6 ms·
Minnesota pays 30-40% more per ton for salt than NY or Ohio. Midwest governments should be using their buying power and ability to control political subdivision
by Spooky23 6y ago
Minnesota pays 30-40% more per ton for salt than NY or Ohio. Midwest governments should be using their buying power and ability to control political subdivisions to make these mergers less profitable. For commodities, this is an area where government procurement shines.
In the absence of sane Federal regulatory action, consolidation of suppliers is best addressed by consolidating demand. A state like Minnesota should be forcing cities/counties to use a single state contract and leverage that demand to pull salt in from Canada, Western NY, wherever. Then use multi-state alliances to drive more demand and concessions from suppliers.
The downside is that winner take all procurement will put incumbents out of business, but that will happen anyway.
- dr-detroit 6y agoIn Michigan everything is corrupted by 100 years of letting elites run the government which here means the auto concerns. The car barons own the salt mine and they heap it out generously to the roadways because they know it destroys the autos forcing the slave class to buy more autos.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> winner take all procurement will put incumbents out of business The worst part isn't that companies go out of business, they probably won't, but that after a few rounds of one big state contract only one company will have the capacity to even bid for the contact. That one big company will then subcontract lots of little local delivery contracts. The one big company will have then effectively replaced the government in that it will manage salt delivery across the state.
- trf12 6y agoNow do the same projection for government’s usage of cloud.
- RaptorJ 6y agoWho are the private organizations buying road salt/salting services to within even two orders of magnitude of municipalities/state govts?
- lxmorj 6y agoThat’s silly. A single buyer doesn’t have to buy the entire supply in one shot. They could easily say “We buy the cheapest marginal salt in any quantity until our total capacity is met. You must beat $CANADA_PRICE + $IMPORT_PRICE, as well as $NY_PRICE + $TRANSPORT_PRICE or we’ll have to buy from them instead”.
- sandworm101 6y agoThe parent spoke of "winner take all procurement", which is a very different concept than "single buyer".
- enkid 6y agoI believe that's what your parent post is saying.
- Spooky23 6y agoEnd of the day, the market is doing that anyway. Remember the private equity folks are buying up the means of production -- contracting out trucking or whatever is meaningless. It's obviously building an old-school Trust, but under our current legal philosophy, as long the private equity / public companies slowly boil the frog and the commodity doesn't increase in price quickly, there will be no Federal regulatory action. All of these things are re-treads of what happened between 1880-1920. The cost efficiencies driving profit are about using computer tech to reduce labor and other costs. In the old days, it was spinning machines powered by coal/gas/electricity displacing water or craft work. It's more profitable/lower risk to build a monopoly and slowly implement cost-cutting than to be forced to do so by a competitve marketplace.
- eru 6y agoShouldn't low barriers to entry reduce these excess profits?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoMost government bidding processes are, in and of themselves, a high barrier to entry. Much of this is by design because the companies with the government influence to fix the problem are the ones who created it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eru 6y agoYes, definitely. Most government bidding processes would be improved by simplifying them drastically. Eg highest bidder wins. Instead of the beauty contests with lots of different factors that need evaluation by politicians.
- michaelt 6y agoThe article claims it isn't economic to transport salt >150 miles over land. So at the very least, you have to buy a salt mine in the right location. Maybe even start a new one, if the existing monopolists own them all. Not exactly a low barrier to entry IMHO :)
- eru 6y agoWell, they should focus on reducing barriers to entry. > The article claims it isn't economic to transport salt >150 miles over land. The higher the excess profits, the bigger that radius gets.
- bequanna 6y agoMinnesota state procurement is seriously broken with residents now paying the second highest taxes in the nation (after CA). The only question is whether this should be attributed to incompetence via political appointments or straight up graft. Check out the MNLARS project, if you’re interested in another excellent example. Pay attention to the insane dollar amounts involved and feel free to make up your own mind if the people in charge of that project were really that dumb or if there is something more sinister going on.
- sjg007 6y agoMinnesotans don't have much time for political nonsense. Taxes in Minnesota are not an issue. We have had the highest voter participation percentage of any state for a long time. This is a great state to live in that cares about its citizens, people with disabilities and children. We also have great schools but we do have a large achievement gap. Another thing that bothers me are some of the inequities across counties. We also have a lack of affordable housing like everyone else does. With respect to MNLARS you can read the report rather than speculate: https://dps.mn.gov/divisions/dvs/forms-documents/Documents/independent-expert-review-of-mnlars.pdf https://dps.mn.gov/divisions/dvs/forms-documents/Documents/i...
- bequanna 6y agoAh yes, the "Blue Ribbon Committee" organized by the same people who were responsible for managing the MNLARS project for the past decade. I'm glad there were able to put together this "independent" and completely bias-free review of this project so this can be put to bed. Get real. I lived in MN most of my life and finally moved last year. I now reside in TX and keep much more of what I make. If you don't smell something fishy with this project and the way MN is managing tax revenue, they've got you fooled. The politicians will hide behind very noble reasons to request more money from taxpayers. Perhaps there are some true believers, but they are only concerned with empire building, giving high-paying/do nothing jobs to cronies, and maximizing the amount of money flowing through their coffers. People at all levels of government have few if any incentives to be results-oriented and efficient but are heavily incentivized to request more money, employees, etc. The unfortunate thing is that the people of MN have been easily manipulated via guilt, social justice, etc. into paying well more than their fair share. Maybe guilt is a cultural defect somewhat specific to MN, but it seems that the politicians have been quite good at exploiting it for gain. > This is a great state to live in... It _used_ to be a great state to live in. Below average wages, above average taxes. Keep buying into Minnesota exceptionalism and telling yourself that your quality of life is somehow better than other places in the US. It ain't.
- blackguardx 6y agoOhio has salt mines. Are there any in Minnesota?