5 ms·
This is pretty much the argument I always made to crypto evangelists who touted cryptocurrencies as existing "outside the reach of government": governments can
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
This is pretty much the argument I always made to crypto evangelists who touted cryptocurrencies as existing "outside the reach of government": governments can pretty much make anything they want to illegal.
Yes, on some level this would be basically impossible to enforce (you could always transfer your currency to a new "brain wallet" where you just memorized the key words), but on the other, it would mean actually buying anything with crypto, or exchanging it to fiat, would put one at great legal jeopardy.
- smoldesu 6y agoAgain, this only really applies if they catch you. I agree with most of what you're saying, but a law like this presupposes that their government can catch you while exchanging it, which is pretty damn hard with most crypto. This is one of those "broken tail-light" laws like piracy, where they basically use it as an excuse to double-charge criminals who get caught transacting with dirty crypto.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoTechnology rarely wins against policy. The government can and does use force. It’s no skin off their back to lock you up for a few years of they suspect you’ve got money you’re not “sharing” with them. In America all they have to do is ask you if you have crypto, and you tell the truth or risk going to jail.
- fredfoobar 6y agoI'm not sure what you base "Technology rarely wins against policy" on. There was a huge war on drugs in America, but people figured how to grow pot indoors, and the dark market thrived, you can even buy drugs off the internet and have it delivered to your home.
- coliveira 6y agoYou mean, gangsters thrived. You'd you want to be a gangster?
- fredfoobar 6y agoI will not be, but some people might. Please consider the history of the world.
- Rule35 6y agoIn a world where that simply means being able to flee with your assets, yes. I wouldn't want to be anything else.
- fredfoobar 6y agoDid you read the article? "In India, despite government threats of a ban, transaction volumes are swelling and 8 million investors now hold 100 billion rupees ($1.4 billion) in crypto-investments, according to industry estimates." All they will end up doing is push crypto into the dark markets. They simply do not have the capacity (or are sophisticated enough) to go after the crypto holders.
- ketamine__ 6y agoWithout a fiat off ramp trading crypto becomes less attractive as a speculative investment.
- coliveira 6y agoPeople have always been able to trade illicit products. The biggest example is drug trafficking. Would you like to become a drug trafficker? Similarly, you may be able to buy cryptocurrency, but if the government doesn't want it you'll be a law breaker.
- fredfoobar 6y agoI will not, but some one will and they'll sell it for a premium [1]. 1: https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/bitcoin-is-trading-at-a-46-premium-on-luno-nigeria-after-central-bank-ban-2021-02-26 https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/bitcoin-is-trading-at-a-46-p...
- rawtxapp 6y agoOne key difference is drugs are physical products, you can be "caught" with it, whereas cryptocurrency is completely virtual. Unless you're caught at exchange time, you could be walking around with millions of dollars worth of crypto around and no one would know.
- thethimble 6y agoYou could use the same argument for digital piracy. There’s countless examples of people who have been caught and penalized for piracy.
- Rule35 6y agoThink of all the Jewish gold the Nazis wouldn't have stolen, or even detected, had it been converted into crypto with a passphrase. You buy it covertly when trouble looms and cash it in once in a safe country. The big problem is government is trying to block, capital flight, can't be stopped. Hopefully this eliminates some of the governmental excesses as they lose their monopoly powers, even if only slightly. Haters: It's not my fault if you don't know your history. Jews were an attractive scapegoat because they were rich. If they suddenly didn't have any money they wouldn't have been worth 1/10th the effort. If they could have taken their assets across the border covertly they could have fled sooner and with a guaranteed safe landing spot. I know people whose family didn't flee (and died for it) because of trying to protect the family legacy.