3 ms·
Design For Reliability
- buescher 6y agoIt's wild to see electromigration and temperature-driven aging come back as a concern at today's dense process nodes. Pecht's landmark work in the early nineties mostly debunked the old handbook models that were based on those causes of failure. Most electronics will still fail due to overstress or mechanical fatigue from vibration or temperature cycling, of course, but it's really interesting to see these concerns return.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI'm glad to see this. Not sure if anyone's listening, though. Reliability and robustness seem to have fallen by the wayside, in a rush for money. One of my pet peeves, is Bluetooth devices that crap out, after a year. I've gone through quite a few expensive headsets, while my cheap exercise headsets have lasted for many years.
- mumblemumble 6y agoI don't think this is deliberate, but it seems that one of the big things that has changed as a result of the shortening of consumer product development cycles is that it sort of eliminates any feedback loop that might incentivize manufacturers to engineer for reliability. Why build a device that's designed to last for 10 years, when consumers are going to buy themselves a new one every year or two, regardless of whether the old one is still functional and meeting their needs?
- blacktriangle 6y agoThere's an ebb and flow to these things. If new technology is making my headset obsolete every year, designing a 10-year headset makes no sense. Once headset technology settles down and people realize they keep buying the same thing over and over, then the customer starts to value reliability more. Unfortunately customer behavior updating to the reality that underlying technology of a product has stopped evolving lags by a few years, but it happens.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoLike flatbed scanners. Most are still USB 2, and the resolution is still 600 X 600 (like it was ten years ago). I have an old HP that I got a decade ago, that basically still has the same specs as their current flagship.
- tablespoon 6y ago> There's an ebb and flow to these things. If new technology is making my headset obsolete every year, designing a 10-year headset makes no sense. Once headset technology settles down and people realize they keep buying the same thing over and over, then the customer starts to value reliability more. Unfortunately customer behavior updating to the reality that underlying technology of a product has stopped evolving lags by a few years, but it happens. However, business really like the income that comes from regular tech refreshes. Once technology stops making their products obsolete after N years, they'll often start designing them to reduce reliability (e.g. going for cheap parts that will fail faster) or incorporating planned obsolescence features. IIRC, this is what's happened to consumer printers and many types of home appliances.
- taxicabjesus 6y agoRecently my father had wifi problems at his house. I thought the smart thermostat had a firmware update that was flawed, resulting in it not staying on the network for more than a day. After a few months of this all the other devices started losing their wifi connections too. I replaced the Ubiquiti access point with a router flashed with ddwrt [0], and everything now works fine. Maybe a neighbor's wifi network started overlapping on the channel, but I think it most likely the access point just died. It was mounted where it got sun every morning, maybe the heat cycles accelerated the AP's aging? I bought a parts laptop off ebay to fix the broken hinge on the HP laptop I bought in the summer of 2012. After getting my laptop working, I figured the parts laptop would probably work if I bought a replacement "DC IN Power Jack". Glued the broken hinge back together, bought the jack off ebay, and poof "now I have two laptops". I put the second one on a network cable and used it as a media server. In recent months I've basically stopped using this laptop because the wifi is so unreliable. The donor laptop's wifi seems to be unreliable too. My 2012-2014 era Toshiba laptop usually works, but every so often its wifi craps out on me too. What's your experience with aging WiFi chips? The problem with trying to fix things is if you don't have the experience, tools, aptitude or a collection parts, fixing something is often a mission-impossible. It's usually easier to throw out the "broken laptop", when all the device actually needs is a replaceable part. (I'm going to ifixit to look at the repairability score before buying another laptop.) [0] https://openwrt.org/meta/infobox/broadcom_wifi https://openwrt.org/meta/infobox/broadcom_wifi - bought the router at a thrift store for $2, on account of it being listed as supported by ddwrt. ddwrt uses proprietary drivers and supports some routers with broadcom chips.
- buescher 6y agoChips - most chips - almost never fail from the aging mechanisms described in the article. The folks interviewed are not kidding when they are talking about applications with extended lifetimes past ten years and only seeing these issues at 28nm and below. In your typical laptop or whatever something else breaks first anyway. There is a lot else that can break in any piece of consumer electronics.