4 ms·
I'm sorry, but I refuse to feel guilty and I don't see why anyone should. When I go to the store and buy some tuna I expect that it was responsibly fished. If i
by gambiting 6y ago
I'm sorry, but I refuse to feel guilty and I don't see why anyone should. When I go to the store and buy some tuna I expect that it was responsibly fished. If it wasn't then it's the fault of our government and regulation, regular customer shouldn't be worried about that. The same with meat - when I buy some I expect that animals weren't abused and beaten at farms, if they were then there's an issue in the system.
- jMyles 6y ago> When I go to the store and buy some tuna I expect that it was responsibly fished. Why do you expect this, when there is evidence to the contrary? > regular customer shouldn't be worried about that Nobody is asking you to single-handedly save the oceans. Start by installing Seafood Watch and do your best to select a sustainable option any time you're eating seafood. > If it wasn't then it's the fault of our government and regulation This is why crony capitalism is forever bound to a love affair with the state; it relieves us of any responsibility for building real communities. Governments have never - and I believe will never - regulate society into behavior befitting the respect due to the Earth. We have given profiteers and their lobbyists access to a single point of failure; we can't be surprised when they utilize it.
- graeme 6y agoThat’s kind of a silly assumption frankly. Even on fish cans in the grocery store some advertise themselves as sustainably fished with certifications, and some don’t. Some egg cartons advertise themselves as “free range” and some don’t. Some meat advertises itself as “grass fed” and others don’t. The products themselves are telling you there are a variety of production standards and it is almost willful blindness to say you believe there is nothing going on because there ought to be nothing going on. You could make an analogous argument about gasoline “Look if this was harming the atmosphere why would governments allow it to be sold? I refuse to feel guilty”
- sokoloff 6y agoGrass-fed beef is advertised that way primarily for nutritional and taste claims and to support/explain the higher prices charged.
- graeme 6y agoThat’s one reason. It’s also widely known it is healthier for the cattle and has them out on pasture rather than in cages. The reason people argue the meat is more nutritious is because the cows are healthier via eating their natural diet. Corn diets cause health problems and bacterial infections requiring antibiotics. Some of this will literally be on the websites of farms selling pastured beef. It’s not a big secret and if you seek out pastured beef it’s likely familiar. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2001/05/010511074623.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2001/05/010511074623.h...
- sorokod 6y agoBut you (plural form if you wish) are part of the system. Without you the system would not exist.
- usrusr 6y agoTuna is hunted wildlife, an international commons. It's clearly evident that no regulation will happen anytime soon that will actually make a difference. If you buy it, you are part of the problem, either ignorantly or knowingly. Occasionally I find myself in some gastronomy setting were nothing in the menu appeals to me other than the dishes containing tuna and then I eat it, and enjoy it a lot. It happens less than once a year. (I do actually share your position wrt farmed meat, those farms are infinitely more regulateable than international fishing and I think we should regulate it hard, hard enough to solve big parts of the inherent inefficiency of putting nutrients though animals before they reach a human mouth by price)
- gambiting 6y agoI'm sorry, but tuna being farmed in international waters shouldn't be an obstacle. In all EU countries and UK there are quotas of what a fishing vessel can bring into port. So it doesn't matter where the fish was actually caught, if the country ran out of annual quota for tuna for instance, then no fishing vessel can bring any tuna to any port. It's not an insurmountable problem.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 6y agoAgreeing on sustainable quotas apparently is. Whaling wasn't stopped (mostly stopped) thanks to people insisting on buying whale products until regulation happens.
- ____throwaway6 6y ago> I go to the store and buy some tuna I expect that it was responsibly fished. If it wasn't then it's the fault of our government and regulation I eat canned tuna also, but that logic doesn’t work generally. By the same logic you could say that if you could buy a BB gun, it’s ok to shoot people with it, because it must not be harmful. Come to think of it, that’s what kids did to each other when I was growing up.
- gambiting 6y agoBut a BB gun specifically comes with a warning not to shoot people because it might cause harm, not to mention that regulations around fake and/or air guns are pretty hardcore already. To maybe give another example - as a consumer I shouldn't care if a phone I'm buying was made using child labour or not - I expect the authorities in every country involved in its production to enforce laws against child labour.
- whatastory 6y agoYou can expect anything you want. Doesn’t make your expectations realistic or absolve you of responsibility, though. Nobody’s going to step in and change things if it’s easy money and people will keep buying it and shifting blame. It doesn’t work that way.
- shlant 6y ago"The consumer is completely to blame" is definitely ridiculous. "As a consumer I have no responsibility in what products I choose to buy" is equally ridiculous.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y ago"There's an issue in the system" doesn't absolve you of responsibility. Right now, unless you take it on yourself to do some research and pay a premium, you know for a fact that any tuna you buy will have been irresponsibly fished and any meat you buy will come from animals that were abused. That is why they're so cheap and everyone knows it. You cannot "expect" anything when you know the opposite for a fact. You can want it, but evidently not enough to lift a finger. I wonder what you would do if you lived in a slave state or fascist regime. Would you buy slave-made goods and justify it because, sure, it's evil, but it's not your job to fix?
- 0xbadcafebee 6y ago> I'm sorry, but I refuse to feel guilty Then you're not sorry. > When I go to the store and buy some tuna I expect that it was responsibly fished. If it wasn't then it's the fault of our government and regulation, regular customer shouldn't be worried about that. How do you think regulations come to be? If a consumer wants a product, a company finds a way to provide it. The company will poison the land, sea and sky in order to provide it to you, they don't give a shit. The government allows it until the people demand regulations to stop it. But you are the people - if you don't want it stopped, it won't be. And so there are no regulations made. There is no parental overlord making sure that what you purchase is sustainable or cruelty-free. Sitting around saying "somebody should stop me from ruining the earth" doesn't actually make it happen. I know you don't want to have any personal responsibility or culpability for the shitty way the world works, but you do. Ultimately, you, and everyone like you, are the reason we can't have nice things.
- gambiting 6y ago>>Ultimately, you, and everyone like you, are the reason we can't have nice things. Because I expect to live in a country with a strong regulatory framework where if I buy something in a store I don't have to worry whether it was produced in an ethical way? You're right, I'm the problem. Thanks mate.
- 0xbadcafebee 6y agoYou've already admitted you won't lift a finger to actually help the situation. Why would you expect your government to do anything if they're made up of people like you? Do you believe all those government workers exist on some other plane of moral relativism? Or do you think that laws and regulations magically come into being, like the zeitgeist just wills regulations into place? The government does not sit around reading your mind and then make regulations to match it. Even if it could, it wouldn't. The government only creates a regulation when either a corporation or a very vocal coalition of people demand it. And those two parties are working against each other anyway, making it even less likely. I really don't know how to explain it in simple enough terms. If you don't care, then neither does the society, and thus the government. Ergo, people like you are the reason the regulations don't exist and aren't enforced when they do.
- TomSwirly 6y agoNo, just because there's no law against it doesn't make it morally right. > there's an issue in the system. But everyone else is just as apathetic as you, so there's no incentive to ever change anything. You say, "The government should ban this!" and the government says, "People are buying and eating this, so in a Democratic system we can't ban this!" You slough off responsibility on them - they slough it off on you - you all convince yourselves you have no possibility at all. Also - I'm curious - have you ever contacted your representatives? Asked them to do anything about it? I'm sure when the tuna finally goes, you'll say, "Yes, I ate tuna all my life, but I bear no responsibility - it's everyone else's fault."
- gambiting 6y ago>>No, just because there's no law against it doesn't make it morally right. Wait, are you replying to the right comment? >>Also - I'm curious - have you ever contacted your representatives? Asked them to do anything about it? Yes, I have. Have you? >>But everyone else is just as apathetic as you, so there's no incentive to ever change anything. Again, I feel like you're replying to the wrong comment. I feel like I live in a country with a very strong regulatory framework and things like fishing are treated very seriously with strong quotas on what can be caught not to overfish, and canned fish has to be clearly labeled where it came from and how it was caught. So I'm not sure which part of what I said comes across as apathetic to you. >>I'm sure when the tuna finally goes, you'll say, "Yes, I ate tuna all my life, but I bear no responsibility - it's everyone else's fault." I'll definitely say that it's the fault of the agencies tasked with protecting the flora and fauna that they are responsible for, not the consumers for eating tuna.
- SamBam 6y ago"I refuse to feel guilty. When I fill my Hummer at the pump, I expect it to be filled with renewable corn oil. If it isn't, there's an issue with the system."