3 ms·
Tenochtitlan was larger than almost every other contemporary city in Europe. The market alone was noted by the Spaniards who saw it to be as large as the cities
by jcranmer 6y ago
Tenochtitlan was larger than almost every other contemporary city in Europe. The market alone was noted by the Spaniards who saw it to be as large as the cities they knew. And, in addition to having universal primary education (for both males and females, imagine that!), as well as more opportunities for lower classes to rise into the ranks of the elites, the city was also more cosmopolitan than most, having what we would see today as ethnic neighborhoods. At a time when the Spanish were busy trying to erase any legacy of Moors or Jews in their country.
Or maybe you'd want to consider instead the Mayans. Their astronomy was on par with--or better than--contemporary Eurasian astronomers. Their calendar is sufficiently precise, and their written legacy vast enough, that we know the chronology of successorship in polities and rulers for the Classical Maya where we struggle to even identify the existence of those same entities in contemporary Europe (although, to be fair, the Age of Migrations is responsible for a lot of that). And, personally, I think the Mayan writing system is more wonderful than anything derived from the Phoenicians or the Chinese.
But why stop with the well-known urban civilizations? Several cultures challenge conventional notions about the development of civilization. The Mogollon culture developed impressive aqueduct systems to enable farming in a desert without any evidence for a centralized authority. The quipus of the Wari and the Inca challenge the notion of writing system. Norte Chico challenges the idea that agriculture is a necessary precondition for urban civilization.
Pre-Columbian America developed very differently from the Eurasia. If you try to fit its development to a Eurasian development sequence, you will find that it doesn't match very well. But that doesn't mean it didn't develop civilization, and pretending that it does misses a wealth of fascinating advancements that they did.
- AlotOfReading 6y agoPoint of correction, it's the Hohokam and not the Mogollons that are known for their massive canal systems. The people inhabiting the broader Mogollon region had fairly small irrigation networks that don't really justify the term "canal". Most archaeologists would also have some quibbles with describing Hohokam irrigation as truly decentralized, particularly in e.g. the civano phase, but it's accurate enough I guess.
- ardit33 6y agoLets make it clear.... they build impressive things, and had a civilization, but they were way behind those both of europe and asia. the Aztecs were sacrificing people to Huitzilopochtli (their war god), when europeans were teaching and learning in Oxford an Cambridge. Same with the mayans. We can discuss all day long, but their civilizations were not any more advanced than old egypt ones, and the ones in the Levantine era (Prior to the Roman period). Which were about 2080-3500 years prior.
- myownpetard 6y agoThe Spanish Inquisition was executing people up until 1826. The last 2itch was executed in England in 1716. Both hundreds of years after the fall of the Aztec Empire. Oxford is a strange callout. It was founded in 1096. About 700 years before the enlightenment. I doubt they were teaching heliocentrism and the scientific method.
- pezezin 6y agoAccording to official records, the Spanish Inquisition tried 150 000 people, and only 2% resulted in death sentences, so that's 3 000 executions over 350 years of history. According to Aztec records, for the consecration of the Great Pyramid of Tenochtitlan, 84 000 people were sacrificed IN FOUR DAYS. You can't even begin to compare the numbers. Many historians agree that the reason a small number of Spanish soldiers could conquer the big Aztec empire is because they could forge alliances with the neighbouring tribes that were completely fed up with them. The Aztec were the Nazis of their time.
- devb 6y agoThose are not accurate numbers. Where did you find them?
- pezezin 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Inquisition#Death_tolls_and_sentenced https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Inquisition#Death_toll... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_sacrifice_in_Aztec_culture#Scope_of_human_sacrifice_in_Aztec_culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_sacrifice_in_Aztec_cultu... You can find plenty of sources there.
- nudpiedo 6y agoRome was at its most 1 Million inhabitants, but since its fall due the Asian and African invasions all cities were constrained in size and development as they needed walls and larger amounts of defensive architecture/design