https://www.nintendolife.com/games/neogeo/last_blade_2/screenshots https://www.nintendolife.com/games/neogeo/last_blade_2/scree... Virtua Fighter (1993), pioneering 3D fighting game: https://www.mobygames.com/game/arcade/virtua-fighter/screenshots/gameShotId,654794/ https://www.mobygames.com/game/arcade/virtua-fighter/screens... IMHO even Tekken IV (2001), released three years after The Last Blade II, aged worse and looks uglier today: https://www.fightersgeneration.com/games/tekken4-p2.html https://www.fightersgeneration.com/games/tekken4-p2.html
- chrisweekly 6y agoYes! Limitations inspire creativity; necessity is the mother of invention; video games from the earliest days of the industry / art form have (by far) the most replayability and "fun per pixel" or whatever metric you care to choose.
- organsnyder 6y agoThe sunset over the dock on Mêlée Island is simply stunning. Amazing what the artists could do with 16 colors.