4 ms·
>> Focus on media literacy, critical thinking and digital literacy. That is just another arms race. I think it naïve to assume that people can be educated out
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> Focus on media literacy, critical thinking and digital literacy.
That is just another arms race. I think it naïve to assume that people can be educated out of this problem. Some people can be, but large numbers will always fall for a good hoax. What we need is laws and policies to address the problem. The good news is that this problem is nothing new. The laws are already on the books.
Imho this is something that the law can manage so long as the legal system is allowed to run its course. People publishing true deepfakes, not parodies but actual attempts to fool people, should face the same slander and defamation charges that previous fakes have for centuries. Even copyright law has tests to draw lines between legitimate parody and improper fakery. Hustler v. Falwell (the Larry Flint case) was about a literary deepfake, a sham interview in a porn magazine. Those who take deepfake too far, or republish such material, open themselves to legal attack. Let the lawyers do their thing.
- eivarv 6y agoI agree on the regulation-part, but I still think many more are able to be educated (at least partway) out of the problem than are given an opportunity. And laws have retroactive impact via e.g. police and courts. Education would have a preventive impact.
- achow 6y agoThe problem is - law is slow. Law has its place, but we also need detection techniques to prevent the quick consequences that rumors and fake media can bring - 'doxing', public shaming, mob lynching, etc.
- admax88q 6y agoWhat if we took the other approach. Currently fake media can bring all sorts of negative consequences because people are conditioned to trust media to a degree. "Most" of the media is true-ish, so a well crafted hoax will be believed by many. But what if we saturated the media with convincing deep fakes. I feel like there's an inflection point, where people are exposed to so much believable but contradictory fake news, that they might develop a natural distrust of anything presented to them. Believing that the media is for the most part true, sets you up to be manipulated or misled when the media gets it wrong.
- Xylakant 6y agoWhat's the result of this? That would mean I basically can no longer believe anything at all which is reported anywhere. Which means my knowledge of events shrinks down to what I can verify personally - which is a regression to pre-print times.
- QuercusMax 6y agoThis is also a propaganda technique made famous by Putin's Russia - the Firehose of Falsehood. Make people so unsure of everything they don't know what to believe, which makes them easier to manipulate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firehose_of_falsehood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firehose_of_falsehood
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pizza 6y agoYou would probably get something that is worse than the status quo, in my opinion. When people feel like they cannot trust anything generally that's quite bad.
- admax88q 6y agoDeepfake laws won't do anything. You're not going to prosecute a disinformation campaign from a foreign power. The only way that would work is if you were to lock down and censor the entire information distributed to your population. Which obviously has its own problems.