3 ms·
My answer was to Dr."(Astrophysist [sic] here)" saying "This is complete BS." If the previous relativistic models failed to produce results different from Newt
by ncmncm 6y ago
My answer was to Dr."(Astrophysist [sic] here)" saying "This is complete BS."
If the previous relativistic models failed to produce results different from Newtonian gravity, it was, apparently, because they were wrong. Now, I don't claim to know anything about how to simplify GR solutions, but I know of people whose job it is to be able to simplify GR solutions correctly; and to be able to tell whether they have been simplified correctly. If they are getting that part of their job wrong, what reason do we have to believe they are doing the rest of their job any better?
Even if simplifying the maths is too hard for most of them, some one or other might have thought to run a direct numerical simulation, without any simplification. (Maybe have an undergrad do it? Or, every undergrad?)