3 ms·
Online and local purchasing do compete on the same ground. A local store uses CT state services and pays taxes to support them. An online store does not use CT
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Online and local purchasing do compete on the same ground. A local store uses CT state services and pays taxes to support them. An online store does not use CT state services and does not pay taxes to support them.
Similarly, many companies use Microsoft software and pay license fees. My company does not.
Would it be "more capitalist" if we were forced to pay a Microsoft tax, to eliminate the "market distortion" of using lower cost software?
- crasshopper 15y agoyummyfajitas, I think by "more capitalist" jbooth means "more competitive". You are obviously right that forcing companies to use higher-cost inputs is inefficient, but taxes are not an input -- they're a necessary burden meant to be shared. To take an extreme example, using a tax shelter could lower the cost of a company's services while decreasing the efficiency of the economy.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoOf course taxes pay for inputs - the inputs are public goods. Taxes are compulsory only to prevent freeloading - you might enjoy the benefits of the CT state police without paying for them. Amazon doesn't enjoy the benefit of the CT state police. Hence, it is not efficient to force them to pay for it. A tax shelter is only inefficient if it allows a company to consume services while forcing others to pay for them. If a company does not consume those services, it is inefficient to force the company to pay for them.
- crasshopper 15y agoyummyfajitas, can you give a real-world example of a tax haven which is Pareto equivalent or superior to the company paying its taxes? Also, who says Amazon pays the tax? Insert elasticity argument.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIn the real world nothing is Pareto equivalent or superior to anything else, except maybe for gifts given to hermits. Pareto efficiency is a purely theoretical construct.
- crasshopper 15y agoYou're dodging the essence of the question. Give us one real world example of a case where tax evasion has been A Good Thing. yummyfajitas, it frankly sounds like you're econtrolling. I looked at your profile and you seem like a smart, educated person, so I'll respond in good faith so you can see how weak your arguments sound. > Taxes are compulsory only to prevent freeloading Says who? This sounds like a stylised model from Econ 101. > A tax shelter is only inefficient if it allows a company to consume services while forcing others to pay for them. Prove it. > Amazon doesn't enjoy the benefit of the CT state police. I don't use the Merritt Parkway but that doesn't mean I don't owe tax on it. > Pareto efficiency is a purely theoretical construct. This from someone who just boiled the entire political economy of Connecticut down to a prisoner's dilemma? > If a company does not consume those services, it is inefficient to force the company to pay for them. What is your reasoning? Perhaps you are sharing these thoughts before giving them a sound-check? I don't mean to be rude but what you're saying doesn't make sense coming from someone of your educational background.
- SamReidHughes 15y agoLiterally every case of tax evasion under a government where the tax rate is too high and the marginal utility of higher taxes is negative.
- crasshopper 15y agoCan you give a real example of a case where this has actually happened? (by marginal utility I assume you mean marginal revenue; governments do not have utility)