4 ms·
First off, my comment wasn't legal advice. Second, the federal government is not bound by the linked document, and indeed there are several cases (such as banki
by sneak 6y ago
First off, my comment wasn't legal advice. Second, the federal government is not bound by the linked document, and indeed there are several cases (such as banking, firearms, et cetera) where it does not apply at all.
The basic core of my statement stands: the fact that they are not actually legally restrained by anything from prosecuting you under these federal laws is a risk that you should be aware of when you undertake breaking them. The fact that they have voluntarily subjected themselves, in some limited circumstances, to restraint is a) not binding upon them, and b) not relevant to that risk, as anyone who has filled out a Form 4473 (or tried to get a credit card terminal for a dispensary) can attest.
They can write all of the memos they want; malicious prosecution for pissing off the wrong people is still a thing, and has recent federal examples (weev, Roger Ver, et c).
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoWould that not be a front and over exertion of states rights? The state said the federal government is overreaching. If they ignore them, would that not lead to the state to fight against the federal government in court?
- sneak 6y agoStates don't have the right, under the current US legal system, to nullify federal laws.
- vulcan01 6y ago> current US legal system To clarify, this is part of the US Constitution (Supremacy Clause). https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artVI_C2_1_1_3/ https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artVI_C2_1_1_...
- yesenadam 6y ago> First off, my comment wasn't legal advice. ?! I'm not sure what you mean by that, but that's exactly what it looked like, every word of it. I guess you know that.
- sneak 6y agoWhat did I advise anyone to do?
- yesenadam 6y agoSorry but I find it impossible to believe you are speaking in good faith.
- sneak 6y agoI've read my comment four times and I can't find anywhere in it where I advised anyone to do anything. You seem to think it was advice; what was the advice? What thing did I tell someone to do or not do?
- yesenadam 6y agoYour entire comment seems to be advising people about the law and their rights or lack of them. Then you ask repeatedly "What did I advise anyone to do?" as if nothing counts as "legal advice" but "advising someone to do something". IANAL but to me, and it seems others, when you get legal advice it often takes the form of information about the law, your rights or lack of them. Not just advising someone to do something. I'm not sure why this is hard to understand. Maybe you are using a very narrow technical definition of "legal advice"..uh, like a lawyer might, I suppose. p.s. [checks who you are] ohh it's You! hehe. I read your article about non-rube email! (And some of your other writing) I thought it was impressive, but seemed super-complex, too much for...non-experts like me. Have you thought about setting that system up for people, as a business? I guess so. https://sneak.berlin/20201029/stop-emailing-like-a-rube/ https://sneak.berlin/20201029/stop-emailing-like-a-rube/
- eyelidlessness 6y ago> First off, my comment wasn't legal advice. Fair. Just a bad legal take. Which other people might interpret as advice. > Second, the federal government is not bound by the linked document Like this. This is not true. You might believe it, you might be acting in good faith, but it’s false. I know there are exceptions, but the DOJ and the federal law enforcement apparatus in general is bound by its own policy, and most (not all) prosecutors take that seriously. They take it so seriously that the linked memo remained in effect even through highly politicized ousting of career officials to install loyal lackeys. Are there exceptions? Absolutely. Are they abusive? Often, when they occur. Are they neutral “might happen to rando people who just got permission to have a little trip and aren’t upsetting anyone who might want to prosecute them maliciously”? Very probably not. It does a disservice to people who are targeted by prosecutorial abuse to frame it this way. And it does a disservice to the people who are far more likely to be targeted by states than the federal government to muddy those waters.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]