4 ms·
> The 42-year-old says he first invested $40,000 in Bitcoin in 2017, and quickly made his money back as the value of the coins rose on the open market. He cashe
by viraptor 6y ago
> The 42-year-old says he first invested $40,000 in Bitcoin in 2017, and quickly made his money back as the value of the coins rose on the open market. He cashed out and got his initial money back, but then watched excitedly over the years as the 10 coins grew to be worth nearly 500,000 euros.
Fortunately this sounds like he didn't lose anything, just never realised extra gains. I know it's slightly nitpicking, but losing your actual $500k and losing $500k unrealised gains from a gamble is a massive difference. Especially if you already withdrew the original investment.
- alisonkisk 6y agoRight. This guy was happy when the unregulated Wild West made him a fortune for doing no work, but started crying for regulation when he was on the bad side of a trade.
- WA 6y agoNo. This is a common way to think about it, but it's wrong imho. Because that money is real and it buys you real stuff. If you have that money one day and it is gone the next, you effectively lost that money. It doesn't matter where it came from. Think about it: You inherit $500k. You lose it through a scam or a bet or gambling. Do you think it doesn't matter? I mean, you didn't earn that money yourself, right? There are no paper losses and no "unrealized gains". It's your money and if it's gone, it's gone. Doesn't matter how you earned it.
- shawnz 6y agoI agree with you, he lost real money. But I also agree with the other poster: it's hard to feel bad for him gambling away money that he got by gambling to begin with.
- ImprobableTruth 6y agoBut it's not real money, it's an asset! I think you have a wrong understanding of what unrealized gains are. It's not about whether you earned it yourself - it's about whether it's liquid cash or just an asset. Only once you sell your asset do you realize your gains.
- shawnz 6y agoAs I asked in the other part of this thread: Would you feel differently if he sold the bitcoins and then immediately bought them again before participating in the scam? Of course not. Even though that would make them "realized", that has no impact on the situation
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Bancakes 6y agoEasy come, easy go. I was never planning on a $500k inheritance, it was just a good bonus.
- D13Fd 6y agoFor tax purposes, in the U.S., what he had at the time was an unrealized gain. So if he later went to convert that Bitcoin into U.S. dollars, he would have a taxable event (i.e., if he cashed out the whole thing, he would owe taxes on the difference between his basis and the value at the time). I don't know how it works in Germany though.
- isthisreality 6y agoThis would be a good way to launder Bitcoin to yourself without paying taxes on it. Could that be what this is?
- WA 6y agoGermany ditched the holding period a while back for stocks. You pay 25% plus a little bit (26.375% in reality) on every gain, no matter if you hold it for 10 years or for two seconds. Bitcoin is tax-free after a holding period of 1 year afaik. If you lose $500k, you don't owe taxes, congratulations. But you still lost money (even if you maybe only lost $300k, because the rest would've been taxes).
- superflit 6y ago"Fortunately this sounds like he didn't lose anything, just never realised extra gains." Sounds like if someones house caught fire the owner did not loose anything because he did not sell it? That were His bitcoins he was the owner of the bicoins and he was scammed.
- viraptor 6y agoI think this is a bad comparison. His situation would be closer to buying a house for $40k, making $40k renting it out. Then someone tells you you could probably sell the house now for $500k, but you don't and instead you gamble it away. You never had the $500k to begin with. You had a house people say could be possibly worth that much.
- shawnz 6y agoThere is no question he really could have exchanged the coins for $500k of value though. If he had sold the bitcoins for cash and then used the cash to buy bitcoins again immediately after so that he could send them to the scammer, then would they be "realized" as opposed to "unrealized", even though there's no practical difference between the two situations?
- viraptor 6y agoIt's the same situation. You don't have $500k - you have an opportunity to get $500k if you do things right. If it's kept as BTC, there's a number of things that could bring the value to $0 without the scam.
- shawnz 6y agoI think this is a pointless distinction. A 500k bank balance is just an "opportunity" to withdraw 500k of cash. There are a number of things that could bring your bank balance to $0 without the scam. 500k of cash is just an "opportunity" to extract 500k of value. etc.