3 ms·
This really sounds like late Communist Czechoslovakia to me, where lying at school was an obvious norm, everyone knew what was publicly unspeakable and which on
by inglor_cz 6y ago
This really sounds like late Communist Czechoslovakia to me, where lying at school was an obvious norm, everyone knew what was publicly unspeakable and which one of your colleagues was a snitch.
The difference is that by late 1980s there were few true believers. Those who held the power and dictated the indoctrination standards were mostly tired pragmaticists who were in power to be in power and little else. There were some people brainwashed enough to believe in theory of Communism, but (unlike in the early 1950s, when Communism intrigued a lot of young intellectuals), they were mostly the stupid ones.
It is horribly fascinating for me to see this replayed in America of all places, but with a distributed, socially enforced political policing instead of a powerful secret police like StB and Stasi. Some people seem to have a powerful authoritarian impulse in them. And obviously they have found a way to crush dissent even without a large governmental oppressive apparatus.
The trouble is that things have changed. If you dissented in Communism or doubted its value, the Western world was an obvious, freer and richer alternative. Where will current and future American dissenters find an alternative to a toxic feed of critical race theory being elevated to a state creed?
The main opposing power is (shudder) China. This really feels like a choice between Sauron and Saruman. I am not sure if Europe can escape from the roof of Isengard, like Gandalf once did. At least plenty of us see the reality for what it is - an ugly attempt to build a racialized dystopia on a base of post-BLM moral panic.
Edit: now sitting at -2 without even an attempt at a rebuttal.
- goatinaboat 6y agoThe difference is that by late 1980s there were few true believers. This was one of the striking things about the collapse of the USSR, former KGB, the supposed final bastion of defence of the Soviet system, became hyper-capitalist oligarchs overnight seemingly without skipping a beat. We see the same thing happening where the one-time stronghold of enlightenment and liberalism doesn't believe in it either. What's also strange is that there are many people in the US with lived experience of the Soviet system, and they are sounding the alarm that what's happening now leads to some very dark places, and their voices are being completely ignored or even shouted down.
- drno123 6y agoI grew up in communist Yugoslavia, and it is obvious both to you and me where this is leading to. You get downvotes from people who were sold a lie.
- inglor_cz 6y agoZdravo, brate. We the former Eastern Europeans feel like Cassandras these days.
- the_why_of_y 6y agoIs your argument that the ethnic conflict and genocide in several former Yugoslav republics in the 1990s was caused by an education system indoctrinating people with anti-racist attitudes? I didn't grow up in Yugoslavia, so please elaborate a bit how that worked, because I don't understand.
- drno123 6y agoNot anti-racist but anti-capitalist. In Yugoslavia no one could own a business that employs more than 8 people, so all bigger companies were owned by the government, because anti-capitalist. As a result, management of all but micro business was selected not based on ones success and merit, but based on political connections, and in addition to that, there was no competition. The products mostly sucked and companies were performing badly. The economy was mostly surviving on international loans, and when this stopped, as a result, we had enormous inflation in the mid and late 80s. Food became scarce, I remember one time when you could buy only 1kg of sugar per household. Electricity was also scarce and there were periodic blackouts. Under such economic conditions, all it took is few “charismatic” sociopaths to start two bloody wars (the first one being in Croatia and Bosnia between 1991-1995 and the second one in Kosovo 1998-1999). Again, anti-racism has nothing to do with it, and I am appaled at how you have tried to mark me as a racist.
- the_why_of_y 6y agoThanks for your answer, which I've upvoted. I'm sorry that I caused you offense - I don't know much about Yugoslavia, so I couldn't parse your comment as referring to anything else but the wars of the 1990s, so I couldn't get your point in the context of an article concerned primarily with anti-racism.
- tekproxy 6y agoCommunists hate historical evidence that their theories are ruinous.
- dfraser992 6y agoI'd upvote you if I could... I think maybe one has to be old enough (I'm GenX) to see how this 'wokeness' is in part a cover story for some sort of authoritarianism coming from the left. i.e. the "Soviet Union" is not merely history to me, unlike millennials. Is all this in reaction to - or in conjunction with - the growing authoritarianism coming from the right? I don't know. I am in all in favor of examining how America has failed Blacks, Native Americans, the working class left in the dust by uber-capitalism (aka Ronald Reagan and all that BS) etc, but what is going on now is becoming problematic aka a mindless ideology. If you pair this with [0], then it seems the Elites [motivated by power, social dominance, etc] have figured out how to leverage entirely valid ways of looking at the world, but not the only ways created by the Gentry into mechanisms / an ideology with which to control society and those in lower social classes. Sounds much like China's Cultural Revolution... Having the Elites of a society be in thrall to any sort of ideology is a bad idea and so having all these students of elite super-upper class schools on the way to the Ivy League being turned into mindless robots will end up badly. Of course, America is the Greatest Country in History (tm) and so having some sort of American fascism hit at the same time as some sort of Cultural Revolution is to be expected </s>. The 2020s are going be a mess. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20210225030540/https://www.indiepf.com/michael-o-churchs-theory-of-3-class-ladders-in-america-archive/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210225030540/https://www.indie...
- legacynl 6y ago> Edit: now sitting at -2 without even an attempt at a rebuttal. Ah poor criticized you. The reason why you're getting downvoted (and the reason why nobody bothers to write a reply), is because the analogy you try to pull is obviously wrong, and it makes you come across as a troll. Society has always ostracized people that do morally egregious stuff. The concept of 'Cancel Culture' has always existed in the form of social stigmatization, laws, religious rules (10 commandments, etc), etc. The only difference is that now racism is seen on the same level as something like being a rapist. Also why would anybody be against anti-racist sentiment? Do you think anti-racism will come at some cost? I really would like an answer to this. > The main opposing power is (shudder) China. This really feels like a choice between Sauron and Saruman. So you actually think China and US are about the same on level of oppressiveness? Really?
- ceilingcorner 6y agoYup. Americans really ought to spend more time studying the USSR and related states. This stuff isn't new and it doesn't end well.
- inglor_cz 6y agoThis is a well-written article by Natan Sharansky on the realities of having to be a "double-thinker" in the former USSR. https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/natan-sharansky-doublethink https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/nat...