11 ms·
Almost none of them could get a job as a software engineer at their own company, if they had to, because they would be completely unqualified. There are 10 CEO
by onion2k 6y ago
Almost none of them could get a job as a software engineer at their own company, if they had to, because they would be completely unqualified.
There are 10 CEO level people mentioned.
Woz could certainly get a job at Apple. He's clearly brilliant and capable.
Larry & Sergey could definitely get jobs at Google. They were PhD CS students at Stanford (how on Earth is that "unqualified" to you?).
Zuckerberg could get a job at Facebook. He obviously wrote a lot of Facebook's early code.
Gates & Allen allegedly didn't do much actual coding themselves but they certainly understood it. I imagine Jobs, Bezos and Jack Ma also understood coding even if they didn't do any themselves. I don't know anything about Ma Huateng.
I doubt any of them could drop in to a high level coding role and be productive, but they could all do intern or junior level stuff. Code isn't that hard that you need to be a special snowflake to do it.
- danielmarkbruce 6y agoYou are assuming a lot. Many stanford phd's fail the google interview. I'd guess larry, sergey and zuckerberg had a pretty good chance of failing their own swe interviews...
- codegladiator 6y agoYou are assuming a lot. Many stanford phd's /dont/ fail the google interview. I'd guess larry, sergey and zuckerberg had a pretty good chance of /passing/ their own swe interviews...
- danielmarkbruce 6y agoYou might be semi joking, so apologies if I took it too literally: I'm assuming nothing really. And we are saying almost the exact same thing. Many pass, many fail. Pretty good chance of succeeding, pretty good chance of failing.
- pyrale 6y agoMaybe the issue is with the Google interview? I mean, plenty of very capable people are filtered out of Google and go on to do great things. It is bound to happen when you receive hundreds of applications and hire one person.
- whydoineedone 6y agoThose interviews select for different things. To start a company, you prioritize speed and the big picture when coding, when being hired by a big company, what matters is that you can conform to the way they do things. While related, they’re not the same
- onion2k 6y agoI am assuming a lot, but everything I've read about Larry, Sergey and Zuck tells me that they're pretty exceptional people (even if that doesn't extend to their coding ability, which I have no idea about). They're people who are driven, focused and hugely ambitious. If they don't have what it takes to pass a SWE interview then there's little hope for the rest of us.
- tinco 6y agoI think the point is, that even if they are intelligent and capable and definitely contributed a lot to their initial codebases ( I don't know why you singled out Gates, but he most certainly did as well), all of these companies grew to the point where almost any code change requires a bunch of expertise with technologies that they probably have not been exposed to. I don't know if they wouldn't get hired, I mean it's not like those companies never hire straight out of college, they obviously do, so expertise is not an absolute requirement. But they probably couldn't be hired as drop-in experienced SE's. Half their tech stacks are on technology that didn't even exist when they last touched code. All of these CEO's are famous for their excellent early talent acquisition of software engineers. Microsoft and Apple for leveraging those engineers to initiate a new digital world, and Facebook and Google for attracting (and motivating) the worlds best to achieve global domination.
- onion2k 6y agoBut they probably couldn't be hired as drop-in experienced SE's. That's exactly what I said in my first post - "I doubt any of them could drop in to a high level coding role and be productive, but they could all do intern or junior level stuff."
- jbroson 6y agoIf this is the standard that "they couldn't get hired TODAY" I'm sure that's not a very interesting fact worth discussing. I mean if we reanimated Big Al Einstein today and he had a blind interview for a tenure track physics position at Princeton Physics dept he would probably fail. The field has changed too much although with months of prep he'd be able to catch up, the same as L & S could for SWE interviews.
- dcolkitt 6y agoThe dirty truth is that most whiteboard industries are heavily loaded on raw cognitive ability. Sure, it’s ostensibly about data structures, but what it’s really about is fluid intelligence. Gates, Zuckerberg, Larry, Sergey and Bezos all have extremely high intelligence, and would most likely pass with ease.
- EvilEy3 6y agoSorry, but that's offensive to stupid people.
- cutemonster 6y agoI agree with you, and I think that this "dirty turth" is unpopular, because lots of people want to feel bright and intelligent, but the algorithm interviews, when interpreted in this way, tells them they're not that super bright -- and they don't like that, so they want to interpret the interviews in other ways, eg it's just luck, or anyone can do it with enough practice or things like that. At the same time, I think the coding interviews generally are harder than what's needed to do the job well, just because there're so many job applicants so the bar gets unnecessarily high? And people who fail the interviews can still be really bright. (Also, some people get nervous and fail mostly related to that. I wonder how to avoid that happening)
- jbroson 6y agoWhat? You honestly think the Stanford PhDs who created Google couldn't get hired as basic SWEs? Seriously? I mean if true that says a lot more about the SWE interviews than it does about Stanford PhDs. I mean there are Yale JDs that fail the bar exam but no one would claim that the average Yale JD couldn't get hired as a Big Law associate or judicial clerk.
- walto2 6y agoIn a very literal sense, that's exactly what's broken about the interview process in the software industry. The philosophy is to avoid false positives at all costs, so a high rate of false negatives is seen as OK. The prevailing advice is, just try your luck again in six months.
- mlcrypto 6y agoThat's the good thing about Bitcoin. I don't have to prove anything to anyone anymore. It doesn't matter where you work if you convert your fiat to the superior store of value
- Alex3917 6y ago> You honestly think the Stanford PhDs who created Google couldn't get hired as basic SWEs? Seriously? They would definitely get a phone screen based on their resumes, but there is a good chance they wouldn't even make it to the virtual onsite round. It's not like the interviewers would use their products or look at their code or dissertation or whatever.
- gamblor956 6y agoGoogle famously refused to hire Max Howell, the programmer who wrote Homebrew, which (based on Google's own statements) was used by 90% of Google's engineers at the time of his interview, because he couldn't invert a binary tree in the specific (but unstated) manner that the interviewer wanted. So it's definitely possible, indeed likely, that Serge and Larry wouldn't get hired at the Google of today. The "average Yale JD" would not get hired as a judicial clerk. Competition for clerkships is fierce, and generally only the top students get them. Any judge would probably take a "top" Yale JD, but unless the judge is a Yale graduate they'll all pass on the "average Yale JD," in favor of a better-performing graduate from another law school (usually their own).
- Spooky23 6y agoThe OP’s point is that education or not, if you’ve been out of practice for decades, none of these companies will hire you as an SWE. Hell, the type of attitudes and personality that made these folks good at what they did would probably be liabilities from some the interview process.
- morelisp 6y agoWhat is this bizarro world where Gates didn't do much coding but Zuckerberg bootstrapping a PHP CRUD app would get him in the door at today's Facebook?
- monoideism 6y agoAgreed, Gates was a brilliant coder for any other faults. He'd probably need to catch up on tech, but could easily then get a very senior engineering job at Microsoft or anywhere else, if he managed to escape the ageism trap. Zuckerberg, on the other hand, partly coded a CRUD PHP app before moving on to executive stuff. He would probably not pass a Facebook interview without several years of intense preparation. Brin and Page fall in between those two. They at least have several years of academic coding and their early Google work. Yes, they're all very smart, but that's not enough to get into most FANG software engineering jobs.
- Alex3917 6y ago> Zuckerberg could get a job at Facebook. He obviously wrote a lot of Facebook's early code. That doesn't mean he could do leetcode problems.
- UnpossibleJim 6y agoNot to be "that guy", but he'd have to get past the HR filter first and if I remember correctly, Zuckerberg dropped out of Harvard. Without a college degree, it's very difficult to get past the HR filter in and of itself to even get to the interview to solve those problems.
- kyberias 6y ago> Zuckerberg could get a job at Facebook. He obviously wrote a lot of Facebook's early code. > Gates & Allen allegedly didn't do much actual coding themselves but they certainly understood it. What? Gates & Allen similarly wrote "a lot of early code". Gates also acted as a Chief Software Architect in his final days at Microsoft.
- mountain_peak 6y agoMy understanding is that the last application code Gates was involved in was the TRS-80 Model 100 [1] circa 1982; I taught my kids assembly on the Model 100 and think it's great. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRS-80_Model_100#ROM_firmware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRS-80_Model_100#ROM_firmware
- samfisher83 6y agoAllen and gates where writing code when they were in highschool when no one was writing code. They also also got 1590 and 1600 on theirs sats when it used to be super hard. These are super smart and motivated people. You don't they could master leetcode after a few weeks of practice?
- dnautics 6y ago> but they could all do intern or junior level stuff. Almost certainly true, but would they pass the coding interview?
- taeric 6y agoUnderlining this point. The claim isn't that they couldn't work in the field. It is that they could have trouble in the interview. I'm not clear why/if this is controversial. I thought it was well established that interviews are tough from both ends and that they suffer heavily from Goodhart's law.
- underdeserver 6y agoGates & Allen didn't do much coding? Gates wrote most of the first version of DOS and lots of other software.
- ido 6y agoI believe you are thinking of Microsoft BASIC? MS-DOS was bought by microsoft from another company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS-DOS#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS-DOS#History
- neonological 6y agoZuck wouldn’t. He’s a Mediocre engineer by his own admission. It’s a myth that he was an autistic genius. The engineering questions at fb aren’t trivial.
- danjac 6y ago> He obviously wrote a lot of Facebook's early code. Have you seen Facebook's early code? It's very much "Early 2000s PHP spaghetti written by undergrad on a caffeine bender at 3 am". Facebook succeeded because of catching lightning in a bottle at the right place/time, and sure, later engineers built it to scale, but let's not kid ourselves that it was due to Zuck's coding genius.
- passivate 6y agoIs Facebook's early code available someplace online?