4 ms·
HIPPA is going to lead to a lot of deaths, but you'll never be able to prove it. If Doctors and Nurses aren't allowed to hear about patients after they transit
by mikewarot 6y ago
HIPPA is going to lead to a lot of deaths, but you'll never be able to prove it. If Doctors and Nurses aren't allowed to hear about patients after they transition to another floor, department, facility, how are they supposed to have the feedback required to improve the standards of care?
ER staff used to keep tabs on their patients with other staff, to see how they were doing, and now they aren't allowed to do so. It's the road to hell paved with good intentions.
- cjcampbell 6y agoCitations would be helpful for such a claim. I work with HIPAA daily, and while I agree that it has a lot of problems, the one you identify here would be an issue of misguided hospital policy. The hospitals would be absolutely within their rights to allow care teams to follow up with patients as they transition. Now I could easily imagine HIPAA being used as a scapegoat for a set of restrictive policies that are actually being driven by other incentives.
- mikewarot 6y agoI said at the outset it could never be proven. There will never be anything to cite, just a continuing trend towards mediocre medical practice in the USA. I'm not a medical person, but have had family in that role. They couldn't comment on it, but I sure can. Informal discussion of patients has been stopped. The feedback channels that allow for discovery of subtle problems and their solutions have been removed. ER staff used to visit their patients, and keep in touch with them, this stopped with HIPPA. This is dehumanizing. Imagine if developers weren't ever allowed to discuss bugs in their programs, unless they were actively working on the same bug? Think of how much that would kill productivity. What if we weren't allowed to discuss any software or OS we currently don't have a license to use? That's about how strict HIPPA is when it comes to discussing patients, at least as implemented by Hospitals. It is far far safer for them to shut all talk about patients down, in terms of patient satisfaction, lawyers, lawsuits and fines.
- watertom 6y agoUnless you work in a hospital and experience the rules first hand I suggest you remember what you were taught in kindergarten, do repeat things you’ve been told because they might not be true. I work in a hospital and I’ve never seen anything remotely like what you described. Our hospital has some of the most sophisticated monitoring systems available for inappropriate patient information access.
- deathanatos 6y agoI think you missed a rather crucial "not" in that first paragraph.
- mikewarot 6y agoIf you see a patient in the ER, and something you did causes an effect a week later, how does your facility enable to you learn about it?
- light_hue_1 6y agoYou don't have experience with HIPAA, and what you're describing is not at all true. > Informal discussion of patients has been stopped. The feedback channels that allow for discovery of subtle problems and their solutions have been removed. No way. I work with hospitals, there are plenty of feedback channels and cases get discussed at length. HIPAA does nothing at all to stop any communication or data sharing that is beneficial for patient safety. > ER staff used to visit their patients, and keep in touch with them, this stopped with HIPPA. This is dehumanizing. This is not at all true. > Imagine if developers weren't ever allowed to discuss bugs in their programs, unless they were actively working on the same bug? Think of how much that would kill productivity. Hospitals literally do these kinds of debriefs all the time. HIPAA does nothing to stop them at all. > It is far far safer for them to shut all talk about patients down, in terms of patient satisfaction, lawyers, lawsuits and fines. You totally misunderstood HIPAA, what it regulates, and how it regulates. It in no way shuts down conversations about patients. I deal with HIPAA-protected data and compliance all the time, I have no idea where you got this impression, but it was not from a doctor.
- Spooky23 6y agoThat has nothing at all to do with HIPAA. The standards of care in many hospitals are really awful, but incompetence isn’t correlated with overly aggressive information policy.
- SkyPuncher 6y agoI worked with HIPAA and am married to a physician. What he claimed isn't possible is entirely possible. You are allowed to follow patient. You are allowed to track outcomes. If a patient isn't actually in actually in your care, there are HIPAA defined means for reviewing cases for quality control.
- claytongulick 6y agoHIPAA specifically states that provider to provider disclosure of PHI does not require patient consent.
- 1996 6y agoAnd on the opposite side, I would love it if I could have hospitals destroy all my records as soon as I leave, because I value my privacy more than their fetishist interest in collecting information that would put google to shame. After trying in vain, I've realized it's fighting windmills on an uphill battle, an I just do medical tourism. No records, paid in cash, in a different country each time
- watertom 6y agoHospitals wish they could destroy your data as well, state laws dictate that hospitals and doctors retain the data, in some states for as long as 15 years. Hospitals would love to treat you as new patient every time through the door, that way it’s your responsibility to inform them of everything and anything that might impact care, it would eliminate a ton of liability for the hospital. Start writing you state government officials and get your laws changed. If worked for a social networking company, and I work for a hospital, you are a fool if you think hospitals have more data. At the social networking company we knew about all you health issues, we knew about your affairs, your spouses affairs, everything you’ve bought in the last 10 years, we knew if your children were actually yours, everything your children were up to, we ankles to n all your text messages, all those years their chatting you platforms, we had reciprocal agreements with them all. We knew everything you ever searched for, every porn site you visited, all your fetish’s, how much you made, your bank amounts. EVERYTHING.
- mikewarot 6y ago
- SkyPuncher 6y agoThis comment demonstrates a lack of understanding of HIPAA. All of what you described is allowed under HIPAA. It happens every day.
- primitivesuave 6y agoThis is a very misinformed comment. I suggest you talk to pretty much anyone who works in healthcare before fabricating rhetoric about how the system works.
- mikewarot 6y agoThis thread represents a failure to communicate, please allow me to restate and clarify. I followed up with my unnamed family who are in the medical world, to see if I was wrong (as the comments here so loudly proclaimed). I was told that I was generally correct and they shared my concern. It appears I didn't express myself clearly enough, and other people weren't charitable enough in their reading of what I said to allow the benefit of the doubt. I'll restate things, now that I've seen a day worth of feedback, as I'm interested in the truth, and not being right, I hope you'll allow this. My observation is that the behavior of my family members has changed because of HIPPA. Long term follow up of former patients, seems to have been completely shut down by HIPPA and the way the medical industrial complex interpreted it. Informal learning of interesting cases (corner cases) seems to be another victim of HIPPA. As a patient, I value privacy. I am concerned that the proverbial pendulum has swung too far, and we are cutting off a valuable (out of band signaling) mechanism for improving the practice of medicine. Did I explain it better this time? What could I have stated differently, or more explicitly? Thank you all for your time and attention.