4 ms·
> Make the solution cheap and the problem goes away all by itself. If we also made the energy storage cheap then you would be right. But it's not cheap.
by fsflover 6y ago
> Make the solution cheap and the problem goes away all by itself.
If we also made the energy storage cheap then you would be right. But it's not cheap.
- ben_w 6y agoBatteries combined with PV are already cheaper than nuclear, and grids of this scale and in these locations reduce the need for storage in the first place.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoOn the margin, PV and wind are cheaper than nuclear. At deep decarbonization, which implies sufficient long-term storage (not just 4 hours) and/or other backup options, it is not cheaper than nuclear. Furthermore only Germany has seen significant anti-renewable NIMBY groups so far (I believe they have over 300 anti-wind groups). At significant scale, these may proliferate even more and find ways to drive up costs (just like they did with nuclear). For some models showing these scenarios, see https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2018.08.006 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2018.08.006
- ben_w 6y agoLast time I ran the numbers, I was assuming 16 hours of battery (~sunset to sunrise, winter solstice, London), and those batteries needing replacement every 1000 nights. It still worked out in favour of PV, even without the suggestion — up in this thread — of connecting to the longer sunlight hours of the Sahara, which reduces need due to each of latitude, covering multiple time zones, and reduced cloud cover.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoRunning the numbers from sunset to sunrise is extremely optimistic if you want 100% renewables. I've seen estimates of more like 4-7 days. However, that's not the biggest problem, current world wide lithium battery production is around 300GWh per year. Typical demand in the UK is around 30GW, even your 16 hours is around 1.5x the current battery manufacturing capabilities. You'd be competing against every car, laptop, tablet and phone manufacturer for that capacity.
- ben_w 6y agoGiven battery factories are being built as fast as possible, and given the batteries in the cars are often suggested as overnight storage (and that transport is such a major part of overall power use), I disagree that this a problem. I would instead describe it as an economic opportunity. Also, the cost of grid storage batteries is dominated by the short lifespan rather than by the number of days or hours it can replace supply. If the battery is enough for a week of zero power from all sources in your entire grid, the wear from normal use takes longer to become a significant cost.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoBattery factories are being build as quickly as possible. That is certainly true. However we're still at the level where one small countries electricity demand would demand a significant percentage of global production for some years to build out. That puts us many years away from grid storage being useable worldwide. Vehicle to grid is interesting but the number of chargers which currently support it very low. It requires a non-trivial amount of infrastructure to invert high voltage DC from the battery back back to a grid synchronous AC signal. In addition to the extra wear on the battery it's had to see how this would be good value while being acceptable to consumers. In some respects recycling of batteries after their service life in a car is a more interesting scenario for grid storage.
- Retric 6y agoCurrent manufacturing capacity is irrelevant as we only need to keep up with solar power generation capacity. Assuming 100GWh of battery manufacturing capacity is built per year that will provide a 20h worth of the world’s electricity demand in ~32 years. However that’s quite conservative, we can extend battery manufacturing much faster than that.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoIf you are trying to price something which requires more than the annual production capacity you have to account for the impact your own buying is going to have on the price. I'm not sure how you can wave that away.
- AngryData 6y agoAre there places with multiple days+ worth of electrical storage capacity? Because that is basically the minimum needed for solar that doesn't end up with regular power outages. I have yet to hear of any such large energy storage projects outside of a handful of dams that aren't actively filled but are turned down during peak solar or wind.
- ben_w 6y ago> that is basically the minimum needed for solar that doesn't end up with regular power outages Why is it needed? My first comment in this thread is in the context of putting the PV in the Sahara desert.