6 ms·
We do forget that medicine is a 20th century science. Even for most of the 1900s, doctors were performing wholly unscientific and unethical things. They still
by renewiltord 6y ago
We do forget that medicine is a 20th century science. Even for most of the 1900s, doctors were performing wholly unscientific and unethical things.
They still barely know anything. Medical science with proper epistemology is young, perhaps younger than the advent of modern computer science.
So there's lots of stuff that's just grandfathered. And because very little modern medicine has the ambition to try real novelty, we never retest the grandfathered taboos.
- RugnirViking 6y agodebateably, doctors still perform unscientific and unethic things to this day. See: electroshock therapy (basically our new form of lobotomy). Deliberately causing brain damage to "fix" mental illness, with almost certain loss of memory, and ability to form new memories. Or the creeping use of of chiropractors for things other than back pain, despite evidence of it's potential for harm. Or mandatory insertion of IUDs in china to control the birth rate. I am sure other therapies too, in time will be found to be extremely poor, especially in psychology and psychotherapy, where trials are extremely complicated , and common medicines have awful issues and <50% effecacy (see: antidepressants having permanent side effects even after cessation of treatment)
- Metacelsus 6y agoAs I understand it, electroshock therapy is never performed without consent and has special restrictions to make absolutely sure of this. Patients are anesthetized during the procedure to avoid pain. Yes it has side effects, but it is a last resort for treatment of severe depression that would otherwise ruin the patient's life.
- DataGata 6y agoI don't see why you're lumping in IUDs with electroshock therapy and chiropractors? Sure, the CCP is awful and has awful policies, but IUDs are strong indicators of a healthy healthcare system elsewhere.
- joquarky 6y ago> Or the creeping use of of chiropractors for things other than back pain, despite evidence of it's potential for harm. Any grey market solutions will become more ubiquitous as standard health care costs continue to skyrocket. I would expect to see more of this.