3 ms·
> It is probably a good strategy to refuse to be talked into positions against your fundamental values by mere evidence. I'm joking but also serious. I believe
by roenxi 6y ago
> It is probably a good strategy to refuse to be talked into positions against your fundamental values by mere evidence. I'm joking but also serious.
I believe that too. There are some boxes so dangerous we need people not to open them even if they believe they should.
However there are a lot of things in the world that we can be wrong about. A strategy of "I'm going to use deontological reasoning" just means that we have to sort right from wrong by an evolutionary process over generations, getting to kids while they are young enough to be swayed, in a process that is a bit icky and disrespectful of people's beliefs. It would be better if people could be persuaded by evidence.
We don't get sewage, skyscrapers and subways by following our instincts or because some people somehow made them values. Everyone wants good sewage systems. The best parts of society come from following evidence and logic as best we are able - including, I point out, the legal system.
- philipkglass 6y agoHowever there are a lot of things in the world that we can be wrong about. A strategy of "I'm going to use deontological reasoning" just means that we have to sort right from wrong by an evolutionary process over generations, getting to kids while they are young enough to be swayed, in a process that is a bit icky and disrespectful of people's beliefs. It would be better if people could be persuaded by evidence. I don't think that you necessarily need to sway kids while they're young. 10 years ago there were no states in the US that had legalized recreational cannabis use for adults. Today there are 17, and I expect at least another 17 over the next decade. What changed? Attitudes shifted among all age groups. It didn't seem like a process of grandparents dying out and their grandchildren entering the voting booth. It didn't seem like an evidence based process either. I was well persuaded in the 1990s that the deleterious health effects and other negative externalities of cannabis use were no worse than those corresponding to alcohol. The historical example of Prohibition was more than enough evidence for me that fueling a black market was worse than letting adults impair themselves. I wonder why evidence didn't persuade people to change laws sooner, yet the shift happened far faster than generational replacement once it started. If anyone reading has a convincing model for how the cannabis attitude shift happened: does it only rationalize history, or does it also predict other things likely to change in the near future? There are a lot of ways we can turn past series of events into coherent stories. There are fewer that successfully foretell what happens in the next chapter.
- salawat 6y agoThe cannabis legalization happened because of two additional factors: A) Overincarceration of non-violent offenders B) the reveal of racist roots in the foundational war on drugs rhetoric (which led to more strict penalties for the use of crack [cheaper street drug], for instance, than straight cocaine [high-society, white-collar drug]). At least that seems to be the lynchpin from my point of view. It was always going to fail from mmy point of view since prohibitions in the U.S. don't have stellar records.
- smcameron 6y ago> There are some boxes so dangerous we need people not to open them even if they believe they should. Religion is several of those boxes, which have already been opened for centuries. Faith, (by which I mean deliberately attempting to believe something to a degree of certainty which exceeds what is warranted by the available evidence) is one of those boxes that should be sealed up and ejected into space, or at least made to be deemed immoral by the majority of people, since it obviously is immoral.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoFew people carry that definition of faith though, but many, especially during the French Revolution, felt as you do, and acted on it, not by ejecting religious people into space, but by gathering them together in barns and burning them in mass executions. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infernal_columns https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infernal_columns