3 ms·
New idea: Break the cards. A gamer doesn't need mathematical perfection. 99% of gamers wouldn't care if a card game rendered something slightly off, a pixel
by sandworm101 6y ago
New idea: Break the cards.
A gamer doesn't need mathematical perfection. 99% of gamers wouldn't care if a card game rendered something slightly off, a pixel or two out of place on a 8k screen. A slight mathematical error wouldn't be noticed. But that same math error would destroy any mining efforts. So I propose that, rather than feeble attempts at software-based DRM, that Nvidea actually break the cards. Add in a tiny math error that gamers won't care about but that will render the cards useless for anything requiring exact calculation.
This would of course be very difficult to design.
- pjc50 6y agoIntel managed this accidentally with the FDIV bug: for certain very specific values, floating point division gave the wrong answer. Then there was the traditional rigged demo solution; one generation of cards behaved differently when the program running was named QUAKE.EXE. That is now almost standard, since part of the reason NVIDIA driver downloads are so large is a huge pack of compatibility tweaks for specific games.
- simias 6y agoModern engines render scenes in multiple passes, iterating over the same framebuffer until everything has been rendered. Engineering such a flaw in a way that wouldn't lead to dramatic cascading effect will indeed be very difficult to design. Note that sometimes games do need absolutely exact results, or at the very least reproducible results. For instance sometimes you want to use something like `glDepthFunc(GL_LEQUAL)` which will only accept a fragment if its depth is equal to the depth buffer's value. A small fudging here would cause potentially large visual issues. I'm not saying it's impossible but I expect that it would create a lot of headache as random, potentially unmaintained games would start glitching here and there.
- tpxl 6y agoWhich would also make the cards useless for any GPGPU workloads.
- tantalor 6y agoIsn't that exactly what they want? To only allow the cards to be used for gaming, not compute tasks like mining.
- csharptwdec19 6y agoThe problem with that however is that games might be using the GPU for non-visual things such as physics or AI. Would those 'off by one' errors impact those tasks?
- postalrat 6y agoYea. But in a good way.
- ali_m 6y agoThat might actually suit NVIDIA's interests just fine - they could sell uncrippled GPGPU-capable cards at a premium whilst claiming that they're helping to protect the supply of cards for gamers. However I think it would be difficult to do this without also breaking rendering pipelines.
- sodality2 6y agoThis would split the market for ML as well.
- wmf 6y agoApproximate ML is a hot research topic.
- rtkwe 6y agoThe other big use and market nVidia wants to have is ML installations for data centers though. Those also want perfect math and are pretty big business for nVidia. Also no one is running an 8k monitor off a 3060 or particularly well off of a single card usually. Also I dread trying to track down a rendering bug and finding out it's an intentional defect in cards, effects are getting pretty intricate and with raytracing small errors will accumulate over the multiple bounces.
- Jonnax 6y agoI'm always amazed how consumers will demand less for their money.
- justwalt 6y agoI definitely wouldn’t buy something that had been intentionally crippled, on principle. Even if it were a very slight crippling.
- X-Cubed 6y agoLook at the Dolphin blog posts for loads of examples of where minor math errors add up to completely break a game.