4 ms·
> does that not mean there is no free will, and therefore that morality does not exist Or in other words, free will is necessary for morality to exist. I beg t
by visarga 6y ago
> does that not mean there is no free will, and therefore that morality does not exist
Or in other words, free will is necessary for morality to exist. I beg to differ.
Morality can be evaluated at population level - do the actions of an agent hurt or help the others? Punishment can be seen as simply compensating for bad influences in society.
If you look at game theory you can see how behavior relates to cooperation or betrayal, how these are also related to the context, and how society needs to weed out those who betray it.
- betwixthewires 6y agoWhat you're saying makes sense, but then you have to talk about words like "action", "agent", "punish". In my definition it is predicated on the idea of a person making deliberate action, yours is that an occurrence has a negative effect on people and so it's cause should be negated. Even if morality as you use it applies even without free will, the words you are using to describe the scenario imply another word, "decide". Without free will, can one be an agent without agency? Is an action an action or simply an occurrence? Can we even examine morality? We must decide first what to punish, then decide to punish. Or are these behaviors in some way predetermined as well? Was it predetermined for us to ponder whether this conversation was predetermined or not? Do you require the ability to make decisions in order to adapt to changing conditions? Without free will can we even talk about game theory? I mean, we can talk about whatever we want, but is the concept valid any longer?