4 ms·
Yah, screw anyone who's on the leading edge of linguistic drift! After all, if someone doesn't properly use the second-person singular pronoun of yore, they're
by mlyle 6y ago
Yah, screw anyone who's on the leading edge of linguistic drift!
After all, if someone doesn't properly use the second-person singular pronoun of yore, they're an illiterate scoundrel! Language shouldn't change.
I think your argument has been decimated (which means reduced by a literal 10%; metaphorical and drifting meanings of words are bad!)
- CyberRabbi 6y agoI sincerely wish I understood what motivates so many people to defend poor language. Celebration for those who race to the bottom and condemnation of those who race to the top.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoWhat's wrong with this particular drift though? Presumably you don't hold that all linguistic drift is regrettable?
- CyberRabbi 6y agoI’ve made no claim about “linguistic drift,” and I’ve explained many times in this thread why “performant” is in poor taste.
- orf 6y agoThe point is that people do not view it as poor language, they understand that it's a protocol for communication and as such it evolves/shifts across time and particularly across generations (Emojis are a great example of this), and view people that look down upon others for relatively benign infractions upon the timeless holy grail that is The Way The English Language Should Be Used as rather pedantic idiots who often bring more disruption to a conversation than clarity. There is no race to the top or the bottom. There is no race at all. Looking down on someone for their preferred set of words and the way they use them will only make you look bad and at the end of the day prevents you from communicating effectively with other members of your species. You should work on that.
- fapjacks 6y agoHuh? I bet I could come up with a few words and a few different ways of using them that you'd look down on me for. I could probably do it in one word and one usage.
- mlyle 6y agoEven deliberately corrupting language can be joyous. My friends were all telling each other "chillax motherfuton" for awhile because of how it made another friend rage. :D
- orf 6y ago"relatively benign infractions" is the key part of my reply.
- fapjacks 6y agoYou're doing the same thing that other dude is doing; you just think you're better.
- CyberRabbi 6y agoNo I think I’ll continue to judge people for their behavior. I also look down on people when they use “ain’t” instead of “aren’t” or when they don’t correctly conjugate their verbs. Being prevented from communicating with people who fail to speak proper English has little practical downsides and many upsides. Looking bad to those who fail to speak proper English is probably more of an upside as well. An apparent failure to speak English well is indistinguishable from an inability to speak English well. Demonizing intolerance of poor English does not help to improve anyone’s ability to communicate precisely and efficiently, it just seems to make people feel better about themselves. There’s nothing wrong with setting high standards for people unless you dislike excellence.
- orf 6y agoIf you want to be guided on that lonely and cold road by nothing but a false sense of superiority then it ain't on me to stop you. Just don't be surprised when, or fail to realise why, people judge you right back for your behaviour.