3 ms·
> Kendi's work is extremely good Kendi proposes a constitutional amendment that would enshrine the principle that Racial inequity is evidence of racist policy
by inglor_cz 6y ago
> Kendi's work is extremely good
Kendi proposes a constitutional amendment that would enshrine the principle that Racial inequity is evidence of racist policy (from certain threshold that he does not specify), and create Department of Anti-racism (DOA) comprised of formally trained experts on racism and no political appointees. The DOA would be responsible for preclearing all local, state and federal public policies to ensure they won’t yield racial inequity, monitor those policies, investigate private racist policies when racial inequity surfaces, and monitor public officials for expressions of racist ideas. The DOA would be empowered with disciplinary tools to wield over and against policymakers and public officials who do not voluntarily change their racist policy and ideas. [0]
Do you find this proposal even good, much less extremely good? I don't. This is an attempt to bend reality by law, which rarely works, but usually has a plethora of unexpected negative consequences.
It also goes completely against any individualism that characterizes the Western society and elevates racial groups to basic building blocks of the country.
https://www.politico.com/interactives/2019/how-to-fix-politics-in-america/inequality/pass-an-anti-racist-constitutional-amendment/ https://www.politico.com/interactives/2019/how-to-fix-politi...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pharmakom 6y ago"Racial inequity is evidence of racist policy" if it's not, then would wildly unequal outcomes not imply some races are superior to others? the science indicates that this is not the case so how else can it be explained? --- Hmmm people didn't like this. I will add the statistic I can't get out my head: Incarceration rates in USA (adult male) per 100k White - 450 Hispanic - 831 Black - 2306 Asian - 210 I don't think this can be explained as cultural or genetic.
- dmpk2k 6y ago> that would imply No, it would not. There are more alternatives than "racist policy" and "racial superiority". Also, we're most likely dealing with continuums between many variables, not discrete buckets.
- brigandish 6y agoNo, because it may be possible that breaking a monolithic group into smaller blocks for analysis would show that some parts of that monolith do better than others, and even other parts of other monolithic blocks that were considered “superior”. Sowell himself gives the example of West Indian immigrants in New York and how they fare far better than American born blacks even though they live in the same area and cannot be distinguished by sight. (From memory) Coleman Hughes, in critiquing Kendi’s position will contrast Russian whites living in the States with those of French whites in the States that show greater disparities than between whites and blacks as monolithic groups.
- brigandish 6y agoI've actually just stumbled across this quote from Hughes as I was reading the review he wrote[0] of Kendi's book, posted nearby in this thread[1] (though I saw him use this elsewhere, in evidence to Congress, I believe): > This view commits him to some bizarre conclusions. For example, according to 2017 Census Bureau data, the average Haitian-American earned 68 cents for every dollar earned by the average Nigerian-American. The average French-American earned 70 cents for every dollar earned by the average Russian-American. [0] https://www.city-journal.org/how-to-be-an-antiracist https://www.city-journal.org/how-to-be-an-antiracist [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26477169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26477169
- Proziam 6y agoPeople don't live in uniform distribution across the country, and different regions have different economic and social climates. The percentage of people born in Scranton, PA that grow up to become software engineers is going to be different than those who grew up in Pittsburgh, San Francisco, or Gary. The geography variable is just one of many that can have a huge impact on outcomes.
- IanDrake 6y agoRaces are equal. However, some cultures are superior to others. Race != culture, although they often follow that line. If races were evenly distributed to cultures there would be no racial disparity that you seek to "repair". You can do the same thing with genders. Women and men (in general) value different things, which is why you don't see many women pumping septic tanks. Value systems lead to outcomes...Gasp! This is something nobody likes hearing these days, since extreme right racists insist their race is better and extreme left racists insist other races must need their help.
- hirundo 6y agoCultures are different from each other in almost any measurable respect. Cultures and races cluster together. Even if the genetic predispositions are identical, surely the cultural programs running on top of them are not. Shall we legislate away cultural predispositions?
- Grustaf 6y agoCulture goes very deep, most of the time you don't need to bring up genes to explain differences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- inglor_cz 6y agoThis is a list of differences in average income by ethnicity (in the USA). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income#By_detailed_ancestry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U... Indian Americans are on the top. Russian Americans are 12th in the list. Dutch Americans are 54th. Do you think that this is a proof of Indian supremacy and Dutch mediocrity? Or is there a policy that systematically oppresses whites of Dutch ancestry and elevates whites of Russian ancestry? Obviously none of those is true.
- zpeti 6y agoPlease explain, with science - why first and second generation black immigrants from the caribbean and africa do better economically than black families who have been in american for generations? I mean according to racial identity they should have the same end results right? I'll wait. For the science...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jacobriis 6y agoPlease share the scientific evidence that all populations have exactly the same distributions for all non-visible characteristics that are relevant to "unequal outcomes".