3 ms·
so streaming music has eaten several different cakes - it has eaten the cake of radio in which I doubt the artist got 1p per play, it has eaten home taping in h
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
so streaming music has eaten several different cakes - it has eaten the cake of radio in which I doubt the artist got 1p per play, it has eaten home taping in https://www.nytimes.com/1985/11/21/arts/issue-and-debate-royalties-on-recorders-and-blank-audio-tapes.html https://www.nytimes.com/1985/11/21/arts/issue-and-debate-roy... in which there was some money paid out for the purchase of home taping equipment but which I think would not at all reach 1p per listen, it has eaten into the album which often cost enough that people bought them intermittently as a few albums could represent a significant part of disposable income, and it has eaten into the singles market (a small record with a b-track on the opposite side - already quite killed by cassettes and CDs)
The people fighting for 1p per stream want to focus on the killing of the album because in that way they look like poor mistreated artists who are just asking for crumbs considering what was taken from them.
And spotify etc. want to argue they are the ones who killed the radio, and thus it should cost them hardly anything and they are already paying way too much.
But at any rate 1p per stream is actually quite a significant increase in price considering what the user gets.
With an album one got album art etc.
Lyrics / liner notes.
And a number of songs - let us say 16 songs.
Nowadays you have to do your own work for the album art and lyrics, and could conceivably be asked to pay separately for them.
This is all a long time ago but I would think it was $10 dollars per average CD during the heyday. (somebody here surely knows the actual number)
So 62.5 pennies per song if 16 songs.
Perhaps it should be 1p per stream, max cost 63p per song per user?
that of course still means spotify eats the part of the market that buys more than one version per year, as someone with ADHD I have had to buy London Calling about 20+ times in my life. At some point I think I should get it for free.
so 1p per song streamed, max 63p per person per song every two years. If they asked for that I would think that is maybe a bit more than its worth, but also approaching fairness.
But they aren't asking for that, even though they should be able to think these things through easier and quicker than I can - so until they start asking for something resembling an actual fair deal I say screw them.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agojust noting also - if you were to make 1p per song without any of my proposed limitations or similar then given the fact that people consume the songs they loved in their 20s all their lives, if you could manage to have a couple top streaming hits for that age group for a couple years you might just be able to go fishing for the rest of your life!