4 ms·
Land mines exist for a reason, as weapons, they have advantages and disadvantages. The advantage is that you can set them up and get automatic area denial: if
by samatman 6y ago
Land mines exist for a reason, as weapons, they have advantages and disadvantages.
The advantage is that you can set them up and get automatic area denial: if your enemy (or your friends, or civilians, or large dogs, or cattle) enter the minefield, they're going to die or at least be mutilated.
Obviously, some of that is disadvantage. The biggest disadvantage is that they're cheap, and buried in the ground, so it's tempting to leave them there, especially if you happen to lose the conflict. So they continue to kill people long after there are no enemies left.
Automated gunbots have the same advantage as landmines. They share a shade of the minor disadvantage, namely they can't reliably tell enemies from friendlies or civilians. But neither can a grunt in a machine gun emplacement.
They are expensive, and above the ground, so there's no world in which civilian children, years after the conflict, are shot to death while playing in a field.
So if these are the "next landmine" I say: good. We would all love to live in the world in which there is no war, but, we don't. Until we do, we will need the weapons of war.
- lambda_obrien 6y agoThat's the exist everyone gives: "everybody else is doing it" It's still immoral.
- samatman 6y agoWell that's just like, your opinion, man. In a vacuum, with perfectly spherical frictionless humans, sure. In the world we live in, a technology which replaces landmines, and kills fewer noncombatants, is an improvement which results in less civilian death. That's moral in my playbook.
- lambda_obrien 6y agoMoral would be not killing other humans for power, resources, etc. I'm comfortable with my beliefs, and I understand your position as well. I personally understand the need for a military, but there are some weapons I wouldn't have been comfortable using when I was a military officer. Luckily, I have no part in those decisions today and I can share my beliefs without any risk to anyone else, "enemy" or otherwise.