3 ms·
There are two separate concerns here: 1. Some sites lock accounts on reports rather than just the offending content or have YouTube-style systems which aren’t
by acdha 6y ago
There are two separate concerns here:
1. Some sites lock accounts on reports rather than just the offending content or have YouTube-style systems which aren’t the DMCA. That’s an indirect problem especially when, as in the latter case, it’s probably a private deal where YouTube avoided lawsuits by agreeing to spare the major holding companies the expense of filing DMCA complaints.
2. The DMCA has penalties for false claims but they’re almost never enforced. This is the best area for reform: if someone’s bot incurred liability for every claim where it misidentified the material or hit a fair use case (e.g. police officers playing music loudly to make YouTube auto-block recordings of them) they would quickly start improving those systems and adding human checks.
- LocalH 6y agoIt's my understanding that the DMCA's "truth" provision is limited to whether the person is authorized to represent the copyright holder, and not anything to do with the actual infringement claim itself
- acdha 6y agoI am not a lawyer but my understanding is that it’s more than that: see https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/512 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/512 - infringement covers not just that you have copyright but also that the user doesn’t have a valid right to use it, which includes fair use. Diebold lost a case where someone published internal emails and they used the DMCA to try to get them taken offline, and a judge agreed that this was fair use: https://www.eff.org/cases/online-policy-group-v-diebold https://www.eff.org/cases/online-policy-group-v-diebold
- LocalH 6y agoWhat I'm referring to is that perjury seems to be limited to cases where the claim to represent the copyright holder is unauthorized. One can file any number of DMCA claims on otherwise false grounds (such as fair use, etc), and if the court then chooses to sue upon DMCA appeal, they can cost the user far more than they should be able to, even if the user wins, as long as the person filing the DMCA is authorized by the copyright holder to do so. I would like to see such perjury charges be expanded to situations where it is clear the copyright holder's representative has acted in bad faith regarding whether infringement even happened, or whether it was justified infringement (fair use).