4 ms·
I am going to put a different spin on this: If you use a service like google photos, wouldn't you want to uplift all your photos, albums and metadata into the s
by ggm 6y ago
I am going to put a different spin on this: If you use a service like google photos, wouldn't you want to uplift all your photos, albums and metadata into the service?
Viewed from the "be maximally useful" perspective, it makes sense. I have 150,000 photos (maybe) -I don't want to approve each one. Even at the album granularity, I have thousands of albums. We all do.
Yes, its a giant, egregious privacy breach. That is pretty much definitional for a cloud based Photo archive/album service.
- crescentfresh 6y agoI use google photos. I also certainly do NOT want to upload all my photos, albums and metadata into the service. Having said that I would still allow full access to all my photos on my device for the convenience of being able to scroll through my thousands of photos to select the 20-100 I want to upload.
- floatingatoll 6y agoNope, that's not what I would want to use Google Photos for.
- ggm 6y agothen.. keep on granting per photo I guess? If they made that impossible thats a dark anti pattern
- cassianoleal 6y agoI take it you didn't even click the OP? Because that's exactly what this is about, and nothing else.
- zwily 6y agoYou can easily grant Google Photos access to all your photos. Why do you think others should not be allowed to specify a subset?
- ggm 6y agoper album would be nice I guess. see, this is why I love HN. it makes me think!
- thitcanh 6y agoIt depends on what you use it for. I only use it to access a non-personal library, but Google Photos still shows all of my local photos in every account. That renders the app useless for me. Google Photo only wants to be a full replacement for your Photos app and doesn't allow any other usage. That's user-hostile. The worst part is that iOS 14 initially let me use Google Photos exactly the way I wanted, until Google (pretty quickly) added the block described by OP.
- ggm 6y agoyea I kinda see this now