5 ms·
India to propose cryptocurrency ban, penalising miners, traders -source
- systemvoltage 6y agoThis is huge. India is 6th largest economy in the world and 3rd largest by purchasing parity.
- 1996 6y agoNo it's not huge Indians will keep their crypto, and wait for either 1) the supreme court to strike down this law 2) a new government to repeal this law. The cat is out the bag. Politicians in every country like money. They will try to appeal to the populace by pretending to fight crypto ("it's bad for the environment!") while knowing its advantages and trying to keep them for themselves
- xwolfi 6y agoYeah, I can picture the dude trying to make the national grid something else than a bitcoin input stream... Crypto isnt bad for the environment, it s more terrible for energy efficiency. I d rather spend what miners spend on an entire justice / police / law system to ensure contracts are trusted and enforced. The one thing that is sure here is that when people try to collect on their newfoubd wealth, there might be some price pressure making everyone poor again.
- fredfoobar 6y agoHow can you convert excess electricity from a hydroelectric power station (which the downstream grid can't handle) into energy for justic/police/law systems? I'm curious.
- geswit2x 6y ago>”excess electricity from a hydroelectric power station” Amazing, the excess is the same size as consumption in Sweden. https://cbeci.org/cbeci/comparisons https://cbeci.org/cbeci/comparisons
- fredfoobar 6y agopower generation is a local phenomena, there are many such stranded/renewable sources of energy. I recommend reading this article: https://www.coindesk.com/frustrating-maddening-all-consuming-bitcoin-energy-debate https://www.coindesk.com/frustrating-maddening-all-consuming...
- bitexploder 6y agoAnd to try and control their monetary policy. They mostly fear what can happen to their central banks of crypto takes off and they don’t have a “handle” in it.
- systemvoltage 6y agoSure it won't change for individuals but if you're a business and want to accept Bitcoin, it will be flat out illegal.
- 1996 6y agoMany businesses are moving to digital only. A digital-only business accepting only crypto will avoid taxes AND have it hold appreciate. Personally, I'm waiting for an crypto-based onlyfan: it's the perfect niche: performers will decide if they want to convert to fiat, or keep their hold for purchases the government may dislike (like drugs: dead drop are an ideal use of crypto) or cashing it abroad like in lavish amenities that cater to a lucky few and only take crypto (yes, they already exist, and I can only predict them becoming more accessible) There is a parallel economy emerging. You can deny it, but it's happening.
- wincy 6y agoOoh doesn’t this provide a legitimate reason to hold Monero? So maybe this will expedite crypto currencies that are intentionally difficult to track.
- lordofgibbons 6y agoThis is exactly the perfect use-case for Monero. A transparent ledger (like BTC & ETH) could very well lead to serious legal trouble. Unfortunately, fiat on-ramp/off-ramp will still be an issue. Not impossible to overcome, but certainly a huge hindrance to crypto adoption in India.
- fredfoobar 6y agoThe problem with Monero is the lack of auditability (of token supply), no one knows if there was an accidental bug in the code that is inflating the supply.
- lordofgibbons 6y agoWe indirectly do know. How does an inflation bug get created? There's either a big in the underlying theory, or there's an implementation bug. Both of those aspects (theory & implementation) have been audited multiple times by some of the foremost experts in cryptography.
- gruez 6y agoafaik that's zcash not monero. monero works like most other blockchains except it has decoy inputs/outputs, but at the end of the day inputs=outputs so it's trivial to verify no inflation happened.
- ketamine__ 6y ago> Unfortunately, fiat on-ramp/off-ramp will still be an issue. It's a huge problem but not for the wealthy.
- smoldesu 6y agoIndia's government is due for a reckoning. The reckless behavior of their conservative representatives has crossed several lines, and I'm surprised more people aren't talking about it. If they don't correct course, I think they're going to become even more hermited than they already are, which only gives their government more power to oppress theological, racial and political minorities. Hindu nationalism should be stopped before it causes more harm than it already has.
- leereeves 6y agoHow is this related to Hindu nationalism?
- smoldesu 6y agoIt's a demonstration of the power that conservative and traditionalist interests hold in India. Just this month they threatened to arrest Twitter and Facebook employees for not censoring their platforms, so hopefully this helps foster a discussion about the political happenings over there.
- modified001 6y agoBeing conservative does not mean being a hindu nationalist
- lordofgibbons 6y agoI'm not sure why you're trying to refute this.. I don't think Modi & co themselves would deny they're Hindu nationalists
- smoldesu 6y agoSure, but being a Hindu nationalist does make you a conservative.
- SilverRed 6y agoMore people aren't talking about it because they don't know or understand what is going on. I only know about the Indian governments corruption because I worked with an Indian programmer who would talk about it. The majority are busy trying to keep up to date with what their own government is doing.
- tomdell 6y ago“ The senior official told Reuters, however, that the plan is to ban private crypto-assets while promoting blockchain - a secure database technology that is the backbone for virtual currencies but also a system that experts say could revolutionise international transactions.” Flashback to a couple years ago when “blockchain experts” proliferated to attempt to apply the technology to seemingly every domain, benefit or no.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThis is pretty much the argument I always made to crypto evangelists who touted cryptocurrencies as existing "outside the reach of government": governments can pretty much make anything they want to illegal. Yes, on some level this would be basically impossible to enforce (you could always transfer your currency to a new "brain wallet" where you just memorized the key words), but on the other, it would mean actually buying anything with crypto, or exchanging it to fiat, would put one at great legal jeopardy.
- smoldesu 6y agoAgain, this only really applies if they catch you. I agree with most of what you're saying, but a law like this presupposes that their government can catch you while exchanging it, which is pretty damn hard with most crypto. This is one of those "broken tail-light" laws like piracy, where they basically use it as an excuse to double-charge criminals who get caught transacting with dirty crypto.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoTechnology rarely wins against policy. The government can and does use force. It’s no skin off their back to lock you up for a few years of they suspect you’ve got money you’re not “sharing” with them. In America all they have to do is ask you if you have crypto, and you tell the truth or risk going to jail.
- fredfoobar 6y agoI'm not sure what you base "Technology rarely wins against policy" on. There was a huge war on drugs in America, but people figured how to grow pot indoors, and the dark market thrived, you can even buy drugs off the internet and have it delivered to your home.
- coliveira 6y agoYou mean, gangsters thrived. You'd you want to be a gangster?
- ianai 6y agoSeems like a sign crypto might actually welcome. “First they call you fools then they call you an enemy” or something like that.
- roflc0ptic 6y agohttps://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/trapped-priors-as-a-basic-problem https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/trapped-priors-as-a-ba...
- xwolfi 6y agoElizabeth Holmes, a few weeks before the collapse of her ponzi fraud ?
- fredfoobar 6y agoComparing bitcoin to Theranos is just silly.
- arcadeparade 6y agoThis is the 10th time in 3 years I've read this story. It won't be banned.
- trhway 6y agoRelated is how mining operations are hunted down in Abhasia. Hitting at mining, the backbone of cryptocurrency decentralization and independence, is an interesting approach in taking crypto under control (the PoW I mean as the PoS is much easy for governments to control naturally).
- fredfoobar 6y agoPoS is not as good as you make it seem. It will create an unbalanced system where the "rich" people get to control the system, this is not what bitcoin is about.
- Rule35 6y agoAnd it'll make a currency easier to control by the authorities. With Ethereum if the feds seize someone's coins they can stake them easily, and with a few seizures could easily have a plurality of the power without spending money. On BTC to control the network they'd actually have to consume more than half as much electricity as Sweden to do so which would be much easier to detect and interfere with.
- thevardanian 6y agoThe recent interview with Nirmala Sitharaman, the current Finance Minister of India, claims otherwise in an interview given yesterday. Here's the interview: https://youtu.be/kHYQ730R-aA?t=1855 https://youtu.be/kHYQ730R-aA?t=1855 So I don't know who's more senior than the FM of India that Reuters is getting their info from.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sn_master 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Indian_banknote_demonetisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Indian_banknote_demonetis... Is a major reason why Indians should trust crypto more. The government can't just make their crypto worthless literally overnight.
- thevardanian 6y agoThat's also an argument for why the government should support btc/blockchain technologies, instead of banning it. Transactions can be open for everyone to see, and therefore easier to audit/account for unaccounted cash and if they're being used or not.
- sn_master 6y agoyes, except for when it's fraud to hide illegal government trades. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/venezuela-petro-cryptocurrency-bolivar-scam https://www.wired.co.uk/article/venezuela-petro-cryptocurren...
- dang 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25970101 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25970101