10 ms·
When hard books disappear
- flipbrad 15y agoit could be interesting to monitor the gradual disappearance of physical copies of books by (for example) monitoring the frequency of listings of that book on ebay, or the amazon marketplace (based on the assumption that books that perish are not re-listed, although I'll admit that books are 'sticky' and could bounce around owners until settling with owners who are keenest to hold on to them long term, so you'd perhaps expect decreasing market volume/listing frequency even without any perishing)
- singular 15y agoI think this is a noble aim, however isn't this partly the duty of national libraries such as the British Library[1] and the Library of Congress[2]? Having said that, perhaps the point is to take such archives out of the hands of government organisations? [1]:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_library http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_library [2]:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_congress http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_congress
- jonknee 15y agoPart of it seems to be that for copyright they want to own the physical books that they have scans of. Instead of destroying the books in the process like is common, they are taking care to preserve the books.
- singular 15y agoAgreed, that's clearly part of it, but the overall thrust of the article seems to be 'if we don't do this physical books will disappear', which seems to be duplicating the work of national libraries. It's a pity they seem to gloss over that, since the duplication of that effort does need some justification - perhaps the national libraries don't cover enough foreign books? Or they don't trust the government? Also it's a bit misleading, acting as if it doesn't already happen.
- jerf 15y agoOn the broad scale of history, neither national governments, nor their commitments to historical preservation, are something you can rely on. I do not mean this as a modern-day political snark at any particular government, I mean this as a historical comment. Of course there's no guarantee your archive will survive indefinitely either, but if we treasure them and have several of them the odds go up substantially.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mechanical_fish 15y agoIt is partly a matter of redundancy. Unthinkable as it might be, libraries do burn. They do have budget cuts. They get burglarized. Their archivists make mistakes. Better three universal libraries than two. Better four than three. When we're sure we have too many we'll deal with that; they are far easier to destroy than create. It is true that things might be more efficient if everyone pooled resources and, say, kept track of the fact that we have ten distributed copies of Book X in the world but only three of Y, so we should be looking out for more copies of Y. Which brings us to a second reason to start a new public archive: as a pilot project to explore different ways of running public archives. Modern infotech is evolving fast; presumably there is lots of room to experiment with different strategies, and the national libraries have only so much budget for research.
- astine 15y agoI do work for the Library of Congress and no, it is not part of the mission of the Library to maintain a physical copy of every book ever written, though it does have extensive collections. Regardless, having redundancy in efforts will only make the efforts more effective. Edit: To expound on my last point, It not just redundancy in the collections, but redundancy in the effort which is important. If the LoC stores two copies of the same book in two geographically dispersed locations but makes the same brain-dead mistake in preservation process at both, then it doesn't matter that there were two copies. Entirely separate organizations using entirely separate methodologies are much safer than one organization. The general process for storing these books seems to be very different than that of the Library so it is good that he is duplicating the effort.
- gwern 15y ago> it is not part of the mission of the Library to maintain a physical copy of every book ever written I read once that the only things the Library is legally required to keep copies of are original author holographs; I don't know if that is true.
- Peroni 15y agoInteresting article however I don't think I'll ever grasp the concept that physical books could one day disappear entirely from the household. If you take an example as puerile as my son's latest acquisition 'Where is little duck?', I struggle to see how an electronic replacement can supersede the physical interaction he has with the different textures and the constant struggle he has learning how to turn one page at a time (he's only 13 months old btw!). I love ebook technology and whilst I can't justify the cost of a kindle currently, I could definitely see myself reading more if I had one but I think to say that technology will render physical books defunct is sensationalism.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoAnd yet your example is squarely in the center of the problem. How many children's books from 1850 are in your house? How many children's books from 1950 are in your house? What percentage of your own children's books are still in your possession? Children's books have a very short shelf life. New ones get published all the time. A very tiny percentage become Curious George and get reprinted for decades, but the rest go out of print. The printed copies get used by children and therefore become ragged and nasty. In ten years you will have thrown them away. Hopefully you will have thrown them away: Clutter is no good either. If we want to preserve them it should not be your house's job. This is why archiving is hard. It is why backups are hard. It all seems so redundant when the objects are shiny and new and sitting right there, they're in the stores, they're on all your iDevices, they're all over YouTube. And then one day you wake up and the original film of your 1970s-era Oscar-winning movie has fallen apart. This actually happens! You've got to think ahead. The danger of the digital era is that we get tempted to rely on a number of physical copies that is so small that we get blindsided by black-swan accidents. That's what this is really about. The movie Metropolis was ultimately saved because it was distributed in physical copies and a film archive in Argentina didn't throw theirs away like everybody else. That sort of thing is in danger of stopping. Make copies!
- Peroni 15y agoI am 100% in favour of archiving and I agree with your point entirely. My frustration is directed towards those who believe that within the next few decades, printed books will be obsolete.
- davidw 15y agoI don't think books will disappear. I could see a divergence, though: High quality, "collectible" books kept for their prestige value. "Consumable" books that you read for fun or to learn something fairly current (not timeless) drift more and more towards ebooks. In other words, people buy Knuth's books to adorn their office shelves with, but probably won't feel the same way about putting "Twilight" (or worse) there, even if they enjoy reading them.
- SatvikBeri 15y agoI think there will be a major shift with the next generation. A lot of the reasons for keeping hardcover books are due to tradition/"I grew up with this therefore I like it"-similarly to music. I agree that consumable books will disappear faster than collectible books. In fact, I believe Amazon released statistics a while back showing pulp fiction sells better (compared to paper copy sales) than pretty much any other genre on the Kindle. But I am not so sure collectible books will be around in 30 or 50 years. By then, the concept of a bookshelf may seem hopelessly backwards. A lot of the historical symbols of pride have become meaningless (or at least significantly less appreciated), why wouldn't paper copies of Knuth's books follow?
- stephen_g 15y agoI don't know if there is such a big similarity to music... We interact directly with a book, so using an ebook is a very different experience. But listening to music sounds pretty much the same whether the source is a computer, my phone, or a CD. Maybe it is just because I grew up with books, but I really prefer to actually hold a real book to read it (although I do read ebooks when it's more convenient). The tactile experience of a real book is something that I think ebooks will have a very hard time trying to surpass. So I think that there will always be a place for them. Although perhaps I'm starting to sound like someone who will only listen to music on LPs!
- davidw 15y agoBooks have also been with us for a long time, far longer than vinyl, cassette tapes, 8-tracks, CD's, etc....
- nirvdrum 15y agoI'm really lamenting the demise of physical books and am happy I went through college when I did. Without a doubt having a whole volume of books at hand in a lightweight device is awesome. But reading a book is about much more than just the content to me. None of the devices on the market adequately model how I interact with a book and I think fundamentally they can't. E.g., I constantly refer back to previously read material. I never know 100% where it is or know in advance that I'm going, but I have a rough idea of where it was by the thickness of the book. If I'm reading a novel, I like to refer to some previous dialog. If I'm reading a math book, I like to go back to the motivating example. When the depth component is removed it's surprisingly difficult to find my place. Likewise, I can navigate through a book by thumbing through it much faster than I can press the "prev" or "next" button or try to perform a binary search by entering in random page numbers. Having said all that, I have a Sony Reader and I keep it in my bag when I commute. If I end up getting stuck someplace longer than anticipated, it's really handy to have a whole library at my hands. It's just not my preferred way of reading.
- oinksoft 15y agoI think this just explains that physical books will be practical and widespread until we see some groundbreaking eBook user interface that can match those benefits (I'm not holding my breath).
- hugh3 15y agoMy Nook is good for travel, but now the novelty is wearing off I use it less for that. Last week I went away for a week carrying only a small cabin bag, which should be the killer app for the Nook, but when it came time to pack I didn't feel like dealing with questions like "Is my Nook charged?" and "Where the hell is the charger cable for my Nook?" and "If I start charging now, will it have enough charge to make it for the entire flight?" so I just shoved four paperbacks into my bag. Heavier and bulkier, but less effort.
- jonknee 15y agoShould have gotten a Kindle, hardly any need to wonder if it's charged.
- lettergram 15y agoI don't really feel books will disappear. I know personally I read most of my books on ebook, but on occasions I will go buy a book of an author I like and I know many people do the same as I do. Also the library of congress made it its goal to archive all the knowledge both to a giant database as well as in the paper form. So I feel the article is slightly off in that regard.
- ctdonath 15y agoWon't disappear completely, just as mechanical watches haven't ... but they'll become luxury items, focused more on "I want this and I want it as well-made as possible" than the functional content. I've got 26 bookcases at home. The prospect of moving is staggering (last time the sheer mass bumped the predicted cost by $2000). There are piles of books I so want to read but know I'll never get to ... and will never part with. Oh, to have electronic copies of 2/3rds so I'd at least have the content for the prospect of reading some day without the weight/volume, and to replace the remaining 1/3rd with high quality renderings for the sensory experience of "I _own_ this".
- EGreg 15y agoThis reminds me a bit of the library of alexandria. Physical books all in one place have a bad habit of being more vulnerable to destruction. But hey why not, it's just one copy of the books. I think it's a great idea to at least attempt to keep an archive for this reason: "When they were making microfilm of books, they thought they would never have to rescan them. When they were being scanned at 300 dpi, they thought they would never have to scan them again. We know someday these books will be rescanned. They will be waiting here in boxes."
- whatusername 15y agoI think you'll find that only applies to picture books. If you have a scanned/OCRed copy of a novel (or a book that is an ebook from the get-go) -- then why would you need to rescan it?
- jim_h 15y agoI hope physical books don't disappear for a long time. Maybe once ALL books are available as ebooks in open format and without restriction on what I can do with them. I'd like the ability to trade, borrow, or resell my books. Also, if there are the equiv 'used' bookstores that sell ebooks for $1.
- BasDirks 15y agosomewhat related: individual titles do disappear, without a trace. I have an 1876 French poem collection on my shelves about which _nothing_ is written on the internet.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoSo write about it!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoLots of talk about "books won't really go away". I'm reminded of the victrola my Grandmother kept until the day she died. Kids these days (mine and their friends) don't own music collections. Its all on the web. They just download, listen, discard music. I believe a generation will grow into EBooks and have utterly no use for bulky, unsearchable faded paper books. I will be left in my crowded house, filled with books, and the grandchildren will know I am an old coot. And I am happy with this.
- jamesbritt 15y agoLots of talk about "books won't really go away". I'm reminded of the victrola my Grandmother kept until the day she died. Except that books have a far, far, longer history than records/CD/magnetic disks as a physical, portable medium for instant-access. There's no reason a dead-tree book can't also have an e-ink inside-cover that allows for full-index searching. Books have evolved but are unlikely to just go away, and the "flip pages with your finger" UI has proved immensely durable. Also, what are we to make of all those kids buying vinyl? :)
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoPortable? Instant-access? Are you sure you don't have that backward? EBooks outstrip paper books in this way, by at least an order of magnitude.
- jamesbritt 15y agoMy dead trees do not demand Net access and electricity. And they boot really fast.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoCome on - an EBook like Kindle doesn't require net access - you can have thousands of books in your hand. And the current model runs for a week or two between recharges. Those are hardly issues now, and will become non-issues in the next year or two. Lets admit it - books have no advantage whatsoever beyond our lifetime familiarity and affection for them. They will go away as surely as victrolas, snuff boxes, spats and buggy whips.
- Apocryphon 15y agoWake me up when digital displays can match the graphical resolution of the printed page. And when the display is attached to a reader device that will never, ever need to be recharged. And is incredibly lightweight. And gives off the satisfaction of physically flipping through pages.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ezy 15y ago- http://global.epson.com/newsroom/2011/news_20110517.html http://global.epson.com/newsroom/2011/news_20110517.html - Solar - Books are heavier, already. - Personal preference, but the UI will improve over time -- it probably won't be flipping a page however. See you next year! :-)
- Apocryphon 15y agoI ain't touching this unless it has haptic features that simulate the sensation of page-flipping, full ability in annotations and scribblings on the e-pages (I want to be able to use a ruler with my markings, I want digital pens, I want to be able to use digital crayons for all I care), and it is medically confirmed that reading e-ink produces no more eyestrain than reading paper. And I want it to be unhackable. And EMP shielded.
- gnaritas 15y agoPage-flipping is obsolete. All these things you want, already exist in books, so stick with books, when your generation dies, the next won't care about those quaint things and they'll move forward with the new medium.
- Apocryphon 15y agoI can't help but think fifty years down the line we'll see a huge spike in cancer rates caused by continuous exposure to electronic devices. If not from EM radiation, then from the materials they're made of. And I'm generation Y, we'll invent clinical immortality and we're going to live forever.
- drud 15y agoIt is without doubt a very good effort. More long term projects like this should be undertaken. A good example.
- ck2 15y agoOr there might be a revolution in "print-on-demand" making it possible to do for $1 per book someday. Insert previous book for recycling credit, which gets pulped later, new book prints on recycled paper but with ink that can also be easily extracted later. Babylon5 had a newpaper printer I think where you inserted the previous day's paper and got a new one. People will always like hard copy for some casual mediums.
- martincmartin 15y agoMovies didn't cause theatre to disappear completely. Light bulbs didn't cause candles to disappear completely. Printed books will get a feel of classic/high end/fancy. Parents will be reading to their kids from printed books (as well as electronic ones) for a while.
- WalterBright 15y agoI'd love it if Amazon offered me a discount on kindle versions of hard books I've already bought from Amazon. I'd like to clear out the thousands of pounds of books I have and just keep the digital versions. I'd even promise that the books go to the recyclers, not on the used market.
- mark_l_watson 15y agoBrewster Kahle is great: here is someone who has a track record of achieving material success but has turned his energies to filling a public need. In a delete nothing world, where ideally URIs never change, new material == a new URI, it is easy enough to assume that digital material will last forever, but I am a bit pessimistic here. For example, what if a systemic software error invalidates most of S3? I must agree with other people here that collectible books will probably always exist. I have a 50 pound tome of da Vinci's total corpus of work a customer gave me for Christmas - thumbing through that is simply a different kind of experience than accessing the same material through a web browser, even without rich media like video.