4 ms·
I don't think companies paying their taxes - in the USA at least - would help much on the education side of things, because much of the USA has a stunningly bad
by simonw 6y ago
I don't think companies paying their taxes - in the USA at least - would help much on the education side of things, because much of the USA has a stunningly bad system of using property taxes to pay for schools.
So schools in rich areas get more money than schools in poor areas.
Charging companies taxes and simultaneously reforming how schools are funded could work?
I imagine changing the funding mechanism would be extremely politically unpopular with homeowners who's property values are attached to the quality of their local schools.
It's such a gross system.
- systemvoltage 6y agoOnly about half of the funding comes from local sources. > On average, 8% of revenues are federal, 47% from the state, and 45% locally sourced. And this varies widely from state to state.
- moduspol 6y agoDoes evidence show more school funding would fix underperforming public schools?
- jaywalk 6y agoYou can find studies that support either side of that argument. So I guess the answer is: it's more complicated than that.
- moduspol 6y agoAre there records of any US public schools that were underperforming, were given notably more funding, and saw a corresponding increase in test scores or other objective metrics? EDIT: I guess I'm looking for the success stories. "Here's an inner-city school and the outcomes were bad. Then we increased funding and now their outcomes are comparable to good schools."
- jaywalk 6y agoNone that I'm aware of. I live outside of Detroit, so I'm very familiar with the example of how the absolute bottom-tier Detroit Public Schools spend more per student than some of the richest (and highest performing) school districts in the suburbs.
- castlecrasher2 6y agoI've heard precisely the opposite, though that was an anecdote from Milton Friedman, so take that how you will.
- mLuby 6y agoIt's common sense that a school with more money can hire more and better teachers as well as remove barriers to learning like food insecurity and lack of textbooks/computers. The burden of proof falls on the counterintuitive claim that the same school would have the same sustained effectiveness regardless of funding.
- moduspol 6y agoNobody claimed that all schools (or schools in general) will have the same outcomes regardless of funding. It's quite possible parent engagement and cultural differences are stronger drivers for positive outcomes, and that those things lead to higher funding for schools. But that doesn't imply higher funding causes positive outcomes. They're just correlated. Many of our nation's underperforming schools are located in urban areas with no shortage of funds available and under the control of the political party supporting this idea. Yet the issue remains unsolved. Is there any level of funding that would lead proponents to acknowledge funding may not be the primary issue?
- varispeed 6y agoThere is another problem regardless of how good education you get chances are you'll become a wage slave. The harder you work, the increasingly more tax you have to pay, so making effort does not pay these days. Then you have things like illegal drug market teasing the youth, as the margins are high and tax free. I thing just making the schools better will not have much effect, because young people have no motivation to do better as they'll have mediocre lives regardless of how much effort they put in education as the system is designed for the poor to stay poor.
- dpcx 6y agoI can tell you first hand that "the youth" aren't thinking about margins and taxes when they are deciding between taking a job and joining the illegal drug market. They're thinking about how long it takes to earn a dollar.
- varispeed 6y agoYes, they don't think about it directly, but this is what is responsible for how long they need to work to make a dollar. I thought that is obvious... Essentially in the legal market, the more you work, the less you get thanks to progressive tax.
- confidantlake 6y agoThe taxation scheme makes virtually 0 difference. No one working as a software engineer is thinking, man this progressive tax is too high, time to quit facebook and sell crack. People working min wage are paying way less tax under a progressive taxation scheme. I really don't understand this thinking.
- brandmeyer 6y ago> because much of the USA has a stunningly bad system of using property taxes to pay for schools. This might have been true once upon a time, but pushes in State and Federal funding over the last couple of decades have mostly filled in the gaps. Take a careful look at district funding per-pupil in your state and you might be surprised. While there certainly are differences, they are nowhere near as large as they were in the past.
- mavelikara 6y ago> Take a careful look at district funding per-pupil in your state Off-topic, but where can I find this data for CA?
- mrep 6y agoThis website has extremely informative visualizations that show how state and federal funding for school fills in those gaps: https://apps.urban.org/features/school-funding-do-poor-kids-get-fair-share/ https://apps.urban.org/features/school-funding-do-poor-kids-...
- brandmeyer 6y agoNot really off-topic, IMO. The state department of education has it for state-level statistics in CO and NC. CO even publishes a browser in map form. Local school districts publish their own local budgets in these states, too. That doesn't directly answer your question, but that's where I think you should start.