4 ms·
>> A fair number of faculty, while appreciative of his contributions to the field, held him in low regard because he & some of his main "acolytes" systematicall
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
>> A fair number of faculty, while appreciative of his contributions to the
field, held him in low regard because he & some of his main "acolytes"
systematically worked to block any researchers in the U.S. working on ideas that
ran counter to his own. Meaning more than a generation or more of
advancement has stagnated in the US.
I've heard this about Chomsky before and I don't get it. It sounds like he's
criticised for doing what any researcher would do- defend his work and criticise
competing approaches. I know that's what I do and what everybody else I know
does (and has done to me too). Of course any researcher worth her salt will
defend her work and of course they will criticise competing approaches.
Robustly so. That is how research works and that is how researchers work.
He "systematically worked to block any researchers in the U.S. working on ideas
that ran counter to his own"? Yes, that's precisely what you do when you think
the other approach is rubbish, you fight to put it out like a fire that
threatens to burn down your beloved field. You only ever stop criticising
others' work and promoting your own ideas when you are 100% convinced -no doubts
at all- that it's your work that's flawed.
Otherwise, how does science advance? Nobody has the absolute truth in any
scientific question. Our best chance to know the truth is to try to formulate an
answer and then have everybody's answers duke it out, like pit fighters in Conan
the Barbarian. The alternative is to let your ideas go without putting up a
fight - but then you run the risk of letting ideas that are worse than yours
prevail. And I'm probably getting all this from Schopenhauer on the art of
dialectic, which I read a while ago, but this is how debates go. And science is
a debate. And if you're having a debate, it means there is disagreement- that's
the point of having a debate; and the point of having research: that we can't
agree about what the truth is in the first place. Otherwise, we wouldn't need
research.
So I think that those complaints are best explained as sour grapes by those who
failed to convince of the merit of their ideas, and blame Chomsky for doing his
job as a scientist better than them. Of course you're starting at a disadvantage
if you're going up against an established authority in your field, no less one
of the size of Chomsky, but that's exactly what everyone else spends all their
time trying to become, an established authority in their field. And they want
that so that they can defend their own ideas more easily. So that, too, is not
such a great piece of criticism.
- wrnr 6y agoThanks it is good to know there are still those who think there is a truth to be settled by politicking like real gentleman. Still I love how his favourite question of universal grammar was utterly sidelined when it was shown that problems of parser ambiguity also show up in the vision system, a much older neural structure.
- foldr 6y agoParser ambiguities have never really been a major focus of Chomsky’s research. He’s certainly never argued for the existence of UG on the basis of parser ambiguities.
- mistermann 6y agoWhat if some of the ideas that Chomsky "put out like a fire" were actually correct, and would have been discovered to be so if more time and (collaborative) effort had gone into them?
- DSingularity 6y agoAre you accusing his sincerity? The correctness of the ideas which failed to gain traction is irrelevant. The burden is on the authors of those works to explain and decent the merit of their ideas. If they failed to convince their peer reviewers then that is on them. Unless you are accusing the peer-reviewers of acting in bad-faith.
- mistermann 6y ago> Are you accusing his sincerity? No, I am pointing out the shortcomings in this statement: >> He "systematically worked to block any researchers in the U.S. working on ideas that ran counter to his own"? > Yes, that's precisely what you do when you think the other approach is rubbish, you fight to put it out like a fire that threatens to burn down your beloved field. You only ever stop criticising others' work and promoting your own ideas when you are 100% convinced -no doubts at all- that it's your work that's flawed. - > The correctness of the ideas which failed to gain traction is irrelevant. Do you perceive yourself to have knowledge of what difference an alternative outcome would have made in the world? > The burden is on the authors of those works to explain and decent the merit of their ideas. If they failed to convince their peer reviewers then that is on them. It is also "on" anyone else who would have been affected by good ideas not being "put out like a fire". Things that do not happen are not stored in your mind, therefore it is quite natural for them to not exert much influence on your thinking. > Unless you are accusing the peer-reviewers of acting in bad-faith. I have no knowledge of their actions and therefore no opinion, I am simply pointing out shortcomings in thinking.