6 ms·
Lots of comments here along the lines of "SMS 2FA is bad", but hell, if the phone companies had an appropriate level of liability here (which should be a shit t
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Lots of comments here along the lines of "SMS 2FA is bad", but hell, if the phone companies had an appropriate level of liability here (which should be a shit ton), this should be impossible.
And it's not just about 2FA, most of humanity expects that if someone else texts them, those texts will go to their phone and only their phone unless they've given explicit verifiable consent.
I mean, in this case all the hacker did was fill out a form and say pretty please. I hope phone companies that allow this get sued.
- coding123 6y agoWhen they invented text messaging, heck even the phone system itself, did they provide anything that said there was an expectation of privacy? Not sure which is why I'm asking.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIf I understand correctly, the initial telephone systems were run by manual operators at a physical switchboard, who could listen in to anything that was said on any line. Many people also had party lines, where someone (in another house or apartment) could pick up their phone and listen to your conversations. So, no, not much of an expectation of privacy - at least, there shouldn't have been.
- mgbmtl 6y agoIf there was no expectation of privacy, the police would not need a warrant to tap a line.
- edgyquant 6y agoWhen cell phones first became big, probably 10-15 years ago at least, there was a website for my area I lived in at the time (southern Illinois) that would list texts and people could vote on the funniest ones. There were some really private messages that would hit the top (obviously phone numbers weren’t displayed.) So it used to be people had the assumption that texts were public, because for some carriers they basically were.
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoThis is hilarious. Do you happen to have any links regarding this? Would love to read more.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoIs the initial set of expectations the immutable legal standard?
- IgorPartola 6y agoWiretapping (without a warrant) is stupidly illegal.
- inetknght 6y agoSaying something is illegal and expecting everyone to follow the law is just pinky-swearing.
- IgorPartola 6y agoYeah! Why have laws anyways? Every law will be broken sooner or later and it’s not like we have institutions tasked with enforcing laws. /s
- coding123 6y agoI'm under the assumption that wiretapping to create evidence is illegal, but wiretapping to get a warrant probably happens all the time. (AKA Judge and Police officer listen to illegally captured audio - Judge approves official warrant to make future recordings legal)
- IgorPartola 6y agoWiretapping by a private person should not happen.
- inetknght 6y ago"should not" and "does not" are not equal statements.
- sneak 6y agoThis would also be impossible if services stopped demanding your phone number to make an account. This is a growing trend in consumer services, and it's a privacy nightmare. Imagine if they demanded your SSN to sign up? A phone number is no different or less sensitive a unique identifier, perhaps even moreso these days. There are widespread reports of delivery businesses selling their phone number databases (with associated credit card suffixes, delivery addresses, order history, et c) to large advertising companies for data mining. Providing your direct cell number to an app is basically like providing your home address and a bunch of other sensitive data. Don't do it, or make a burner gmail account to get a disposable Google Voice number for each account that you must have that demands a phone number. Then, that number isn't reused and an attacker that obtains your mobile number can't attack your login method for other apps. Reusing phone numbers is about as bad as reusing passwords.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Imagine if they demanded your SSN to sign up? A phone number is no different or less sensitive a unique identifier, perhaps even moreso these days. The goal is for the service to have a unique identifier, and phone numbers happen to be a really good one to prevent spam also since it outsources verification of human entity to the phone companies.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou’re not wrong. The problem is the lack of an authoritative identity provider in the US.
- sneak 6y agoNo, that's not the problem, the problem is that many many organizations demand an authoritative identity when no such thing is necessary or advisable. https://sneak.berlin/20200118/you-dont-need-to-see-my-id/ https://sneak.berlin/20200118/you-dont-need-to-see-my-id/ The US has plenty of centralized identity systems, including the Real ID one, a backdoor federal ID system that is required to board all commercial flights in that country.
- Eridrus 6y agoBut what is an appropriate level of liability here? Phone companies never signed up to be the guardians of our digital lives, and the tech industry at large has just built a castle on shakey foundations. And there are obvious trade-offs here, if we make number portability harder, it means you're somewhat hostage to your phone provider.
- IgorPartola 6y agoNo, this is exactly what they signed up for. When I sign a contract with my phone company to give me access to their network I expect that they will not just give it to someone else instead under my name.
- ineedasername 6y agoPhone companies are guardians of our our accounts with them. The absolutely bear responsibility if poor security or loopholes allow someone to gain any sort of access to our accounts. Security and convenience are often a trade off. Clearly service providers are not properly judging where that balance should be.
- Eridrus 6y agoSure, to a point. But the right costs and trade-offs aren't the same if you're protecting your spotify account vs millions of dollars in cash.
- smadge 6y ago> Phone companies never signed up to be the guardians of our digital lives The parent comment addressed this point. This is not just about 2FA. SMS users expect their communication are private, except (debatably) by the courts with a warrant.