5 ms·
"left" indeed -- I have been a pretty radical socialist since I was 16. (Well, at least on paper, I haven't been done activist work for years) ... And I don't r
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
"left" indeed -- I have been a pretty radical socialist since I was 16. (Well, at least on paper, I haven't been done activist work for years) ... And I don't recognize myself in this "left" that people keep talking about. I think it's hilarious to call CNN "left" or think that anybody in GitHub leadership is "left" for relabeling git branches. Plz. It's just a proposterous strange (and uniquely American) partitioning of the world.
If you define "left" as anything "not far right" then, yeah, ok, of course it's going to include a bunch of liberals who are not interested in any real structural change in the political-economic system and so are obsessed instead with changing how people speak.
So I just don't use the word anymore if I can. I'm not "left wing", I'm a socialist... Unfortunately "socialist" also seems to mean something weird to many Americans, too. (That anybody could with a straight face call Obama or Biden socialist just boggles my mind...)
- aspnet_dev 6y agoIf you want to understand why Biden and Obama are called socialists, I suggest you do some reading of the Anarcho-Capitalist literature (Anatomy of the State is the most obvious) or maybe listen to someone like Peter Schiff. I don't agree with their philosophy as I believe it to be unrealistic but their criticisms and descriptions of what the state is and isn't is valid and why some call it socialist may make more sense to you. Hans Herman Hoppe (I am sure someone will quote mine him to smear him after I've mentioned him and haven't read any of this books) even called Democracy a soft form of communism.
- chickenpotpie 6y agoBiden and Obama are called socialists because Americans were trained to fear communism and socialism during the Cold War. There is nothing about their political stance that is socialist. Conservatives have just learned that they can score easy points by calling anyone left of Ronald Reagan a marxist
- aspnet_dev 6y ago> There is nothing about their political stance that is socialist. Yes there is. There is a tonne of stuff that is explicitly socialist. In the UK my boss (who is from the UK) has recently said that the Biden Administration is more socialist than the previous administration. The news here has said it. It got nothing to do with the cold-war. It is to do with their policies.
- chickenpotpie 6y agoBiden is socialist because your boss said so?
- aspnet_dev 6y agoI will spell it out for you. If there are quite a lot of people outside of the US that consider him to be much more socialist (and there are quite a few) than Trump, then it cannot just be "American conservatives" that are claiming this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chickenpotpie 6y agoYour argument is based off a quote i didn’t say. I never said “American conservatives” I said conservatives
- aspnet_dev 6y agoYou said: > Conservatives have just learned that they can score easy points by calling anyone left of Ronald Reagan a marxist
- malandrew 6y ago> There is nothing about their political stance that is socialist. I don't know how anyone can make this statement with a straight face. What about ObamaCare?
- majjgepolja 6y agoI am not american, so can somebody explain why this comment is downvoted? So that I can avoid such mistakes in words usage when I come to america?