6 ms·
IIRC: Molten Salt "solar towers" work well in desert environments. Your point remains however: Desert solar-power is a different beast than normal solar-power.
by dragontamer 6y ago
IIRC: Molten Salt "solar towers" work well in desert environments.
Your point remains however: Desert solar-power is a different beast than normal solar-power. PV won't work well in a desert, you need to change your methodology entirely.
A "Solar tower" consists of a tower (which is just a standard thermal power-plant: usually a steam engine), and a ton of mirrors that heats the tower to 500C. The hotter the environment, the better a solar tower design gets.
- sandworm101 6y agoThe solar towers do work better in hotter environments but only marginally. When you are heating things to above 500c, whether the background is 0c or 30c doesn't make much difference. The mirrors suffer the same issues as PV panels (dirt/dust/scratches). Solar towers work best at lower latitudes where the sun is more overhead. Many of those latitudes are in deserts but the desert conditions are secondary to the angle of the sun.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe thing is: solar thermal plants get better the hotter the environment gets. In contrast: PVs get worse-and-worse the hotter they get. Hot solar panels mean that the silicon resistance goes up and up. IIRC, someone (I think IBM) did "solve" some "PVs in the desert" issue by running cold water to cool down the panels so that PV-efficiency can go back up. (Where "solve" was some experimental plant I remember hearing in the news years ago...) That's the kind of thing you need to do to get good energy from PVs in a desert environment. ------------ So for any hot and dry environment, it just sorta pushes the design towards thermal plants, and away from PVs. PVs are really good in temperate conditions however (where natural wind is good enough to cool off the panels). Just different technologies for different ecologies.
- sliken 6y agoRecent studies show that mixed use land where solar is above crops helps. The solar cells run cooler, and the shade helps many crops avoid over exposure and reduces the amount of water needed for the crops. So both get a boost to efficiency. If using the sahara this would help make the land more productive, help provide power for desalination, and help produce food.
- kumarvvr 6y agoFor current price points, solar thermal power is just not economical. Cheaper to throw in a bunch of panels and replace them after they are scratched by the sand, that to build expensive panels. Automation can be the solution for solar farms in the deserts. Daily automated cleaning, compressed air hosing, etc can be built into the project.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Cheaper to throw in a bunch of panels and replace them after they are scratched by the sand, that to build expensive panels. Its cheaper to replace a mirror than to replace a PV panel. The main benefit to solar-thermal is that they're innately offset from the sun by a few hours. In the morning, it takes a few hours to heat up, and then after the sun sets, it takes a few hours to cool down. During that offset period, the plant continues to generate power. Generating power at 9pm from thermal-residue (at the cost of losing 9am performance) is an acceptable tradeoff, especially when you consider that thermal plants work as a "team" with normal PV panels. Normal PV panels cannot give 9pm or 10pm power, not without an expensive battery bank (which suddenly makes thermal solar towers cost effective). ---------- Moving forward: the problem isn't going to be megawatts... its going to be megawatts AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME. That 7pm to 12pm power is currently served by Natural Gas peaker plants, and will continue to be served by peaker plants for the foreseeable future. After that point, the wind picks up and Wind Energy + Baseload (aka: Nuclear) takes over for the rest of the night. I know there's a group who believe that solar + batteries can solve the 7pm to 12pm power problem. But I believe that specifically discovering generators for that timeframe (ex: thermal solar towers) would be a superior option compared to giant battery banks.
- MauranKilom 6y ago> (which is just a standard thermal power-plant: usually a steam engine) CMIIW, but aren't "standard thermal power-plants" (especially those involving steam) usually reliant on a steady supply of (cold) water? That would seem like a major dealbreaker in a desert...
- dragontamer 6y agoYes and no. Yes: you need to cool the water down to increase the efficiency of a steam engine / traditional thermal power plant. For many plants, this is a supply of fresh water. No: A desert environment is obviously hostile to fresh water (like a stream). As such, "cooling the water" is solved through other means. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivanpah_Solar_Power_Facility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivanpah_Solar_Power_Facility In the case of Ivanpah Solar Power (the first Thermal Solar Plant that popped up in my search), they air-cool the water in a closed system. It won't get as cold as stream-water, but it still gets cold-enough that they can recycle / extract energy out of the steam engine system they use.