6 ms·
> especially cultural factors that make software development harder for those who can’t pass as YOUNG white males. FTFY. I’m 58, and learn faster, and more co
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
> especially cultural factors that make software development harder for those who can’t pass as YOUNG white males.
FTFY.
I’m 58, and learn faster, and more comprehensively, than I ever did, when I was younger.
I think my grasp of “the big picture,” or a high established baseline, is a big reason for the fast uptake. I don’t need to be told what iterators or allocators are. After having designed hundreds of applications, drivers, tools, APIs, SDKs, libraries, and systems, I know why we do stuff. It isn’t just rote dogma.
This gives me the flexibility to adapt my view of the world to deal with new paradigms and concepts. Also —and this is important— I can “mix and match” my approach. Most of my work, these days, is a chimera. I will use classic patterns, from thirty years ago, and combine them with new “cutting edge” stuff.
That takes flexibility, curiosity, knowledge, and motivation.
Also, teaching is important to learning. Especially teaching smart people. It challenges us to really understand what we’re trying to impart, as we are guaranteed to get challenging questions. When I took martial arts, many moons ago, the “postgraduate” stuff was to become a teacher. The Sifu (you know which art) would insist that students achieving new belts, immediately start training those in earlier belts. By the time you became a blackbelt, you were ready to teach an entire class, unassisted.
BTW: I never became any good at it, but I did learn some cool approaches to stuff.
- hikingsimulator 6y agoIt isn't uncommon to see people rely on the argument of neuroplasticity as a crutch. That one person seemingly doesn't learn as well and as fast past one's twenties is a thinly veiled ageist take but also an easy hand-wave to discard personal/professional change. It's always good to see your kind of comments.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoI guess it depends how you view/define learning. If by learning we mean learning _any_ information, then it seems likely the rate of learning would always increase over time since as you gain more knowledge it's more likely that you've done something similar in the past. If we're strictly talking about learning _new_ information (As in, not closely related to previous knowledge) then I can understand the argument that someone learns slower as they age. Basically it seems like it comes down to crystalized knowledge and how you count that.
- admissionsguy 6y ago> If we're strictly talking about learning _new_ information (As in, not closely related to previous knowledge) Is it possible to clearly separate the two, or are there universal concepts underpinning every domain?
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoI don't know. Probably not, but I'm just musing.
- arethuza 6y agoPerhaps that suggests the approach you sometimes here from medics (particularly for surgery) of "see one, do one, teach one" isn't quite as alarming as it initially sounds!
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI tend to "learn by doing." I don't really like pointless academic exercises. I need to be shipping stuff. When I want to learn something new, I'll set up a project, with a definite ship goal, that uses whatever I am studying. It may not be perfect, when it ships, but it does ship. Shipping is also learning. There's absolutely nothing to compare with releasing finished product, and supporting it. I've learned a lot of the "soft" skills necessary to ship and support. These are different from simple algorithms or debugging exercises.
- agumonkey 6y agoMaybe that's just me but in college my brain was high frequency [0] but low clarity. Some people might have wiser approaches (I've seen a few I believe, where they would be calm and try to see large and abstract without rushing). 10 years after college my thinking changed and instead of sweating hard I started to understand things at a higher level without this hectic feeling. It requires less efforts and at the same time let's you reach more creative, larger solutions. (pretty counter intuitive when it started to happen). [0] and I've seen this on dev discords where 20yos goes into all directions trying to apply all configuration of 'lessons of the day' in random ways and high stress. Very different brain activity. ps: this brings a lot of questions about the psychology of learning.. how much do you learn because of youthful ego, social status desire, peer pressure, elder validations, future anxiety versus joyful and creative ways to see things and discuss ideas.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoI'm 22 and I kind of relate to high frequency, low clarity but I like this style of learning. It lets me quickly learn the basics of things and if I want to dive deep I can revisit things later on.
- agumonkey 6y agoI guess it's matter of outlook, with time you want less 'revisit later on' and a more balanced 'enjoyable, peaceful and deeply learned quickly'.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoWell I'll see what happens. Right now it feels quite enjoyable and not frantic learning, and it doesn't feel like I'm leaving gaping holes in my knowledge I'll have to fill in later. I'm also naturally diving deeper into topics as I spend more time doing work related to them so all in all, I'm quite happy with how things are going so far.
- ravi-delia 6y agoIf nothing else as time goes on there's less and less 'later on' and more and more stuff to revisit; perhaps you'd naturally see this kind of pattern if you accumulate more and more knowledge debt and spend more time paying it down to get a firm foundation.
- tasogare 6y ago> cultural factors that make software development harder for those who can’t pass as white males Racist remarks like this need to stop. Being White or not has nothing to do with learning tech. Available resources (internet, libraries, universities) are available usually for free or small fees for everyone regardless of race (at least in the European case). Most other countries in the world haven’t even a significant White minority, and when they have one, they are not plotting against non-White to hinder their learning of technology (often quite the reverse, in fact).
- paedubucher 6y agoI actually got in touch with the author because of this remark, because this subject wasn't even discussed in the article at all. It looks like virtue signaling to me. Such remarks really make me cringe.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 6y agoRacist remarks like the author said need to stop. It only promotes racism. This critical race theory is doing more damage than all history combined.
- tester34 6y agoIndeed It's not only racist, but also does not promote outperforming. You can either sit and complain or try hard to skew the odds that are against you.
- statstutor 6y ago> Available resources (internet, libraries, universities) (mentors, support from authority, sufficient time/financing to be able to use the available resources) If a professor believes consciously or subconsciously, by looking at you, that you're less likely to succeed, that's a significant barrier that may well be immediately fatal to your interest in a subject. The frequency with which this kind of thing is said out loud is astonishing. E.g.: https://abc11.com/education/nc-state-professor-suspended-for-calling-women-useless-in-lecture/5585611/ https://abc11.com/education/nc-state-professor-suspended-for... If you've never personally witnessed quiet sexism (against women) and quiet racism (against non-white and in particular black people) in computer science, then I question where you have been.
- johbjo 6y ago> I think my grasp of “the big picture,” or a high established baseline, is a big reason for the fast uptake. This is a valid argument and true also in my experience. The counter argument is that "software building" is to media companies (faang) what a press is to an advertising company. Problem-solving is not the relevant value-creating activity. The perceived need is for "creators" and "operators" for the "machine", rather than engineers and problem-solvers. Screens today are spaces that need to be filled with "cultural content". The technology itself is a public good, and they want willing bodies that don't ask questions to turn the wheels of the "machine". This is the rationale for ageism, whether valid or not.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI completely understand why FAANG-type companies (and all their imitators) want young kids, right out of school. Young folks learn rote (they just spent a whole bunch of years at school, doing exactly that), and adapt to it quickly, even if they don't fully understand the context or goals, so they are more likely to follow direction and process; especially if you can gamify the process. Me, I like to know why, and to "play the tape through to the end." I'm also apt to say stuff like "Are you sure that you want to do that? You know it's likely to give you a race condition, if you use a different device. Might be worth it to consider a different approach.", and whatnot. That kind of pisses in the punch bowl.
- nonameiguess 6y agoI don't think this is the reason. They want people with no families and no responsibilities because those people will move to Seattle or San Francisco and work 100 hour weeks without having to worry about uprooting spouse and kids and ruining all human relationships. I actually hope one of the outcomes of post-pandemic normalization of remote work is less tacit age discrimination from companies that used to greatly prefer people willing to relocate.
- sokoloff 6y agoI don’t think tacit is exactly the right word there. Effective (or de facto) is probably closer. If the company is willing to hire someone and that person decides they’re not willing to relocate, I don’t think that’s tacit age discrimination.
- christophergs 6y agoWhen you say you learn faster and more comprehensively than when you were younger - was it gradual improvement, or did you have some significant turning points where you optimized your learning process?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoIt seems to have happened in big "jumps." Sort of "Ah-HA!" moments. But really, it's an accretion. That is especially true of the stuff that I need to ship software, which is quite different from what I need to write software.
- novask 6y agoI've gone completely the opposite. I seem to have made more mistakes as I've gotten older (35y) and learning seems to go more slowly. Some of them are mistakes you'd expect someone with 0-1 years of experience to make, even though I've got 5 or so. It's all downhill from here, I guess.
- danaliv 6y ago> Also, teaching is important to learning. Hear, hear. I didn't really know how to fly until I started teaching people how to do it. I thought I did, but not really. Not deeply.
- pts_ 6y agoIt's similar for me. I was less motivated and could grasp less as a college student over now with 10 years experience.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoSoon to be 58 year old here. In a lot of ways I'm better at this software stuff than I was at 28 - looking back and comparing to now I really sucked at it back then. But the aforementioned cultural factors mean that it's a lot harder to find work (I think this is what you were alluding to with your edit to change to YOUNG). Part of the advantage now is knowing what things are important to learn and knowing what will become ephemera because you've seen so much ephemera come and go over the years.
- j7ake 6y agoI think as you grow older you build a large web of knowledge where you can connect disparate pieces of information into a coherent framework. This should make one easier to learn new material (eg reading your first scientific paper can take a very long time, but by the time you have read your 1000th, you will have built models to help digest information). However it may be that this developed framework can hinder new learning if new skills are fundamentally incompatible with existing framework. There old habits can slow down incorporation or new skills. For example, learning Japanese as an anglophone may be harder than learning Japanese as a Korean speaker. The anglophone would need to actively ignore learned habits to learn Japanese.