3 ms·
> No nation can survive systemic corruption for very long, it is a cancer that eats away at everything. While I appreciate the sentiment, I’m not sure that’s t
by dgellow 6y ago
> No nation can survive systemic corruption for very long, it is a cancer that eats away at everything.
While I appreciate the sentiment, I’m not sure that’s true:
- China is managed by corrupt elite since the last century
- Russia is completely corrupt (as was the USSR)
- India seems to have systemic corruption issues
- France politicians are well known for their corruption scandals
…
- himinlomax 6y ago> France politicians are well known for their corruption scandals No, the typical scandal is about them lining their pockets, which is related but not quite the same crime.
- panopticon 6y agoIsn't bribe-taking the poster child "corruption" activity? Or do you mean "lining their pockets" in another sense?
- himinlomax 6y agoCorruption is taking money in exchange of favors. The typical French scandal involved having relatives and friends getting fake jobs, typically paid for by a city government.
- dgellow 6y agoYou're arguing semantics, they are both forms of corruption.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nine_k 6y agoRussia is not corrupt in the same sense the US is. In Russia, the bureaucrats can bend and break local laws, siphon out some funds, etc. But they are pretty strictly controlled by the "power vertical", up to the quasi-tzar who is Putin. This structure does not tolerate breaking its internal rules, not keeping promises, etc, and is quick to unseat a bureaucrat which failed to conform, no matter how high in the hierarchy. This is why a number of things in Russia can be done quickly and relatively efficiently, when the higher-ups demand it. It, of course, is not very democratic and does not always align with the desires of the population, but in many cases it does. I suspect China has a similar structure: a bureaucrat may engage in corruption as long as he fulfills the orders of CCP; if corruption interferes with it, it is eliminated. This is the well-known efficiency of authoritarianism, e.g. of monarchy: if the monarch desires something good, that good thing can be completed very quickly and allocation of resources won't be a problem. (The trouble is, of course, that when a monarch desires something bad, the bad thing gets implemented as efficiently, for there's no counterbalance.)
- d1zzy 6y agoYeah I would actually argue that a minimum amount of corruption IS necessary in real life. Unless you live in a utopian society with perfect laws and application of them, corruption allows to move wheels that otherwise take forever to move or may never move. Of course, corruption can also be (very) detrimental to society. But attempting to remove all corruption from it seems to be the wrong priority.